{"items":[{"_id":"6afca5f8c78ea47caf09df33","referendumIndex":679,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23940595,"blockHash":"0x5c4239e834fe3650cd8bd179b3f290232b46274c80bb9bc2515c56ad0d81c4df","blockTime":1794942408000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","title":"Runtime Upgrade 2.5.3","content":"Upgrade all System chains to [Release 2.5.3](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/releases/tag/v2.5.3).\n\nWhitelisted by [#679](https://collectives.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/679).","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-11-17T19:06:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-11-17T19:14:20.397Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-17T21:58:48.000Z","state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"stateSort":1,"cid":"QmSKu6RBu4bck78apup2RwR1texD3xAzQKa14ZUkC22PDw","contentHash":"ace77f607625a4c2c24fce590e89bc4a","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":false,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6afca5f674667fceb6f9e0e1","referendumIndex":679,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23940595,"blockHash":"0x5c4239e834fe3650cd8bd179b3f290232b46274c80bb9bc2515c56ad0d81c4df","blockTime":1794942408000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x1b53329f0c1166138458090927b621c660d4949063430c10aed1ff37697378da","len":291}},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":36140125,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":36141781,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":45500000000000,"nays":0,"support":455000000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[36343381,[36343381,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":45500000000000,"nays":0,"support":455000000000000,"electorate":"18167707079416784022"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0x580330f089a56f1bdf275e04b8540cb20e10d4d230855a93b637081ded9e93b1"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":false,"proposalHash":"0x1b53329f0c1166138458090927b621c660d4949063430c10aed1ff37697378da","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6afca5f674667fceb6f9e0e3","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":23940595,"blockHash":"0x5c4239e834fe3650cd8bd179b3f290232b46274c80bb9bc2515c56ad0d81c4df","blockTime":1794942408000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmSKu6RBu4bck78apup2RwR1texD3xAzQKa14ZUkC22PDw","createdAt":"2026-11-17T19:06:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-11-17T19:14:20.397Z","referendumIndex":679,"contentHash":"ace77f607625a4c2c24fce590e89bc4a"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6afca5f674667fceb6f9e0e3","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","publicKey":"6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","address":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6aed44d8c78ea47caf7e8624","referendumIndex":678,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23461127,"blockHash":"0x939d2910f1e1e0d39333103e557ed4c17cdf5c3e255ad6e805dfea9ebf00f22e","blockTime":1793934480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd","title":"Restitution for Karura LKSM holders affected by delayed Kusama BEEFY offence reporting","content":"## Executive summary\n\nThis proposal asks Kusama governance to authorize a one-time transfer of **36,246.528144881225 KSM** to the Karura Homa staking subaccount: `EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez`\n\nThe transfer would restore the Treasury-directed portion of KSM removed from the shared backing of LKSM holders after six reported 50% slashes affected the same Homa nominator exposure to validator: `DooaUKbyTV7j7GtNQdLmHMM7UW8THSr6x2nxt3jrPeWX6NV`\n\nThe critical issue is that the offence was purely off-chain until the report was submitted on-chain. The report could be withheld and submitted much later, after the Karura validator insurance had been withdrawn. The same delay left too little time for Kusama governance to review or cancel the queued slash, effectively bypassing both safeguards.\n\n## Decision requested\n\nApprove the following one-time Treasury-directed transfer under the applicable Kusama governance mechanism:\n\n- **Amount requested:** 36,246.528144881225 KSM\n- **Beneficiary:** Karura Homa staking subaccount\n- **Destination:** [`EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez`](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez)\n- **Purpose:** Restore the KSM removed from the pooled backing of LKSM holders in the delayed-reporting incident described below\n\nThe transfer replenishes the shared Homa/LKSM backing. It is not paid to an individual LKSM holder, the validator operator, or an offence reporter.\n\n## Incident and accounting\n\nThe incident accounting attributes six separate 50% slash entries to the same Homa nominator exposure associated with the validator across the following eras:\n\n| Era   | Homa exposure (KSM) | Slash fraction |\n| ----- | ------------------: | -------------: |\n| 10170 | 12,921.006827077684 |            50% |\n| 10171 | 15,913.218466463611 |            50% |\n| 10172 | 12,021.928035787969 |            50% |\n| 10174 | 13,874.686063881595 |            50% |\n| 10175 | 11,858.635465196066 |            50% |\n| 10176 | 13,958.365463551354 |            50% |\n\nThe supplied chain-derived totals are:\n\n- **Total exposure:** 80,547.840321958279 KSM\n- **Gross slash after runtime rounding:** 40,273.920160979138 KSM\n- **Reporter reward at 10%:** 4,027.392016097914 KSM\n- **Treasury-directed portion requested for restitution:** 36,246.528144881225 KSM\n\n## Why the case warrants restitution\n\n### 1. Repeated reports affected one pooled exposure\n\nThe incident evidence shows six 50% reports against the same Homa nominator exposure. The proposal relies on event-level accounting of the resulting slash amounts; it does not assume that six percentages can simply be added together.\n\n### 2. Delayed off-chain reporting bypassed the practical review window\n\nThe offence evidence and report remained entirely off-chain until submission to Asset Hub. According to the incident timeline, the reports were withheld after the relevant offence eras had ended and submitted close to the end of the unapplied-slash period.\n\nNormally, submitting a report queues the slash and leaves time for Kusama governance to review and cancel or reverse it. Here, delaying submission left nominators little practical opportunity to reduce exposure, gave governance insufficient time for meaningful review or cancellation, and effectively bypassed that safeguard.\n\n### 3. The insurance backstop was unavailable\n\nKarura validator insurance had been withdrawn before the delayed reports were submitted and processed. Because the report could be withheld off-chain, the offender could withdraw the insurance first and submit the report later, defeating the intended backstop.\n\n### 4. The reporter incentive rewards delay\n\nThe current 10% reporter reward is economically misaligned. By reporting as late as possible, a reporter can allow a malicious validator to cause more damage, increasing the eventual slash and therefore the reporter's reward.\n\nThe desired behavior is the opposite: reports should be submitted as soon as possible to minimize harm. This is an economic bug that should be addressed.\n\n### 5. Polkadot has addressed this failure mode\n\nPolkadot has enabled required validator self-stake and disabled nominator slashing, addressing this exact class of risk. The [Polkadot Developer Docs](https://docs.polkadot.com/node-infrastructure/run-a-validator/staking-mechanics/offenses-and-slashes/) describe the resulting model as one in which only the validator's self-stake remains subject to slashing.\n\nIf Kusama had adopted a comparable model before this incident, the pooled LKSM backing would not have been directly exposed to the validator's slash in this form. Kusama has not adopted these changes and remains vulnerable to the same failure mode.","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-11-06T03:08:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-11-06T03:52:54.284Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-17T17:10:27.732Z","state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"stateSort":1,"cid":"QmbGQjc2r8aFCjP9fRRoUBhGba8yARYS2aM2dS2RFVkMuz","contentHash":"d9d3d94850ed8cbe0359e25d8e189fd0","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"d9d3d94850ed8cbe0359e25d8e189fd0","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Treasury Proposal: Restoring Slashed KSM for LKSM Holders\n\n## Summary\n\nA request has been made to Kusama's government (governance) to send **36,246.53 KSM** to the Karura Homa staking account. This would refill the shared pool of KSM that backs LKSM holders.\n\n## What Happened?\n\n- A bad validator was slashed (punished) six times at 50% each.\n- The slashes hit the shared Homa/LKSM pool, not just one person.\n- The slash reports were kept secret off-chain and turned in very late.\n\n## Why It Was Unfair\n\n- The late reporting gave governance almost no time to review or cancel the slashes.\n- Karura's insurance money had already been taken out before the reports came in.\n- Reporters actually earn **more** by waiting, because the reward is 10% of a bigger slash.\n\n## The Numbers\n\n- Gross slash: about **40,273.92 KSM**\n- Reporter reward (10%): about **4,027.39 KSM**\n- Amount requested back: **36,246.53 KSM**\n\n## What Is Being Asked\n\n- Send **36,246.53 KSM** from the Kusama Treasury to the Homa staking subaccount.\n- The money refills the shared LKSM backing — not any single holder, validator, or reporter.\n\n## Bigger Picture\n\n- Polkadot already fixed this problem with validator self-stake and no nominator slashing.\n- Kusama has not made these changes and can be hurt the same way again."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"36246528144881225","beneficiary":"EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":false,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aed44c17db0b12a3b7bd4dd","referendumIndex":678,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23461127,"blockHash":"0x939d2910f1e1e0d39333103e557ed4c17cdf5c3e255ad6e805dfea9ebf00f22e","blockTime":1793934480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd","authors":["HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x72728570963166706f9ed6b0862904e4baefe0f143bf6da602bb6df28b6f21af","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":35977242,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"ESJ6ggzgRLRdUtmj1E1oLD1Vmg6xY6sPTeSgeoStB1y4QNi","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":35991512,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000000271559e92c9000","nays":"0x000000000000000001298ec633652400","support":"0x000000000000000000138b215ee8d000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[36193112,[36193112,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000000271559e92c9000","nays":"0x000000000000000001298ec633652400","support":"0x000000000000000000138b215ee8d000","electorate":"18167707079416784022"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":false,"proposalHash":"0x72728570963166706f9ed6b0862904e4baefe0f143bf6da602bb6df28b6f21af","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"36246528144881225"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez"}}]}],"amount":"36246528144881225","beneficiary":"EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez","beneficiaries":["EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"36246528144881225","beneficiary":"EQFY1VnjdYUSJ9oWoNgunPHeqLFooyPF3r6ZkTbCU5a6Eez","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aed44c17db0b12a3b7bd4df","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":23461127,"blockHash":"0x939d2910f1e1e0d39333103e557ed4c17cdf5c3e255ad6e805dfea9ebf00f22e","blockTime":1793934480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmbGQjc2r8aFCjP9fRRoUBhGba8yARYS2aM2dS2RFVkMuz","createdAt":"2026-11-06T03:08:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-11-06T03:52:54.284Z","referendumIndex":678,"contentHash":"d9d3d94850ed8cbe0359e25d8e189fd0"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aed44c17db0b12a3b7bd4df","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xee9e0a9ced1d9809056b4adca8d224ea3c359ab9af1fb6986028fe816e37665a","publicKey":"ee9e0a9ced1d9809056b4adca8d224ea3c359ab9af1fb6986028fe816e37665a","address":"HyBryanRsB1GGKa9ZfqvRc3XpTDipYyRvxNNyZYfWFcenhd"},"commentsCount":4},{"_id":"6ad75c61c78ea47cafc98469","referendumIndex":676,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22797018,"blockHash":"0xf3d4dc150a21fd57632a85588977a667c1c43694c0dd800d758ac9236dd22ce7","blockTime":1792498704000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","title":"An independent Kusama on a reduced JAM, keeping its validators","content":"Supporting this proposal means KSM holders want an independent Kusama, keeping its own validators on a reduced JAM, to be **scoped, priced and specified in the open, and compared with JAM Prime before Kusama's validators are retired.** It continues [#573](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573), which passed on 21 August 2025.\n\nIt asks for no funds, no DOT and nothing from the Kusama Vision fund. It sits beside [#671](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/671), [#672](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/672), [#673](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/673) and [#674](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/674) so that a voter who wants Kusama to keep its validators has a line to vote for. You can support this and any of the four. If both pass, the comparison comes first.\n\nThe full resolution is the proposal itself, shown below.\n\n## References\n\n- [Forum post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/a-fifth-option-an-independent-kusama-on-a-reduced-jam-keeping-its-validators/19047)\n- [Full paper](https://github.com/Birdbrain-wtf/publications/blob/main/content/articles/independent-kusama-fifth-option/index.md)\n- [Come to the Monday call](https://birdbrain.wtf/chaos/join), 26 October, 15:00 UTC, given to this question\n\n*Proposed by Birdbrain (People Chain identity `Birdbrain`), a collective on Kreivo. Decent Partners supports Birdbrain. Interests in full are in the paper.*\n","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T12:18:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T12:20:07.329Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-16T15:19:21.385Z","cid":"QmdJnvx5pnGF7MzLRz5Jyf4AQXtNEfqmE8bycoKJSTyNZj","contentHash":"f4f60f1569dccbaae0228296db563312","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"stateSort":1,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"f4f60f1569dccbaae0228296db563312","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Proposal #675 (Simplified)\n\n- This is a vote about keeping Kusama independent with its own validators.\n- It wants the plan to be checked, priced, and shared openly.\n- It wants this plan compared with another plan called JAM Prime.\n- This must happen **before** Kusama's validators are retired.\n- It asks for **no money** — no funds, no DOT, nothing from the Kusama Vision fund.\n- It follows an earlier vote (#573) that passed on 21 August 2025.\n- It works alongside proposals #671, #672, #673, and #674. You can vote for this one and any of those.\n- If both this and another proposal pass, the comparison happens first."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":false,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad75c459432d5e4041a4930","referendumIndex":676,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22797018,"blockHash":"0xf3d4dc150a21fd57632a85588977a667c1c43694c0dd800d758ac9236dd22ce7","blockTime":1792498704000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","authors":["DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Deciding","indexer":{"blockHeight":23945900,"blockHash":"0x94b17d659e878e67cb828b54ba0094a844e7d28b6e0d131b005a0898971f62c6","blockTime":1794953616000}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xe6abe7f11ad89116d0b1a9704db80e5ad793d39f3d351e7a412389c9a1ab8e97","len":2731}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35744316,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"JHqkqPcTZuAwEWeunv9Mz1eyfuUSHqr8o5CaFkRgPAu6VrB","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":35942656,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000027541b39a9e000","nays":"0x000000000000000000aba62e940b5800","support":"0x000000000000000000253268d6cc6000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[36144256,[36144256,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000027541b39a9e000","nays":"0x000000000000000000aba62e940b5800","support":"0x000000000000000000253268d6cc6000","electorate":"18167707079416784022"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["## Wish for Change: an independent Kusama on a reduced JAM, keeping its validators\n\n**Proposed resolution**\n\nKSM DAO continues the direction it set in Referendum #573 (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573), on these terms.\n\n**1. Direction.** An independent Kusama, keeping its own validator set, staking, governance and monetary policy on a reduced JAM network of its own, is scoped, priced and specified in the open, with Kusama's validators, nominators and parachains, and put to KSM holders beside JAM Prime before any transition retires Kusama's validators.\n\n**2. Relation to #671 to #674.** This proposal is not part of the selection round those four define, and does not change their rules. If it passes, KSM DAO's position is that #573 stands until KSM holders have compared a priced independent Kusama with JAM Prime, and that DOT DAO should not be asked to accept a package that retires Kusama's validators before that comparison is published.\n\n**3. What the comparison needs.** Each is published with its workings, for anyone to check or dispute:\n\n| Output | Content |\n| --- | --- |\n| Validator cost survey | Hardware, hosting, bandwidth, labour and tooling per seat, from Kusama's own operators, published in aggregate |\n| Reference configuration | Cores, validator count, hardware and slot time for a Kusama-sized JAM network, tested on a public network run by Kusama validators |\n| Funding model | What commission covers at today's issuance and at #573's 2.4%, what must come from use, set beside JAM Prime's on the same terms |\n\nThe starting parameters are #573's 32 cores and KSM as the native token for staking, storage and coretime, with a validator set elected by KSM stake and no fewer than 96 seats, three for each core.\n\n**4. Protection while the comparison is made.** Kusama's validators keep their seats under the existing election. Staking continues and no stake is forced to unbond. Coretime stays priced in KSM and sold by Kusama's own Coretime chain. Any reduction of the validator set is its own referendum, as #655 was.\n\n**5. Stewardship.** Kusama-specific work for this direction is carried by an open steward collective accountable to KSM DAO, which Birdbrain offers to form on Kreivo and which validators, nominators, parachain teams and JAM client teams are invited to join. KSM DAO can withdraw this mandate by referendum at any time.\n\n**6. Funding.** This referendum requests no funds, no DOT and nothing from the Kusama Vision fund. Any funding is a separate proposal against published milestones.\n\n**Effect of this vote.** Approval records KSM holders' wish that independence is priced and compared before it is retired. It transfers no funds, changes no code and grants no privileges."],"isFinal":false,"proposalHash":"0xe6abe7f11ad89116d0b1a9704db80e5ad793d39f3d351e7a412389c9a1ab8e97","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad75c459432d5e4041a4932","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22797018,"blockHash":"0xf3d4dc150a21fd57632a85588977a667c1c43694c0dd800d758ac9236dd22ce7","blockTime":1792498704000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmdJnvx5pnGF7MzLRz5Jyf4AQXtNEfqmE8bycoKJSTyNZj","createdAt":"2026-10-20T12:18:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T12:20:07.329Z","referendumIndex":676,"contentHash":"f4f60f1569dccbaae0228296db563312"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad75c459432d5e4041a4932","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x20469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144","publicKey":"20469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144","address":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"},"commentsCount":13},{"_id":"6adfa542c78ea47caff0118a","referendumIndex":677,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23047599,"blockHash":"0xbe39dab9327efbb385d1198947cc9985b874e5f783034cec66c94b162af4ed24","blockTime":1793041680000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","title":"Runtime Upgrade 2.5.1","content":"Upgrade all system chains to [release 2.5.1](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/releases/tag/v2.5.1).","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-10-26T19:08:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-26T19:13:04.673Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-29T13:07:12.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23156881,"blockHash":"0x8b40a8ffbcd2821b785bd709a4dfa66bdfdd19689f022b49772d34f59068bb82","blockTime":1793279232000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmR6x8nMCdqGTWzBVLDrxLBnSjQW4H2AHF7kd9S21yCCNT","contentHash":"99d7253a609c45395c4fa7ac7e618e01","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6adfa533cf03e088dd81a191","referendumIndex":677,"indexer":{"blockHeight":23047599,"blockHash":"0xbe39dab9327efbb385d1198947cc9985b874e5f783034cec66c94b162af4ed24","blockTime":1793041680000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23156881,"blockHash":"0x8b40a8ffbcd2821b785bd709a4dfa66bdfdd19689f022b49772d34f59068bb82","blockTime":1793279232000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xbaaf00c787682e673c8f478009678e5d666c183592c05ece2653a2366c6c9e1d","len":291}},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":35832440,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":35832740,"confirming":35870911},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000de5f43e2a9ec000","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000024052d25a7ba4000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35870911,[35870911,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000de5f43e2a9ec000","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000024052d25a7ba4000","electorate":"18096794384417300795"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0xc5e6e0a9246c00c433b3ac70e66ff8c49c180f199655597d09d05a9f32ff9410"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xbaaf00c787682e673c8f478009678e5d666c183592c05ece2653a2366c6c9e1d","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35871011,"index":0},"approved":[35870911,{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":33333333333},{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"18096794384417300795","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":23156282,"blockHash":"0x2f47e96e9a1fa48afe7752f6474b1b785eb3d63296a583ed2564153e4318ba80","blockTime":1793278008000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6adfa534cf03e088dd81a193","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":23047599,"blockHash":"0xbe39dab9327efbb385d1198947cc9985b874e5f783034cec66c94b162af4ed24","blockTime":1793041680000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmR6x8nMCdqGTWzBVLDrxLBnSjQW4H2AHF7kd9S21yCCNT","createdAt":"2026-10-26T19:08:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-26T19:13:04.673Z","referendumIndex":677,"contentHash":"99d7253a609c45395c4fa7ac7e618e01"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6adfa534cf03e088dd81a193","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","publicKey":"6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","address":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6ad72ce3c78ea47caf7f8ac0","referendumIndex":675,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22791578,"blockHash":"0xa223b80cb68834d4da64caa37403b962c71e9dc4ea21a60638b333826b507940","blockTime":1792486560000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","title":"PSEUDONYM: generative portraits of Kusama and Polkadot accounts (retroactive + Phase 1)","content":"**PSEUDONYM** turns any Kusama or Polkadot address into a generative portrait, using only public on-chain data. This referendum funds the working version (retroactive) and Phase 1: a public experiment in whether people want to see, keep or hide their on-chain portrait.\n\nDiscussion since 7 October: [Polkadot Forum](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/discussion-pseudonym-generative-portraits-of-kusama-and-polkadot-accounts-a-social-experiment-in-on-chain-identity/18920) · [Subsquare #56](https://kusama.subsquare.io/posts/56)\n \nLive work: https://arkain.vercel.app · Archive: https://arkain.vercel.app/archive\n\n**Request**\n\n- **Total: 3,333 KSM** (Medium Spender limit)\n- Budget: 14,000 USD (4,000 retroactive + 10,000 Phase 1). At 4.17 USD/KSM (CoinGecko, 20 October 2026) this would be 3,357 KSM, so the request is capped at 3,333 KSM (≈ 13,899 USD) and the difference is taken from the contingency line.\n- **Beneficiary (Kusama Asset Hub):** EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad\n- **Duration:** 26 weeks\n\n**Payouts** (scheduled treasury spends; future payouts can be voided by governance)\n\n| # | When | KSM |\n|---|---|---|\n| 1 | On enactment | 1,785.5357 |\n| 2 | ~Week 10 (relay block 36,994,453, ≈ mid-January 2027) | 714.2143 |\n| 3 | ~Week 22 (relay block 38,204,053, ≈ mid-April 2027) | 833.25 |\n\n**Phase 1 deliverables**\n\n- Wallet ownership via message signing (Polkadot.js, Talisman, SubWallet, Nova)\n- Claim or veil: owners can mint a snapshot of their portrait on Kusama Asset Hub (no fee, no sale), or hide it from the public archive\n- Verified reflections\n- Public report on the results\n- Code under MIT, artwork under CC BY\n\n**How Phase 1 will be judged**\n\n- Public counter and archive numbers reported at weeks 10 and 22, alongside the scheduled payouts\n- A written report at week 26: portraits generated, claims, veils, reflections, and what did not work\n- If adoption stays low, the report will say so plainly, and no follow-up proposal will be made without new evidence\n\n**Current state (honest numbers):** 23 portraits generated since 16 October 2026 (the counter counts portraits, not people, and includes one of my own test renders). The archive includes my own portrait.\n\n**Why KSM:** the Kusama treasury currently holds only a negligible amount of DOT, so the request is denominated in KSM.\n\n**Why Kusama:** portraits read both Kusama and Polkadot activity, because many identities span both networks, but the experiment itself (claim or veil, snapshot mints, public archive) runs on Kusama Asset Hub.","contentType":"markdown","track":33,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T08:56:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T09:09:21.080Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-03T22:20:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23370756,"blockHash":"0x3664b35825bfcfafe7ca32bc20593ef117478fddbb84674837b3b03bd22ea8d5","blockTime":1793744424000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2892018000000000,"nays":"0x000000000000000000155c8616464200","support":962180000000000}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmQMPtZtiCBj3FPcqu44PkCnHhgKYjNWkSNfXgRbbw4AMv","contentHash":"4b7f8f2c3b06d5de94bcb604887a2cfa","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"4b7f8f2c3b06d5de94bcb604887a2cfa","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"**PSEUDONYM (project)**\n\nPSEUDONYM is a project that turns Kusama and Polkadot wallet addresses into made-up pictures (portraits). It only uses information that is already public on the blockchain.\n\n**What it wants**\n- It asks for 3,333 KSM from the Kusama treasury.\n- The money pays for work already done and for \"Phase 1,\" a test to see if people want to show, keep, or hide their on-chain portrait.\n- The project would last 26 weeks.\n\n**What Phase 1 will do**\n- Let people prove they own a wallet by signing a message with apps like Polkadot.js, Talisman, SubWallet, and Nova.\n- Let owners \"claim\" a copy of their portrait on Kusama Asset Hub (free, not for sale) or \"veil\" it so it is hidden from the public archive.\n- Add verified reflections.\n- Publish a public report on the results.\n- Share the code (MIT) and the artwork (CC BY).\n\n**How it will be judged**\n- Numbers will be shared at weeks 10 and 22 along with payments.\n- A written report at week 26 will honestly say what worked and what didn't. If few people use it, the report will say so, and no new proposal will be made without new evidence.\n\n**Current state (honest numbers)**\n- 23 portraits have been made since 16 October 2026.\n- The counter counts portraits, not people, and includes one test picture by the creator.\n\n**Why KSM and Kusama**\n- The Kusama treasury has almost no DOT, so the request is in KSM.\n- Portraits look at both Kusama and Polkadot activity, but the test itself runs on Kusama Asset Hub."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"1785535700000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"714214300000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36994453,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"833250000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":38204053,"after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad72ce09432d5e404158611","referendumIndex":675,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22791578,"blockHash":"0xa223b80cb68834d4da64caa37403b962c71e9dc4ea21a60638b333826b507940","blockTime":1792486560000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":33,"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"proposer":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","authors":["EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x2802","section":"utility","method":"batchAll"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23370756,"blockHash":"0x3664b35825bfcfafe7ca32bc20593ef117478fddbb84674837b3b03bd22ea8d5","blockTime":1793744424000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2892018000000000,"nays":"0x000000000000000000155c8616464200","support":962180000000000}}},"info":{"track":33,"origin":{"origins":"MediumSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x04d5a242aaddaed1de3b0cbd4e587249afa4ba249bf8c1caecc5f3416808f37f","len":176}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35742347,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","amount":6666666666600},"deciding":{"since":35744750,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":2892018000000000,"nays":"0x000000000000000000155c8616464200","support":962180000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35946350,[35946350,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":2892018000000000,"nays":"0x000000000000000000155c8616464200","support":962180000000000,"electorate":"18116576108667796413"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x04d5a242aaddaed1de3b0cbd4e587249afa4ba249bf8c1caecc5f3416808f37f","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"1785535700000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"714214300000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36994453,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"833250000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","pubKey":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":38204053,"after":null}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"18116576108667796413","rejected":[35946350,{"who":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","amount":33333333333},{"who":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad","amount":6666666666600}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad72ce09432d5e404158613","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22791578,"blockHash":"0xa223b80cb68834d4da64caa37403b962c71e9dc4ea21a60638b333826b507940","blockTime":1792486560000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmQMPtZtiCBj3FPcqu44PkCnHhgKYjNWkSNfXgRbbw4AMv","createdAt":"2026-10-20T08:56:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T09:09:21.080Z","referendumIndex":675,"contentHash":"4b7f8f2c3b06d5de94bcb604887a2cfa"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad72ce09432d5e404158613","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad"]},"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c","publicKey":"4ef9da067a08e92c49c8ebade31cdf11d14c736a4bfe5bf5baf394095e9a037c","address":"EMsUTbNpFuTUwa6ybNZLAtA9sT3Fi6PSPP2gF9BWFbHfyad"},"commentsCount":4},{"_id":"6ad712dbc78ea47caf5779d3","referendumIndex":674,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788530,"blockHash":"0xc6ab5bde540a160354b54f5c8416195171c32ee2dd101811f4c82883bcb4f12c","blockTime":1792479912000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","title":"Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 4: 2 cores for 20 years","content":"## References\n- [Forum Post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-on-jam-prime-the-infrastructure-decision/19044)\n- [Full paper](https://github.com/sdfinst/publications/blob/da60fe67d9c8b13b04bf3af6dab5c49be0625fe1/content/articles/kusama-jam-prime-infrastructure-decision/index.md)","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:05:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:13:29.326Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-04T11:28:55.192Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367882,"blockHash":"0x343cdd932396cc9e25c237b593d79f464592ce4c6b2982f9e6952218187bd1a0","blockTime":1793738376000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903fb07a7f400","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmeUyLkv8RiZtmf6VvGugDE94Jd5hzrwkhcpGBPGEWtwU2","contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad712c99432d5e40412ed1a","referendumIndex":674,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788530,"blockHash":"0xc6ab5bde540a160354b54f5c8416195171c32ee2dd101811f4c82883bcb4f12c","blockTime":1792479912000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367882,"blockHash":"0x343cdd932396cc9e25c237b593d79f464592ce4c6b2982f9e6952218187bd1a0","blockTime":1793738376000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903fb07a7f400","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xbddaa64143553b5f705ad2b2c4cbd24ce273f6491c7cfe183b0608385e955267","len":8894}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35741259,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":35743768,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903fb07a7f400","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35945368,[35945368,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903fb07a7f400","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000","electorate":"18116313522331481622"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["## Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 4: 2 cores for 20 years\n\n**Proposed resolution**\n\nSubject to selection by the rules in this resolution, Kusama’s token-holder governance (KSM DAO) supports a complete security and resource endowment on **JAM Prime**, the Polkadot-aligned JAM instance contemplated as shared infrastructure, comprising **2 cores for 20 years**, totaling **40 coretime-years (CTYs)**, on these terms.\n\n**1. Infrastructure direction.** KSM DAO pursues a protected Kusama-controlled service jurisdiction on JAM Prime, superseding WFC #573’s independent lightweight JAM direction upon selection (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573). Kusama’s community and the Kusama Vision programme retain responsibility for its mission and strategy.\n\n**2. Specified resource package.** The following resources define the protected package and the operating scope it secures.\n\n| Resource or term | Requirement |\n| --- | --- |\n| Compute | 2 full cores reserved throughout the term; 40 CTYs. |\n| Protected term | 20 years from verified operational availability of the complete package. |\n| System base footprint | **250,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for system functions and shared host resources. |\n| Migration footprint allowance | **200,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for initial support of 12 other parachains. |\n| Total footprint planning ceiling | **450,000 JAMKB-equivalent**, backed and usable throughout the protected term; actual requirements assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Always-accumulate resources | Protected always-accumulate registration and a sufficient quantified minimum allowance, assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Control | Protected KSM authority throughout the term. |\n| Stewardship | Accepted, Fellowship-led implementation and maintenance of the agreed operating scope. |\n| Consideration | Fixed DOT amount under clause 5 for the complete package. |\n\nThe system base uses the planning model for 5 system chains (Asset Hub, Coretime, People, Bridge Hub and Encointer), shared host state and programs, 2 reusable authorizer-program blobs, 1 active and 2 additional solicited Parachain Validation Function (PVF) versions per chain, 3 host-program versions and contingency. The migration allowance provides initial support for 12 other parachains, with 1 PVF version and generic host-side state per chain plus contingency.\n\nKSM governance must define participant quotas, future upgrade backing and permissible reallocation. Participants must secure additional backing before state growth or overlapping upgrades exceed their quotas. Transitional backing may be released only once replacement backing is in place or the dependent state has been removed. The complete footprint entitlement remains protected throughout the agreed term.\n\nKSM governance may permit additional Kusama activity using separately funded JAM coretime where the implemented service supports it. Additional purchases follow their own availability, pricing and duration. Their footprint needs must fit assessed available capacity or receive additional funded provision. Such purchases do not enlarge this endowment or automatically acquire its resource protections, protected term or stewardship commitments.\n\n**3. Protected KSM control.** KSM governance retains authority over service upgrades, internal governance, monetary policy, authorizers and internal resource assignment. It determines reservations for retained functions and the permitted uses and conditions for releasing other endowed capacity. The implemented boundary must prevent ordinary unilateral revocation, reassignment or material impairment through manager and other host administrative powers. Protection covers the agreed compute, effective footprint backing, always-accumulate resources and KSM authority through host upgrades throughout the term.\n\n**4. Fellowship mandate and continued alignment.** KSM DAO delegates technical assessment, architecture, implementation, migration and maintenance to the Polkadot Fellowship under an accepted mandate. The Fellowship should assess the system base and initial migration needs separately and establish a viable arrangement for the agreed offering within the reserved compute, assessed footprint and sufficient always-accumulate resources.\n\nThe assessment should cover use of externally acquired JAM coretime by the Kusama service, including possible direct purchases by users, the associated authorization and operating requirements, and controls over endowed capacity released for use elsewhere. Material changes to the agreed package, including necessary footprint ceiling revisions, return to the relevant governance bodies. KSM governance retains material offering decisions. The mandate preserves Kusama–Polkadot alignment through shared technologies, primitives, standards and interfaces.\n\n**5. Complete-package consideration and DOT pricing.** The entire package’s reference is **US$4,320,000 = 40 CTYs × US$108,000 per CTY**, with a contribution ceiling of **5,000,000 DOT**. **D** is the UTC calendar date of the finalized block recording this individual Kusama referendum’s approval. **P90(D)** is the arithmetic mean of CoinGecko’s **00:00 UTC USD price snapshots for 1 DOT**, asset identifier **polkadot**, for all 90 completed UTC days **D−90 through D−1**, inclusive.\n\n**Fixed DOT consideration = US$4,320,000 ÷ P90(D), rounded upward to the smallest transferable DOT unit.**\n\nThe original approval date remains the pricing anchor through result certification, tie-breaking, DOT DAO voting and settlement. Its calculation fixes the complete-package offer. Once accepted by DOT DAO, that DOT amount remains unchanged despite market movements; its future USD value remains variable.\n\nA result above 5,000,000 DOT requires revised terms and renewed KSM governance before payment. This resolution provides no automatic ceiling increase, truncation of the calculated contribution, reduction of the package or substitution of another proposal.\n\n**6. Kusama Vision fund and Kusama Vision programme.** The contribution uses eligible Kusama Vision fund resources, amending WFC #498 while preserving the Kusama Vision programme and existing commitments (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/498). Expenditure and outstanding obligations are reconciled; the remainder supports development.\n\nThis proposed arrangement is subject to acceptance by Web3 Foundation (W3F). W3F may confirm the eligible contribution through an explicit support vote or a conscious neutral abstention explicitly recorded for this round, allowing other KSM holders to decide. Ordinary nonparticipation provides no funding confirmation.\n\n**7. Consequences for Kusama.** The independent validator set, staking system and associated staking issuance and rewards retire with the completed transition. Further monetary design requires KSM decisions; deflation remains possible. KSM governance retains offering decisions and treatment of existing commitments.\n\nCoretime sales and other commitments backed by the endowment must fit its available capacity after reservations for retained functions. Parachain teams seeking capacity beyond that allocation may pursue continued hosting within the Kusama service using separately funded resources where technically supported, or migration to Polkadot under its applicable access terms. Affected teams may request a Kusama Treasury transition budget through a separate KSM funding decision.\n\n**8. Selection and bilateral acceptance.** The coordinated round consists of four infrastructure WFC proposals: 8 cores for 5 years, 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months, 4 cores for 10 years and 2 cores for 20 years. Voters may support every acceptable proposal. Each must independently satisfy the applicable approval and support thresholds.\n\nAfter all four close through approval or rejection, the passing proposal with the greatest exact final conviction-weighted AYE tally is selected. Early approval fixes its tally and pricing date while selection awaits the remaining outcomes.\n\nCancellation, killing or timeout requires a fresh governance decision for the incomplete round. Unverifiable tallies leave selection unresolved. No passing proposal means no mandate. Exact ties among the highest passing tallies require a further decision among those original approved proposals, preserving the winner’s original approval date.\n\nOnly the winner advances to Polkadot’s token-holder governance (DOT DAO) for acceptance of the complete package and fixed consideration: **One mandate and one contribution**.\n\n**Effect of this vote.** Approval establishes a political direction, financial rule and requested technical mandate, conditional on selection. Resource allocation, payment and technical changes require authorized implementation actions; the WFC itself transfers no funds and grants no technical privileges.\n"],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xbddaa64143553b5f705ad2b2c4cbd24ce273f6491c7cfe183b0608385e955267","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"18116313522331481622","rejected":[35945368,{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad712c99432d5e40412ed1c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22788530,"blockHash":"0xc6ab5bde540a160354b54f5c8416195171c32ee2dd101811f4c82883bcb4f12c","blockTime":1792479912000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmeUyLkv8RiZtmf6VvGugDE94Jd5hzrwkhcpGBPGEWtwU2","createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:05:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:13:29.326Z","referendumIndex":674,"contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad712c99432d5e40412ed1c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":4},{"_id":"6ad712bcc78ea47caf576caa","referendumIndex":673,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788502,"blockHash":"0x6f248518255149294e09d6714bceffd0bb44aa0c5d061217670c4b07a2584fb9","blockTime":1792479840000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","title":"Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 3: 4 cores for 10 years","content":"## References\n- [Forum Post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-on-jam-prime-the-infrastructure-decision/19044)\n- [Full paper](https://github.com/sdfinst/publications/blob/da60fe67d9c8b13b04bf3af6dab5c49be0625fe1/content/articles/kusama-jam-prime-infrastructure-decision/index.md)","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:04:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:13:08.515Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-04T11:28:22.094Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367894,"blockHash":"0x0ecd2672da998c02d95143a83166ed546422a616a6a655c83c2acaa167b34b07","blockTime":1793738400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903f8b39c1000","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmWtnTKWc2VVryANLiDah48cZBuFGrGF4DoPJezBA4Uzox","contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad712ad9432d5e40412ed15","referendumIndex":673,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788502,"blockHash":"0x6f248518255149294e09d6714bceffd0bb44aa0c5d061217670c4b07a2584fb9","blockTime":1792479840000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367894,"blockHash":"0x0ecd2672da998c02d95143a83166ed546422a616a6a655c83c2acaa167b34b07","blockTime":1793738400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903f8b39c1000","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xce7cf9f7434fa0594d083c8035cdf9f3afa487dd1a1708bf4b8b0722b2689d2a","len":8894}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35741250,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":35743772,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903f8b39c1000","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35945372,[35945372,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":2699000000000000,"nays":"0x0000000000000000004903f8b39c1000","support":"0x000000000000000018b2c2cfae1e3000","electorate":"18116313522331481622"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["## Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 3: 4 cores for 10 years\n\n**Proposed resolution**\n\nSubject to selection by the rules in this resolution, Kusama’s token-holder governance (KSM DAO) supports a complete security and resource endowment on **JAM Prime**, the Polkadot-aligned JAM instance contemplated as shared infrastructure, comprising **4 cores for 10 years**, totaling **40 coretime-years (CTYs)**, on these terms.\n\n**1. Infrastructure direction.** KSM DAO pursues a protected Kusama-controlled service jurisdiction on JAM Prime, superseding WFC #573’s independent lightweight JAM direction upon selection (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573). Kusama’s community and the Kusama Vision programme retain responsibility for its mission and strategy.\n\n**2. Specified resource package.** The following resources define the protected package and the operating scope it secures.\n\n| Resource or term | Requirement |\n| --- | --- |\n| Compute | 4 full cores reserved throughout the term; 40 CTYs. |\n| Protected term | 10 years from verified operational availability of the complete package. |\n| System base footprint | **250,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for system functions and shared host resources. |\n| Migration footprint allowance | **200,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for initial support of 12 other parachains. |\n| Total footprint planning ceiling | **450,000 JAMKB-equivalent**, backed and usable throughout the protected term; actual requirements assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Always-accumulate resources | Protected always-accumulate registration and a sufficient quantified minimum allowance, assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Control | Protected KSM authority throughout the term. |\n| Stewardship | Accepted, Fellowship-led implementation and maintenance of the agreed operating scope. |\n| Consideration | Fixed DOT amount under clause 5 for the complete package. |\n\nThe system base uses the planning model for 5 system chains (Asset Hub, Coretime, People, Bridge Hub and Encointer), shared host state and programs, 2 reusable authorizer-program blobs, 1 active and 2 additional solicited Parachain Validation Function (PVF) versions per chain, 3 host-program versions and contingency. The migration allowance provides initial support for 12 other parachains, with 1 PVF version and generic host-side state per chain plus contingency.\n\nKSM governance must define participant quotas, future upgrade backing and permissible reallocation. Participants must secure additional backing before state growth or overlapping upgrades exceed their quotas. Transitional backing may be released only once replacement backing is in place or the dependent state has been removed. The complete footprint entitlement remains protected throughout the agreed term.\n\nKSM governance may permit additional Kusama activity using separately funded JAM coretime where the implemented service supports it. Additional purchases follow their own availability, pricing and duration. Their footprint needs must fit assessed available capacity or receive additional funded provision. Such purchases do not enlarge this endowment or automatically acquire its resource protections, protected term or stewardship commitments.\n\n**3. Protected KSM control.** KSM governance retains authority over service upgrades, internal governance, monetary policy, authorizers and internal resource assignment. It determines reservations for retained functions and the permitted uses and conditions for releasing other endowed capacity. The implemented boundary must prevent ordinary unilateral revocation, reassignment or material impairment through manager and other host administrative powers. Protection covers the agreed compute, effective footprint backing, always-accumulate resources and KSM authority through host upgrades throughout the term.\n\n**4. Fellowship mandate and continued alignment.** KSM DAO delegates technical assessment, architecture, implementation, migration and maintenance to the Polkadot Fellowship under an accepted mandate. The Fellowship should assess the system base and initial migration needs separately and establish a viable arrangement for the agreed offering within the reserved compute, assessed footprint and sufficient always-accumulate resources.\n\nThe assessment should cover use of externally acquired JAM coretime by the Kusama service, including possible direct purchases by users, the associated authorization and operating requirements, and controls over endowed capacity released for use elsewhere. Material changes to the agreed package, including necessary footprint ceiling revisions, return to the relevant governance bodies. KSM governance retains material offering decisions. The mandate preserves Kusama–Polkadot alignment through shared technologies, primitives, standards and interfaces.\n\n**5. Complete-package consideration and DOT pricing.** The entire package’s reference is **US$4,320,000 = 40 CTYs × US$108,000 per CTY**, with a contribution ceiling of **5,000,000 DOT**. **D** is the UTC calendar date of the finalized block recording this individual Kusama referendum’s approval. **P90(D)** is the arithmetic mean of CoinGecko’s **00:00 UTC USD price snapshots for 1 DOT**, asset identifier **polkadot**, for all 90 completed UTC days **D−90 through D−1**, inclusive.\n\n**Fixed DOT consideration = US$4,320,000 ÷ P90(D), rounded upward to the smallest transferable DOT unit.**\n\nThe original approval date remains the pricing anchor through result certification, tie-breaking, DOT DAO voting and settlement. Its calculation fixes the complete-package offer. Once accepted by DOT DAO, that DOT amount remains unchanged despite market movements; its future USD value remains variable.\n\nA result above 5,000,000 DOT requires revised terms and renewed KSM governance before payment. This resolution provides no automatic ceiling increase, truncation of the calculated contribution, reduction of the package or substitution of another proposal.\n\n**6. Kusama Vision fund and Kusama Vision programme.** The contribution uses eligible Kusama Vision fund resources, amending WFC #498 while preserving the Kusama Vision programme and existing commitments (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/498). Expenditure and outstanding obligations are reconciled; the remainder supports development.\n\nThis proposed arrangement is subject to acceptance by Web3 Foundation (W3F). W3F may confirm the eligible contribution through an explicit support vote or a conscious neutral abstention explicitly recorded for this round, allowing other KSM holders to decide. Ordinary nonparticipation provides no funding confirmation.\n\n**7. Consequences for Kusama.** The independent validator set, staking system and associated staking issuance and rewards retire with the completed transition. Further monetary design requires KSM decisions; deflation remains possible. KSM governance retains offering decisions and treatment of existing commitments.\n\nCoretime sales and other commitments backed by the endowment must fit its available capacity after reservations for retained functions. Parachain teams seeking capacity beyond that allocation may pursue continued hosting within the Kusama service using separately funded resources where technically supported, or migration to Polkadot under its applicable access terms. Affected teams may request a Kusama Treasury transition budget through a separate KSM funding decision.\n\n**8. Selection and bilateral acceptance.** The coordinated round consists of four infrastructure WFC proposals: 8 cores for 5 years, 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months, 4 cores for 10 years and 2 cores for 20 years. Voters may support every acceptable proposal. Each must independently satisfy the applicable approval and support thresholds.\n\nAfter all four close through approval or rejection, the passing proposal with the greatest exact final conviction-weighted AYE tally is selected. Early approval fixes its tally and pricing date while selection awaits the remaining outcomes.\n\nCancellation, killing or timeout requires a fresh governance decision for the incomplete round. Unverifiable tallies leave selection unresolved. No passing proposal means no mandate. Exact ties among the highest passing tallies require a further decision among those original approved proposals, preserving the winner’s original approval date.\n\nOnly the winner advances to Polkadot’s token-holder governance (DOT DAO) for acceptance of the complete package and fixed consideration: **One mandate and one contribution**.\n\n**Effect of this vote.** Approval establishes a political direction, financial rule and requested technical mandate, conditional on selection. Resource allocation, payment and technical changes require authorized implementation actions; the WFC itself transfers no funds and grants no technical privileges.\n"],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xce7cf9f7434fa0594d083c8035cdf9f3afa487dd1a1708bf4b8b0722b2689d2a","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"18116313522331481622","rejected":[35945372,{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad712ad9432d5e40412ed17","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22788502,"blockHash":"0x6f248518255149294e09d6714bceffd0bb44aa0c5d061217670c4b07a2584fb9","blockTime":1792479840000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmWtnTKWc2VVryANLiDah48cZBuFGrGF4DoPJezBA4Uzox","createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:04:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:13:08.515Z","referendumIndex":673,"contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad712ad9432d5e40412ed17","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":3},{"_id":"6ad71260c78ea47caf56c116","referendumIndex":672,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788471,"blockHash":"0xafdf3d08f423bb3ac22ef0e4900b6bdd3d0b585f3fc5862940f9d04220947ced","blockTime":1792479792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","title":"Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 2: 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months","content":"## References\n- [Forum Post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-on-jam-prime-the-infrastructure-decision/19044)\n- [Full paper](https://github.com/sdfinst/publications/blob/da60fe67d9c8b13b04bf3af6dab5c49be0625fe1/content/articles/kusama-jam-prime-infrastructure-decision/index.md)","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:03:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:12:38.893Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-04T11:26:44.672Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367900,"blockHash":"0x022d607db9021f5bdebb4db445cb1ffa4f700fb2dec8568c4b8fc71f60516f52","blockTime":1793738400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001a0f2e159d0000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003bf4a44546a400","support":"0x000000000000000018b61f8e99eef000"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmWJ1ZMoaiXBipNsymqD1ApXZcbh7wtKL7n9ZfDwv8JEqe","contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad7125b9432d5e40412d663","referendumIndex":672,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788471,"blockHash":"0xafdf3d08f423bb3ac22ef0e4900b6bdd3d0b585f3fc5862940f9d04220947ced","blockTime":1792479792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367900,"blockHash":"0x022d607db9021f5bdebb4db445cb1ffa4f700fb2dec8568c4b8fc71f60516f52","blockTime":1793738400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001a0f2e159d0000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003bf4a44546a400","support":"0x000000000000000018b61f8e99eef000"}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x4a125cd2bbeb7bc150080448eb3584e36b8dbf6cb9c21f42c633ecc08caa7d1f","len":8950}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35741239,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":35743774,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001a0f2e159d0000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003bf4a44546a400","support":"0x000000000000000018b61f8e99eef000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35945374,[35945374,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001a0f2e159d0000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003bf4a44546a400","support":"0x000000000000000018b61f8e99eef000","electorate":"18116313522331481622"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["## Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 2: 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months\n\n**Proposed resolution**\n\nSubject to selection by the rules in this resolution, Kusama’s token-holder governance (KSM DAO) supports a complete security and resource endowment on **JAM Prime**, the Polkadot-aligned JAM instance contemplated as shared infrastructure, comprising **6 cores for 6 years and 8 months**, totaling **40 coretime-years (CTYs)**, on these terms.\n\n**1. Infrastructure direction.** KSM DAO pursues a protected Kusama-controlled service jurisdiction on JAM Prime, superseding WFC #573’s independent lightweight JAM direction upon selection (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573). Kusama’s community and the Kusama Vision programme retain responsibility for its mission and strategy.\n\n**2. Specified resource package.** The following resources define the protected package and the operating scope it secures.\n\n| Resource or term | Requirement |\n| --- | --- |\n| Compute | 6 full cores reserved throughout the term; 40 CTYs. |\n| Protected term | 6 years and 8 months (exactly 6⅔ years) from verified operational availability of the complete package. |\n| System base footprint | **250,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for system functions and shared host resources. |\n| Migration footprint allowance | **200,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for initial support of 12 other parachains. |\n| Total footprint planning ceiling | **450,000 JAMKB-equivalent**, backed and usable throughout the protected term; actual requirements assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Always-accumulate resources | Protected always-accumulate registration and a sufficient quantified minimum allowance, assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Control | Protected KSM authority throughout the term. |\n| Stewardship | Accepted, Fellowship-led implementation and maintenance of the agreed operating scope. |\n| Consideration | Fixed DOT amount under clause 5 for the complete package. |\n\nThe system base uses the planning model for 5 system chains (Asset Hub, Coretime, People, Bridge Hub and Encointer), shared host state and programs, 2 reusable authorizer-program blobs, 1 active and 2 additional solicited Parachain Validation Function (PVF) versions per chain, 3 host-program versions and contingency. The migration allowance provides initial support for 12 other parachains, with 1 PVF version and generic host-side state per chain plus contingency.\n\nKSM governance must define participant quotas, future upgrade backing and permissible reallocation. Participants must secure additional backing before state growth or overlapping upgrades exceed their quotas. Transitional backing may be released only once replacement backing is in place or the dependent state has been removed. The complete footprint entitlement remains protected throughout the agreed term.\n\nKSM governance may permit additional Kusama activity using separately funded JAM coretime where the implemented service supports it. Additional purchases follow their own availability, pricing and duration. Their footprint needs must fit assessed available capacity or receive additional funded provision. Such purchases do not enlarge this endowment or automatically acquire its resource protections, protected term or stewardship commitments.\n\n**3. Protected KSM control.** KSM governance retains authority over service upgrades, internal governance, monetary policy, authorizers and internal resource assignment. It determines reservations for retained functions and the permitted uses and conditions for releasing other endowed capacity. The implemented boundary must prevent ordinary unilateral revocation, reassignment or material impairment through manager and other host administrative powers. Protection covers the agreed compute, effective footprint backing, always-accumulate resources and KSM authority through host upgrades throughout the term.\n\n**4. Fellowship mandate and continued alignment.** KSM DAO delegates technical assessment, architecture, implementation, migration and maintenance to the Polkadot Fellowship under an accepted mandate. The Fellowship should assess the system base and initial migration needs separately and establish a viable arrangement for the agreed offering within the reserved compute, assessed footprint and sufficient always-accumulate resources.\n\nThe assessment should cover use of externally acquired JAM coretime by the Kusama service, including possible direct purchases by users, the associated authorization and operating requirements, and controls over endowed capacity released for use elsewhere. Material changes to the agreed package, including necessary footprint ceiling revisions, return to the relevant governance bodies. KSM governance retains material offering decisions. The mandate preserves Kusama–Polkadot alignment through shared technologies, primitives, standards and interfaces.\n\n**5. Complete-package consideration and DOT pricing.** The entire package’s reference is **US$4,320,000 = 40 CTYs × US$108,000 per CTY**, with a contribution ceiling of **5,000,000 DOT**. **D** is the UTC calendar date of the finalized block recording this individual Kusama referendum’s approval. **P90(D)** is the arithmetic mean of CoinGecko’s **00:00 UTC USD price snapshots for 1 DOT**, asset identifier **polkadot**, for all 90 completed UTC days **D−90 through D−1**, inclusive.\n\n**Fixed DOT consideration = US$4,320,000 ÷ P90(D), rounded upward to the smallest transferable DOT unit.**\n\nThe original approval date remains the pricing anchor through result certification, tie-breaking, DOT DAO voting and settlement. Its calculation fixes the complete-package offer. Once accepted by DOT DAO, that DOT amount remains unchanged despite market movements; its future USD value remains variable.\n\nA result above 5,000,000 DOT requires revised terms and renewed KSM governance before payment. This resolution provides no automatic ceiling increase, truncation of the calculated contribution, reduction of the package or substitution of another proposal.\n\n**6. Kusama Vision fund and Kusama Vision programme.** The contribution uses eligible Kusama Vision fund resources, amending WFC #498 while preserving the Kusama Vision programme and existing commitments (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/498). Expenditure and outstanding obligations are reconciled; the remainder supports development.\n\nThis proposed arrangement is subject to acceptance by Web3 Foundation (W3F). W3F may confirm the eligible contribution through an explicit support vote or a conscious neutral abstention explicitly recorded for this round, allowing other KSM holders to decide. Ordinary nonparticipation provides no funding confirmation.\n\n**7. Consequences for Kusama.** The independent validator set, staking system and associated staking issuance and rewards retire with the completed transition. Further monetary design requires KSM decisions; deflation remains possible. KSM governance retains offering decisions and treatment of existing commitments.\n\nCoretime sales and other commitments backed by the endowment must fit its available capacity after reservations for retained functions. Parachain teams seeking capacity beyond that allocation may pursue continued hosting within the Kusama service using separately funded resources where technically supported, or migration to Polkadot under its applicable access terms. Affected teams may request a Kusama Treasury transition budget through a separate KSM funding decision.\n\n**8. Selection and bilateral acceptance.** The coordinated round consists of four infrastructure WFC proposals: 8 cores for 5 years, 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months, 4 cores for 10 years and 2 cores for 20 years. Voters may support every acceptable proposal. Each must independently satisfy the applicable approval and support thresholds.\n\nAfter all four close through approval or rejection, the passing proposal with the greatest exact final conviction-weighted AYE tally is selected. Early approval fixes its tally and pricing date while selection awaits the remaining outcomes.\n\nCancellation, killing or timeout requires a fresh governance decision for the incomplete round. Unverifiable tallies leave selection unresolved. No passing proposal means no mandate. Exact ties among the highest passing tallies require a further decision among those original approved proposals, preserving the winner’s original approval date.\n\nOnly the winner advances to Polkadot’s token-holder governance (DOT DAO) for acceptance of the complete package and fixed consideration: **One mandate and one contribution**.\n\n**Effect of this vote.** Approval establishes a political direction, financial rule and requested technical mandate, conditional on selection. Resource allocation, payment and technical changes require authorized implementation actions; the WFC itself transfers no funds and grants no technical privileges."],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x4a125cd2bbeb7bc150080448eb3584e36b8dbf6cb9c21f42c633ecc08caa7d1f","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"18116313522331481622","rejected":[35945374,{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad7125b9432d5e40412d665","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22788471,"blockHash":"0xafdf3d08f423bb3ac22ef0e4900b6bdd3d0b585f3fc5862940f9d04220947ced","blockTime":1792479792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmWJ1ZMoaiXBipNsymqD1ApXZcbh7wtKL7n9ZfDwv8JEqe","createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:03:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:12:38.893Z","referendumIndex":672,"contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad7125b9432d5e40412d665","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":4},{"_id":"6ad711c1c78ea47caf55a233","referendumIndex":671,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788391,"blockHash":"0x46d0bfb5852cf9d75f6cad676880d669bbd07570a23abee681c5db1768b06161","blockTime":1792479624000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","title":"Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 1: 8 cores for 5 years","content":"## References\n- [Forum Post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-on-jam-prime-the-infrastructure-decision/19044)\n- [Full paper](https://github.com/sdfinst/publications/blob/da60fe67d9c8b13b04bf3af6dab5c49be0625fe1/content/articles/kusama-jam-prime-infrastructure-decision/index.md)","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:00:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:11:57.101Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-11-03T20:40:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367906,"blockHash":"0x58d4182f54e17fbf3b7090605ce20c5fbbc68917eff4b28cda3152890777fbad","blockTime":1793738424000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000023c219bdd9a000","nays":"0x00000000000000000033b211062c5400","support":"0x000000000000000018b7bd608b4e6000"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"Qmbf7AFK56fGymeghRAB8qkSU2SzpYzStg7jZg33ni7GSk","contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ad711bc9432d5e40412c08b","referendumIndex":671,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22788391,"blockHash":"0x46d0bfb5852cf9d75f6cad676880d669bbd07570a23abee681c5db1768b06161","blockTime":1792479624000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":23367906,"blockHash":"0x58d4182f54e17fbf3b7090605ce20c5fbbc68917eff4b28cda3152890777fbad","blockTime":1793738424000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000023c219bdd9a000","nays":"0x00000000000000000033b211062c5400","support":"0x000000000000000018b7bd608b4e6000"}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x0382276c3bf113f520610005fec96cbef4f404ec7a469b3c63ac3954a7b68159","len":8890}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35741213,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":35743776,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000023c219bdd9a000","nays":"0x00000000000000000033b211062c5400","support":"0x000000000000000018b7bd608b4e6000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35945376,[35945376,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000023c219bdd9a000","nays":"0x00000000000000000033b211062c5400","support":"0x000000000000000018b7bd608b4e6000","electorate":"18116313522331481622"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["## Infrastructure Wish-for-Change proposal 1: 8 cores for 5 years\n\n**Proposed resolution**\n\nSubject to selection by the rules in this resolution, Kusama’s token-holder governance (KSM DAO) supports a complete security and resource endowment on **JAM Prime**, the Polkadot-aligned JAM instance contemplated as shared infrastructure, comprising **8 cores for 5 years**, totaling **40 coretime-years (CTYs)**, on these terms.\n\n**1. Infrastructure direction.** KSM DAO pursues a protected Kusama-controlled service jurisdiction on JAM Prime, superseding WFC #573’s independent lightweight JAM direction upon selection (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573). Kusama’s community and the Kusama Vision programme retain responsibility for its mission and strategy.\n\n**2. Specified resource package.** The following resources define the protected package and the operating scope it secures.\n\n| Resource or term | Requirement |\n| --- | --- |\n| Compute | 8 full cores reserved throughout the term; 40 CTYs. |\n| Protected term | 5 years from verified operational availability of the complete package. |\n| System base footprint | **250,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for system functions and shared host resources. |\n| Migration footprint allowance | **200,000 JAMKB-equivalent planning allowance** for initial support of 12 other parachains. |\n| Total footprint planning ceiling | **450,000 JAMKB-equivalent**, backed and usable throughout the protected term; actual requirements assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Always-accumulate resources | Protected always-accumulate registration and a sufficient quantified minimum allowance, assessed by the Fellowship. |\n| Control | Protected KSM authority throughout the term. |\n| Stewardship | Accepted, Fellowship-led implementation and maintenance of the agreed operating scope. |\n| Consideration | Fixed DOT amount under clause 5 for the complete package. |\n\nThe system base uses the planning model for 5 system chains (Asset Hub, Coretime, People, Bridge Hub and Encointer), shared host state and programs, 2 reusable authorizer-program blobs, 1 active and 2 additional solicited Parachain Validation Function (PVF) versions per chain, 3 host-program versions and contingency. The migration allowance provides initial support for 12 other parachains, with 1 PVF version and generic host-side state per chain plus contingency.\n\nKSM governance must define participant quotas, future upgrade backing and permissible reallocation. Participants must secure additional backing before state growth or overlapping upgrades exceed their quotas. Transitional backing may be released only once replacement backing is in place or the dependent state has been removed. The complete footprint entitlement remains protected throughout the agreed term.\n\nKSM governance may permit additional Kusama activity using separately funded JAM coretime where the implemented service supports it. Additional purchases follow their own availability, pricing and duration. Their footprint needs must fit assessed available capacity or receive additional funded provision. Such purchases do not enlarge this endowment or automatically acquire its resource protections, protected term or stewardship commitments.\n\n**3. Protected KSM control.** KSM governance retains authority over service upgrades, internal governance, monetary policy, authorizers and internal resource assignment. It determines reservations for retained functions and the permitted uses and conditions for releasing other endowed capacity. The implemented boundary must prevent ordinary unilateral revocation, reassignment or material impairment through manager and other host administrative powers. Protection covers the agreed compute, effective footprint backing, always-accumulate resources and KSM authority through host upgrades throughout the term.\n\n**4. Fellowship mandate and continued alignment.** KSM DAO delegates technical assessment, architecture, implementation, migration and maintenance to the Polkadot Fellowship under an accepted mandate. The Fellowship should assess the system base and initial migration needs separately and establish a viable arrangement for the agreed offering within the reserved compute, assessed footprint and sufficient always-accumulate resources.\n\nThe assessment should cover use of externally acquired JAM coretime by the Kusama service, including possible direct purchases by users, the associated authorization and operating requirements, and controls over endowed capacity released for use elsewhere. Material changes to the agreed package, including necessary footprint ceiling revisions, return to the relevant governance bodies. KSM governance retains material offering decisions. The mandate preserves Kusama–Polkadot alignment through shared technologies, primitives, standards and interfaces.\n\n**5. Complete-package consideration and DOT pricing.** The entire package’s reference is **US$4,320,000 = 40 CTYs × US$108,000 per CTY**, with a contribution ceiling of **5,000,000 DOT**. **D** is the UTC calendar date of the finalized block recording this individual Kusama referendum’s approval. **P90(D)** is the arithmetic mean of CoinGecko’s **00:00 UTC USD price snapshots for 1 DOT**, asset identifier **polkadot**, for all 90 completed UTC days **D−90 through D−1**, inclusive.\n\n**Fixed DOT consideration = US$4,320,000 ÷ P90(D), rounded upward to the smallest transferable DOT unit.**\n\nThe original approval date remains the pricing anchor through result certification, tie-breaking, DOT DAO voting and settlement. Its calculation fixes the complete-package offer. Once accepted by DOT DAO, that DOT amount remains unchanged despite market movements; its future USD value remains variable.\n\nA result above 5,000,000 DOT requires revised terms and renewed KSM governance before payment. This resolution provides no automatic ceiling increase, truncation of the calculated contribution, reduction of the package or substitution of another proposal.\n\n**6. Kusama Vision fund and Kusama Vision programme.** The contribution uses eligible Kusama Vision fund resources, amending WFC #498 while preserving the Kusama Vision programme and existing commitments (https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/498). Expenditure and outstanding obligations are reconciled; the remainder supports development.\n\nThis proposed arrangement is subject to acceptance by Web3 Foundation (W3F). W3F may confirm the eligible contribution through an explicit support vote or a conscious neutral abstention explicitly recorded for this round, allowing other KSM holders to decide. Ordinary nonparticipation provides no funding confirmation.\n\n**7. Consequences for Kusama.** The independent validator set, staking system and associated staking issuance and rewards retire with the completed transition. Further monetary design requires KSM decisions; deflation remains possible. KSM governance retains offering decisions and treatment of existing commitments.\n\nCoretime sales and other commitments backed by the endowment must fit its available capacity after reservations for retained functions. Parachain teams seeking capacity beyond that allocation may pursue continued hosting within the Kusama service using separately funded resources where technically supported, or migration to Polkadot under its applicable access terms. Affected teams may request a Kusama Treasury transition budget through a separate KSM funding decision.\n\n**8. Selection and bilateral acceptance.** The coordinated round consists of four infrastructure WFC proposals: 8 cores for 5 years, 6 cores for 6 years and 8 months, 4 cores for 10 years and 2 cores for 20 years. Voters may support every acceptable proposal. Each must independently satisfy the applicable approval and support thresholds.\n\nAfter all four close through approval or rejection, the passing proposal with the greatest exact final conviction-weighted AYE tally is selected. Early approval fixes its tally and pricing date while selection awaits the remaining outcomes.\n\nCancellation, killing or timeout requires a fresh governance decision for the incomplete round. Unverifiable tallies leave selection unresolved. No passing proposal means no mandate. Exact ties among the highest passing tallies require a further decision among those original approved proposals, preserving the winner’s original approval date.\n\nOnly the winner advances to Polkadot’s token-holder governance (DOT DAO) for acceptance of the complete package and fixed consideration: **One mandate and one contribution**.\n\n**Effect of this vote.** Approval establishes a political direction, financial rule and requested technical mandate, conditional on selection. Resource allocation, payment and technical changes require authorized implementation actions; the WFC itself transfers no funds and grants no technical privileges."],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x0382276c3bf113f520610005fec96cbef4f404ec7a469b3c63ac3954a7b68159","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"18116313522331481622","rejected":[35945376,{"who":"FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9","amount":33333333333},{"who":"HUCzLqog5zqQSz4GDceEDJVnmuGXzERJrHfMXwHsMvauGsE","amount":666666666660000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ad711bc9432d5e40412c08d","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22788391,"blockHash":"0x46d0bfb5852cf9d75f6cad676880d669bbd07570a23abee681c5db1768b06161","blockTime":1792479624000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"Qmbf7AFK56fGymeghRAB8qkSU2SzpYzStg7jZg33ni7GSk","createdAt":"2026-10-20T07:00:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-20T07:11:57.101Z","referendumIndex":671,"contentHash":"63f335498cf5f8e835f16b284d6f5cef"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ad711bc9432d5e40412c08d","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FhpjNasSqLTJgMtftC9HJYh7EzCzZFvwyRgvJqXZYNF1Da9"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":4},{"_id":"6acf0bfac78ea47cafb80c1a","referendumIndex":670,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22546035,"blockHash":"0x77164dee7baf6825eced8cc697e842365e27b833aadc0e318fc0fc1ddc467df3","blockTime":1791953832000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","title":"Close inactive bounties #19, #27, #33 and #38","content":"This referendum is part of the [Kusama Bounty Cleanup initiative](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-bounty-cleanup-first-steps/19009?u=rom1.io), which aims to clean up stale proposals, close inactive bounties and return unused funds to the Treasury.\n\nIt closes bounties #19, #27, #33 and #38. What is left on their accounts, about 8,972.70 KSM in total, returns to the Treasury, and each curator's deposit is returned.\n\nThe decisions are independent (`Utility.force_batch`): if a bounty changes state before enactment, only its decision fails and the others still apply.\n\n## Why\n\nThese four bounties have had no new work for months, and their remaining funds sit idle on their accounts:\n\n- **#19**: no payment since 5 Mar 2026; 3,791.66 KSM are left.\n- **#27**: no child bounty was ever created since its funding in March 2024. The full 5,102 KSM are unused.\n- **#33**: no new work since 2 Jul 2025 (its last award, from June 2025, was paid out in October 2026); 58.18 KSM are left.\n- **#38**: no activity since 28 Jul 2025 (milestones 1 to 3 paid, milestone 4 never paid); 20.86 KSM are left.\n\nClosing them returns these funds to the Treasury, where they can be allocated again. Any remaining work can still be funded through a new proposal.\n\n## Decisions\n\n\n| Bounty | Amount | Current state | Decision | Effect |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| [#19](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/19) Infrastructure Builders Program | 52,000 KSM | Active | Close and return the funds | Closed: 3,791.66 KSM go back to the treasury; the curator deposit is returned. |\n| [#27](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/27) POLKADOT <> KUSAMA BRIDGE SECURITY BOUNTY | 5,102 KSM | Active | Close and return the funds | Closed: 5,102 KSM go back to the treasury; the curator deposit is returned. |\n| [#33](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/33) KSM RFP #2 - RFP Launcher Dapp | 945 KSM | Active | Close and return the funds | Closed: 58.18 KSM go back to the treasury; the curator deposit is returned. |\n| [#38](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/38) KSM RFP #4 - BigTipper | 96 KSM | Active | Close and return the funds | Closed: 20.86 KSM go back to the treasury; the curator deposit is returned. |\n\n## Effect on the treasury\n\n| Line | Amount | When |\n|---|---:|---|\n| Returned to the treasury | +8,972.7 KSM | at enactment |\n| **Net for the treasury** | **+8,972.7 KSM** | |\n\nFor scale: the treasury holds 910,833.26 KSM available at block #22,545,977 (14 Oct 2026, 04:54 UTC); this referendum returns 8,972.7 KSM to it when enacted. It will have moved by enactment.\n\n## The bounties today\n\nRead on Kusama Asset Hub at block #22,545,977 (14 Oct 2026, 04:54 UTC); history from our indexer, which re-reads the chain.\n\n**#19 Infrastructure Builders Program**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Active |\n| Value voted | 52,000 KSM |\n| Proposer | `HERTWZ…ifafdU` (bond 0.043667 KSM) |\n| Curator | `DDzazS…JYoHte` (fee 0 KSM, deposit 0.003333 KSM) |\n| Money | 52,000 KSM voted, 3,791.66 KSM left |\n| Payments | 300 child bounties paid 48,208.34 KSM, from 6 Feb 2023 to 5 Mar 2026 |\n| Child bounties | 0 open |\n| Referenda | #51 (approval): approved on 18 Jan 2023; #73 (curator): approved on 31 Jan 2023; #191 (close): timedout on 25 May 2023 |\n| History | proposed 3 Jan 2023 → funded 24 Jan 2023 → deadline extended ×13 (25 Apr 2023 to 21 Jul 2025) |\n| Last activity | child #19/54 paid out on 5 Mar 2026 |\n\n**#27 POLKADOT <> KUSAMA BRIDGE SECURITY BOUNTY**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Active |\n| Value voted | 5,102 KSM |\n| Proposer | `Fy6erZ…VX33xz` (bond 0.047 KSM) |\n| Curator | `Gdxia9…jwrrTR` (fee 0 KSM, deposit 0.003333 KSM) |\n| Money | 5,102 KSM voted, 5,102 KSM left |\n| Child bounties | none ever created |\n| Referenda | #353 (approval): approved on 15 Mar 2024; #363 (curator): approved on 9 Apr 2024; #468 (curator): approved on 22 Nov 2024; #583 (curator): approved on 11 Sept 2025 |\n| History | proposed 1 Mar 2024 → approved 16 Mar 2024 (ref #353) → funded 20 Mar 2024 → curator proposed 10 Apr 2024 (ref #363) → curator accepted 30 Jul 2024 → curator removed 1 Nov 2024 → curator proposed 23 Nov 2024 (ref #468) → curator accepted 6 Jan 2025 → deadline extended ×2 (17 Mar 2025 to 6 Jun 2025) → curator removed 11 Sept 2025 → curator proposed 12 Sept 2025 (ref #583) → curator accepted 13 Sept 2025 |\n\n**#33 KSM RFP #2 - RFP Launcher Dapp**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Active |\n| Value voted | 945 KSM |\n| Proposer | `E5qFqe…Wvtqrg` (bond 0.034333 KSM) |\n| Curator | `Fw6jim…eQedrk` (fee 0 KSM, deposit 0.003333 KSM) |\n| Money | 945 KSM voted, 58.18 KSM left |\n| Payments | 7 child bounties paid 953.98 KSM, from 1 Jul 2025 to 13 Oct 2026 |\n| Child bounties | 0 open |\n| Referenda | #513 (approval + curator): approved on 16 Apr 2025 |\n| History | proposed 31 Mar 2025 → approved 17 Apr 2025 (ref #513) → funded 19 Apr 2025 → curator proposed 24 Apr 2025 → curator accepted 29 Apr 2025 |\n| Note | paid (953.98 KSM) plus left (58.18 KSM) is 1,012.16 KSM, 67.16 KSM more than voted. This amount reached the bounty outside its votes (a direct transfer to its account or to one of its children's accounts). |\n| Note | the curator's update deadline (relay block 29,435,381) has passed: anyone can now remove the curator |\n| Last activity | child #33/0 paid out on 13 Oct 2026 |\n\n**#38 KSM RFP #4 - BigTipper**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Active |\n| Value voted | 96 KSM |\n| Proposer | `E5qFqe…Wvtqrg` (bond 0.034067 KSM) |\n| Curator | `GBdGQC…q3ygTP` (fee 0 KSM, deposit 0.003333 KSM) |\n| Money | 96 KSM voted, 20.86 KSM left |\n| Payments | 3 child bounties paid 75.14 KSM: 26.24 KSM on 2 Jul 2025, 26.7 KSM on 9 Jul 2025, 22.2 KSM on 28 Jul 2025 |\n| Child bounties | 0 open |\n| Referenda | #529 (approval with curator): approved on 1 Jun 2025 |\n| History | proposed 23 May 2025 → approved 2 Jun 2025 (ref #529) → curator proposed 2 Jun 2025 (ref #529) → funded 7 Jun 2025 → curator accepted 2 Jul 2025 |\n| Note | the curator's update deadline (relay block 30,346,925) has passed: anyone can now remove the curator |\n| Last activity | child #38/2 paid out on 28 Jul 2025 |\n\n## Technical details\n\n| Item | Value |\n|---|---|\n| Chain | Kusama Asset Hub (`statemine` v2003002), block #22,545,977 |\n| Referendum | #670 expected (numbers are assigned on submission) |\n| Track | Treasurer (track 11), origin `Origins.Treasurer` |\n| Call | `Utility.force_batch(calls: [Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 19), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 27), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 33), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 38)])` |\n| Proposal | Inline, 15 bytes: `0x2804105f074c5f076c5f07845f0798` |\n| Call hash | `0x88c918d45eae4192110739c6d52b3d5022f05183a4dfe7e1dcf1b8c1c2f88779` (blake2-256) |\n| Deposits | submission 0.0333 KSM, decision 33.3333 KSM |\n| Timing | 2 h preparation, up to 14 days deciding, 2 days confirmation, enactment at least 24 h after approval |\n| Treasury effect | +8,972.7 KSM |\n| Dry run | passed at block #22,545,977 |\n\n## Testing\n\nThe exact proposal above was dry-run with `DryRunApi.dry_run_call`, origin `Origins.Treasurer`, against the state of live Kusama Asset Hub at block #22,545,977 (14 Oct 2026, 04:54 UTC) (`statemine` v2003002). Nothing was submitted. A dry run shows what the call would do on the state of that block; it does not guarantee the result at enactment.\n\nResult: **Ok**, 4 of 4 calls applied.\n\nEffects: 4 × `Balances.Unreserved`, 4 × `Balances.Transfer`, 4 × `Bounties.BountyCanceled`.\n\n| # | Event |\n|---|---|\n| 1 | `Balances.Unreserved { who: DDzazS9qxXPmm4t8vX8zpCBzFcDuhKD3BNKqmXxtbJYoHte, amount: 0.0033 KSM }` |\n| 2 | `Balances.Transfer { from: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNead6MsJmhobHNZgLUbzKWrHCBh, to: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 3,791.66 KSM }` |\n| 3 | `Bounties.BountyCanceled { index: 19 }` |\n| 4 | `Balances.Unreserved { who: Gdxia95Ti5REcK1MLjgg681cq3U9fKBvfRZdjKAZ9jwrrTR, amount: 0.0033 KSM }` |\n| 5 | `Balances.Transfer { from: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNg3Zu984LQJ8dH51aQV9bg8boAb, to: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 5,102 KSM }` |\n| 6 | `Bounties.BountyCanceled { index: 27 }` |\n| 7 | `Balances.Unreserved { who: Fw6jimeopqaUo9A8QdDQ5ZyGY7JTdqcm2ycH3iqnkeQedrk, amount: 0.0033 KSM }` |\n| 8 | `Balances.Transfer { from: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNh9H1E4d1RfY8hx1WMQ24J6LqG8, to: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 58.18 KSM }` |\n| 9 | `Bounties.BountyCanceled { index: 33 }` |\n| 10 | `Balances.Unreserved { who: GBdGQCQH2Kha4JLtub27VaBqXyw2ZdMqXTgwDomtAq3ygTP, amount: 0.0033 KSM }` |\n| 11 | `Balances.Transfer { from: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNi4NFxr6EcUNiu1qnJpk79Po2cq, to: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 20.86 KSM }` |\n| 12 | `Bounties.BountyCanceled { index: 38 }` |\n\n13 bookkeeping events left out (4 zero-amount releases, 4 emptied accounts and 5 batch markers); the dry run in \"Verify it yourself\" lists them all.\n\nNot covered: the vote itself, and what may change before enactment: the curator opening a child bounty or awarding the bounty; anyone removing the curator of #33, whose update deadline has passed (the closure should still return the funds, but the curator's deposit is then slashed; not dry-run in that state); anyone removing the curator of #38, whose update deadline has passed (the closure should still return the funds, but the curator's deposit is then slashed; not dry-run in that state). The call is checked again when it runs: a decision whose bounty moved fails alone, the other decisions still apply (`Utility.force_batch`).\n\n## Verify it yourself\n\n1. **Decode the call.** In [Polkadot.js Apps → Extrinsics → Decode](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/extrinsics/decode), paste the proposal bytes `0x2804105f074c5f076c5f07845f0798`. It should read `Utility.force_batch(calls: [Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 19), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 27), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 33), Bounties.close_bo…`.\n2. **Check the state.** In [Developer → Chain state](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/chainstate), query `bounties.bounties(19)`, `bounties.bounties(27)`, `bounties.bounties(33)`, `bounties.bounties(38)`: the state must match \"Current state\" above.\n3. **Run the dry run.** In [Developer → Runtime calls](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/runtime), call `dryRunApi.dryRunCall` with origin `Origins → Treasurer`, the call above and XCM version 5: the result should be `Ok` with the events listed in Testing.\n\n## References\n\n| | Account | Links |\n|---|---|---|\n| #19 Infrastructure Builders Program: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNead6MsJmhobHNZgLUbzKWrHCBh` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/19) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNead6MsJmhobHNZgLUbzKWrHCBh) |\n| #19: proposer | `HERTWZK4ZpmuXsEgW3UfL5x27XCdT5fE9x4QRbyNWifafdU` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/HERTWZK4ZpmuXsEgW3UfL5x27XCdT5fE9x4QRbyNWifafdU) |\n| #19: curator | `DDzazS9qxXPmm4t8vX8zpCBzFcDuhKD3BNKqmXxtbJYoHte` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/DDzazS9qxXPmm4t8vX8zpCBzFcDuhKD3BNKqmXxtbJYoHte) |\n| #27 POLKADOT <> KUSAMA BRIDGE SECURITY BOUNTY: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNg3Zu984LQJ8dH51aQV9bg8boAb` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/27) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNg3Zu984LQJ8dH51aQV9bg8boAb) |\n| #27: proposer | `Fy6erZmPp78ZY2cN945FU9KnKdATmxvG2eB9a1kh2VX33xz` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/Fy6erZmPp78ZY2cN945FU9KnKdATmxvG2eB9a1kh2VX33xz) |\n| #27: curator | `Gdxia95Ti5REcK1MLjgg681cq3U9fKBvfRZdjKAZ9jwrrTR` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/Gdxia95Ti5REcK1MLjgg681cq3U9fKBvfRZdjKAZ9jwrrTR) |\n| #33 KSM RFP #2 - RFP Launcher Dapp: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNh9H1E4d1RfY8hx1WMQ24J6LqG8` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/33) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNh9H1E4d1RfY8hx1WMQ24J6LqG8) |\n| #33: proposer | `E5qFqe5g5iS4Byu4hyKLAavayXtCiuuuK4xzuLcnQWvtqrg` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/E5qFqe5g5iS4Byu4hyKLAavayXtCiuuuK4xzuLcnQWvtqrg) |\n| #33: curator | `Fw6jimeopqaUo9A8QdDQ5ZyGY7JTdqcm2ycH3iqnkeQedrk` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/Fw6jimeopqaUo9A8QdDQ5ZyGY7JTdqcm2ycH3iqnkeQedrk) |\n| #38 KSM RFP #4 - BigTipper: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNi4NFxr6EcUNiu1qnJpk79Po2cq` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/38) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNi4NFxr6EcUNiu1qnJpk79Po2cq) |\n| #38: proposer | `E5qFqe5g5iS4Byu4hyKLAavayXtCiuuuK4xzuLcnQWvtqrg` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/E5qFqe5g5iS4Byu4hyKLAavayXtCiuuuK4xzuLcnQWvtqrg) |\n| #38: curator | `GBdGQCQH2Kha4JLtub27VaBqXyw2ZdMqXTgwDomtAq3ygTP` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/GBdGQCQH2Kha4JLtub27VaBqXyw2ZdMqXTgwDomtAq3ygTP) |\n| Kusama treasury: receives the returned funds | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29) |\n","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-10-14T04:57:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-14T05:00:32.541Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-28T08:30:00.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23109172,"blockHash":"0x42122d5af0bef79df2ce5e452fd46ad1245b6a19f0fbe9b7a1fe1aa42895d49a","blockTime":1793176200000,"eventIndex":25},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmQJwLCV77NLxg96qUKdB1Fw3knugSN5Dd6tyin8zczE7h","contentHash":"48d8f87b40c999467e35cb76853f5119","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"48d8f87b40c999467e35cb76853f5119","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Bounty Cleanup Referendum\n\n## What is this?\nThis is a vote to close four old Kusama bounties that are no longer being used. A bounty is like a money jar set aside for a special job.\n\n## Which bounties are closing?\nThe vote closes bounties number 19, 27, 33, and 38. None of them have had new work for many months.\n\n## Why close them?\nThe money in these jars has been sitting still and doing nothing. Closing them lets the money go back to the Kusama Treasury.\n\n## How much money comes back?\nAbout 8,972.7 KSM returns to the Treasury when this vote passes. KSM is the money used on Kusama.\n\n## What if one bounty has changed?\nEach bounty is decided on its own. If one bounty changes before the vote finishes, only that one fails. The others still close.\n\n## Did anyone test it first?\nYes. The plan was tested on a copy of the real Kusama chain. All four bounties closed correctly in the test.\n\n## How do I check it myself?\nYou can decode the call, check the bounty states, and run the same test using Polkadot.js Apps, following the steps in the post."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6acf0be4cd583df1184b751a","referendumIndex":670,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22546035,"blockHash":"0x77164dee7baf6825eced8cc697e842365e27b833aadc0e318fc0fc1ddc467df3","blockTime":1791953832000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","authors":["EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x2804","section":"utility","method":"forceBatch"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23109172,"blockHash":"0x42122d5af0bef79df2ce5e452fd46ad1245b6a19f0fbe9b7a1fe1aa42895d49a","blockTime":1793176200000,"eventIndex":25},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x2804105f074c5f076c5f07845f0798"},"enactment":{"after":0},"submitted":35655927,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":35657800,"confirming":35839903},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001e33b98aa0886400","nays":1920000000000000,"support":"0x00000000000000001e222d0c056eb800"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35839903,[35839903,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001e33b98aa0886400","nays":1920000000000000,"support":"0x00000000000000001e222d0c056eb800","electorate":"18109929023032581658"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x2804105f074c5f076c5f07845f0798","hash":"0x88c918d45eae4192110739c6d52b3d5022f05183a4dfe7e1dcf1b8c1c2f88779","call":{"callIndex":"0x2804","section":"utility","method":"forceBatch","args":[{"name":"calls","type":"Vec<Call>","value":[{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":19}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":27}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":33}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":38}]}]}]}},"proposalHash":"0x88c918d45eae4192110739c6d52b3d5022f05183a4dfe7e1dcf1b8c1c2f88779","treasuryBounties":[{"index":19,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":27,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":33,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":38,"method":"closeBounty"}],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35854303,"index":0},"approved":[35839903,{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333},{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333000}],"electorate":"18109929023032581658","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":22987131,"blockHash":"0x6b32885b133035be425609f48dafdb309d3ef5cc7a4d3e8d6108d9be4125924d","blockTime":1792910184000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6acf0be4cd583df1184b751c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22546035,"blockHash":"0x77164dee7baf6825eced8cc697e842365e27b833aadc0e318fc0fc1ddc467df3","blockTime":1791953832000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmQJwLCV77NLxg96qUKdB1Fw3knugSN5Dd6tyin8zczE7h","createdAt":"2026-10-14T04:57:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-14T05:00:32.541Z","referendumIndex":670,"contentHash":"48d8f87b40c999467e35cb76853f5119"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6acf0be4cd583df1184b751c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x641768da63aab1ad01b2ffed1a44b41c4475f3efdcb74d1e45cf3c490db0c11b","publicKey":"641768da63aab1ad01b2ffed1a44b41c4475f3efdcb74d1e45cf3c490db0c11b","emailMd5":"7dbaa2cbffb0e342b3b2b12191d99d18","address":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"6acf09d7c78ea47cafb49659","referendumIndex":669,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22545819,"blockHash":"0xbeb83f1b0bff62b316a9d77424c0a8906c19552cb76670e95df0fcc14cbb9220","blockTime":1791953304000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","title":"Reject proposed bounties #34, #35, #36, #37, #39","content":"This referendum is part of the [Kusama Bounty Cleanup initiative](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-bounty-cleanup-first-steps/19009?u=rom1.io), which aims to clear stale proposals and inactive bounties from Kusama's bounty system.\n\nIt rejects five stale bounty proposals: #34, #35, #36, #37 and #39. Their requested budgets were never approved or set aside; rejection removes them from the list.\n\nThe decisions are independent (`Utility.force_batch`): if a bounty changes state before enactment, only its decision fails and the others still apply.\n\n\n## Why\n\nThese five bounty proposals have been in the Proposed state for 13 to 18 months, and none can move forward:\n\n- **#34**: its approval (with a curator) was put to a vote in referendum #517, which was rejected on 24 Apr 2025.\n- **#35, #36, #37**: their approval was put to a vote in referendum #632, which was rejected on 10 Feb 2026. The same three topics have since been funded as multi-asset bounties MA-0, MA-1 and MA-2 (referenda #647–#649, approved on 19 May 2026), so these proposals are no longer needed (the link rests on matching titles; it is not recorded on chain).\n- **#39**: no referendum has ever proposed to approve it.\n\nNone of them was ever funded, so rejecting them returns no budget. The only funds that move are the proposers' bonds (0.169667 KSM in total), which the Bounties pallet slashes to the Treasury on every rejection; this is how the pallet works, not a penalty chosen for these proposals. Rejecting them clears proposals that can no longer progress.\n\n## Decisions\n\n| Bounty | Amount | Current state | Decision | Effect |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| [#34](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/34) KSM RFP#3 - Kusama.App | 8,000 KSM | Proposed | Reject | Rejected: the proposal is removed and the proposer bond (0.034067 KSM) is slashed. |\n| [#35](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/35) Zero-Knowledge and Advanced Cryptography | 1 KSM | Proposed | Reject | Rejected: the proposal is removed and the proposer bond (0.034667 KSM) is slashed. |\n| [#36](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/36) Proof-of-Personhood | 1 KSM | Proposed | Reject | Rejected: the proposal is removed and the proposer bond (0.033967 KSM) is slashed. |\n| [#37](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/37) Art | 1 KSM | Proposed | Reject | Rejected: the proposal is removed and the proposer bond (0.033433 KSM) is slashed. |\n| [#39](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/39) Bounty | 434.25 KSM | Proposed | Reject | Rejected: the proposal is removed and the proposer bond (0.033533 KSM) is slashed. |\n\n## Effect on the treasury\n\n| Line | Amount | When |\n|---|---:|---|\n| Requested amounts (never approved, never set aside) | 0 | — |\n| Proposer bonds slashed to the treasury | +0.169667 KSM | at enactment |\n| **Net for the treasury** | **+0.169667 KSM** | |\n\nFor scale: the treasury holds 910,833.26 KSM available at block #22,545,764 (14 Oct 2026, 04:45 UTC); this referendum adds 0.169667 KSM to it when enacted. It will have moved by enactment.\n\n## The bounties today\n\nRead on Kusama Asset Hub at block #22,545,764 (14 Oct 2026, 04:45 UTC); history from our indexer, which re-reads the chain.\n\n**#34 KSM RFP#3 - Kusama.App**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Proposed |\n| Value requested | 8,000 KSM |\n| Proposer | `EvoLan…2JoVus` (bond 0.034067 KSM) |\n| Referenda | #517 (approval + curator): rejected on 24 Apr 2025 |\n| History | proposed 8 Apr 2025 |\n\n**#35 Zero-Knowledge and Advanced Cryptography**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Proposed |\n| Value requested | 1 KSM |\n| Proposer | `JFArxq…ygnYVt` (bond 0.034667 KSM) |\n| Referenda | #632 (approval with curator): rejected on 10 Feb 2026 |\n| History | proposed 19 May 2025 |\n| Same subject as | MA-2 “ZERO KNOWLEDGE PROOFS” |\n\n**#36 Proof-of-Personhood**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Proposed |\n| Value requested | 1 KSM |\n| Proposer | `JFArxq…ygnYVt` (bond 0.033967 KSM) |\n| Referenda | #632 (approval with curator): rejected on 10 Feb 2026 |\n| History | proposed 19 May 2025 |\n| Same subject as | MA-0 “PROOF OF PERSONHOOD” |\n\n**#37 Art**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Proposed |\n| Value requested | 1 KSM |\n| Proposer | `JFArxq…ygnYVt` (bond 0.033433 KSM) |\n| Referenda | #632 (approval with curator): rejected on 10 Feb 2026 |\n| History | proposed 19 May 2025 |\n| Same subject as | MA-1 “ART & SOCIAL EXPERIMENTS” |\n\n**#39 Bounty**\n\n| | |\n|---|---|\n| State | Proposed |\n| Value requested | 434.25 KSM |\n| Proposer | `GXTP7t…zkjXvQ` (bond 0.033533 KSM) |\n| Referenda | none has ever proposed to approve it |\n| History | proposed 11 Sept 2025 |\n\n## Technical details\n\n| Item | Value |\n|---|---|\n| Chain | Kusama Asset Hub (`statemine` v2003002), block #22,545,764 |\n| Referendum | #669 expected (numbers are assigned on submission) |\n| Track | Treasurer (track 11), origin `Origins.Treasurer` |\n| Call | `Utility.force_batch(calls: [Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 34), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 35), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 36), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 37), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 39)])` |\n| Proposal | Inline, 18 bytes: `0x2804145f07885f078c5f07905f07945f079c` |\n| Call hash | `0x633f7b0eae4d46fe54db511a3b5dde0036334da85f7c3aaa1e99258e90ccef86` (blake2-256) |\n| Deposits | submission 0.0333 KSM, decision 33.3333 KSM |\n| Timing | 2 h preparation, up to 14 days deciding, 2 days confirmation, enactment at least 24 h after approval |\n| Treasury effect | +0.169667 KSM |\n| Dry run | passed at block #22,545,764 |\n\n## Testing\n\nThe exact proposal above was dry-run with `DryRunApi.dry_run_call`, origin `Origins.Treasurer`, against the state of live Kusama Asset Hub at block #22,545,764 (14 Oct 2026, 04:45 UTC) (`statemine` v2003002). Nothing was submitted. A dry run shows what the call would do on the state of that block; it does not guarantee the result at enactment.\n\nResult: **Ok**, 5 of 5 calls applied.\n\nEffects: 5 × `Balances.Slashed`, 5 × `Balances.Deposit`, 5 × `Bounties.BountyRejected`.\n\n| # | Event |\n|---|---|\n| 1 | `Balances.Slashed { who: EvoLanodoqDsgHb98Ymbu41uXXKfCPDKxeM6dXHyJ2JoVus, amount: 0.034 KSM }` |\n| 2 | `Balances.Deposit { who: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 0.034 KSM }` |\n| 3 | `Bounties.BountyRejected { index: 34, bond: 0.034 KSM }` |\n| 4 | `Balances.Slashed { who: JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt, amount: 0.0346 KSM }` |\n| 5 | `Balances.Deposit { who: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 0.0346 KSM }` |\n| 6 | `Bounties.BountyRejected { index: 35, bond: 0.0346 KSM }` |\n| 7 | `Balances.Slashed { who: JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt, amount: 0.0339 KSM }` |\n| 8 | `Balances.Deposit { who: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 0.0339 KSM }` |\n| 9 | `Bounties.BountyRejected { index: 36, bond: 0.0339 KSM }` |\n| 10 | `Balances.Slashed { who: JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt, amount: 0.0334 KSM }` |\n| 11 | `Balances.Deposit { who: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 0.0334 KSM }` |\n| 12 | `Bounties.BountyRejected { index: 37, bond: 0.0334 KSM }` |\n| 13 | `Balances.Slashed { who: GXTP7tTQHhN3u4Y5a9Xius8qXF5arrPcRAnHZaDtzzkjXvQ, amount: 0.0335 KSM }` |\n| 14 | `Balances.Deposit { who: F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29, amount: 0.0335 KSM }` |\n| 15 | `Bounties.BountyRejected { index: 39, bond: 0.0335 KSM }` |\n\n11 bookkeeping events left out (5 treasury deposit echoes and 6 batch markers); the dry run in \"Verify it yourself\" lists them all.\n\nNot covered: the vote itself, and what may change before enactment: another referendum approving one of these proposals. The call is checked again when it runs: a decision whose bounty moved fails alone, the other decisions still apply (`Utility.force_batch`).\n\n## Verify it yourself\n\n1. **Decode the call.** In [Polkadot.js Apps → Extrinsics → Decode](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/extrinsics/decode), paste the proposal bytes `0x2804145f07885f078c5f07905f07945f079c`. It should read `Utility.force_batch(calls: [Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 34), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 35), Bounties.close_bounty(bounty_id: 36), Bounties.close_bo…`.\n2. **Check the state.** In [Developer → Chain state](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/chainstate), query `bounties.bounties(34)`, `bounties.bounties(35)`, `bounties.bounties(36)`, `bounties.bounties(37)`, `bounties.bounties(39)`: the state must match \"Current state\" above.\n3. **Run the dry run.** In [Developer → Runtime calls](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/runtime), call `dryRunApi.dryRunCall` with origin `Origins → Treasurer`, the call above and XCM version 5: the result should be `Ok` with the events listed in Testing.\n\n## References\n\n| | Account | Links |\n|---|---|---|\n| #34 KSM RFP#3 - Kusama.App: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhKtraDiTGE73wmBALtAU4kdgNX` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/34) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhKtraDiTGE73wmBALtAU4kdgNX) |\n| #34: proposer | `EvoLanodoqDsgHb98Ymbu41uXXKfCPDKxeM6dXHyJ2JoVus` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/EvoLanodoqDsgHb98Ymbu41uXXKfCPDKxeM6dXHyJ2JoVus) |\n| #35 Zero-Knowledge and Advanced Cryptography: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhWWhvNou6nfyBaLpLNJsqQvgRk` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/35) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhWWhvNou6nfyBaLpLNJsqQvgRk) |\n| #35: proposer | `JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt) |\n| #36 Proof-of-Personhood: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhh8ZGXuLwMEtRPWUKrTHc5DHpz` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/36) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhh8ZGXuLwMEtRPWUKrTHc5DHpz) |\n| #36: proposer | `JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt) |\n| #37 Art: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhskQcgznmuoofCg8KLbhNjWGAj` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/37) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNhskQcgznmuoofCg8KLbhNjWGAj) |\n| #37: proposer | `JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/JFArxqV6rqPSwBok3zQDnj5jL6vwsZQDwYXXqb1cFygnYVt) |\n| #39 Bounty: bounty account | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNiEz7K1BgT2we8q1SJJtWv45sRY` | [Subsquare](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/bounties/39) · [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNiEz7K1BgT2we8q1SJJtWv45sRY) |\n| #39: proposer | `GXTP7tTQHhN3u4Y5a9Xius8qXF5arrPcRAnHZaDtzzkjXvQ` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/GXTP7tTQHhN3u4Y5a9Xius8qXF5arrPcRAnHZaDtzzkjXvQ) |\n| Kusama treasury: receives the slashed bonds | `F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29` | [Subscan](https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/account/F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU511Kj2TLuzFcDq9BGduA9TgiECafpg29) |\n","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-10-14T04:48:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-14T04:54:11.677Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-28T08:30:48.000Z","cid":"QmUcMapNcN8ycXuGgHbAEYystkJUoPiYFjHELi8LC7HWW8","contentHash":"7c5eda08f6b673facfc6a5e81aba992d","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23109202,"blockHash":"0x3b3b6725bd9f3ffdf7ac3fc3da517634b7d1f011804a7c6ad55cf6d4ea0f46da","blockTime":1793176248000,"eventIndex":26},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"7c5eda08f6b673facfc6a5e81aba992d","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Bounty Cleanup Referendum\n\nThis is a vote to clean up old, stuck bounty ideas on Kusama.\n\n## What it does\n\n- It says \"no\" to five old bounty ideas: #34, #35, #36, #37, and #39.\n- These ideas never got any money, so saying \"no\" doesn't cost anything.\n- Each proposer put up a small deposit (called a bond) to make the idea.\n- When we say \"no\", those small deposits go to the treasury. This is normal, not a punishment.\n- All five are decided separately, so if one fails, the others still work.\n\n## Why we clean them up\n\n- These ideas have been sitting and waiting for 13 to 18 months.\n- People already voted \"no\" on some of them before.\n- #35, #36, and #37 are about the same topics as newer bounties that got approved instead.\n- #39 was never even voted on.\n\n## The money part\n\n- No budget is returned, because none was ever given.\n- The treasury gains about 0.17 KSM from the small deposits.\n\n## Checking it\n\n- A test run was done on the live chain before submitting.\n- The test showed all five bounties would be closed and rejected.\n- Anyone can check the plan by decoding the call on Polkadot.js Apps.\n\n## Good to know\n\n- This only closes the ideas. It doesn't change votes already made.\n- If a bounty changes before this passes, only that one fails, the rest still work."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6acf09cecd583df1184b4895","referendumIndex":669,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22545819,"blockHash":"0xbeb83f1b0bff62b316a9d77424c0a8906c19552cb76670e95df0fcc14cbb9220","blockTime":1791953304000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","authors":["EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x2804","section":"utility","method":"forceBatch"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23109202,"blockHash":"0x3b3b6725bd9f3ffdf7ac3fc3da517634b7d1f011804a7c6ad55cf6d4ea0f46da","blockTime":1793176248000,"eventIndex":26},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x2804145f07885f078c5f07905f07945f079c"},"enactment":{"after":0},"submitted":35655843,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":35657810,"confirming":35839913},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001e33bf9ac3260880","nays":0,"support":"0x00000000000000001e22331c280c5c80"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35839913,[35839913,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001e33bf9ac3260880","nays":0,"support":"0x00000000000000001e22331c280c5c80","electorate":"18109930562029781385"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x2804145f07885f078c5f07905f07945f079c","hash":"0x633f7b0eae4d46fe54db511a3b5dde0036334da85f7c3aaa1e99258e90ccef86","call":{"callIndex":"0x2804","section":"utility","method":"forceBatch","args":[{"name":"calls","type":"Vec<Call>","value":[{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":34}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":35}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":36}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":37}]},{"callIndex":"0x5f07","section":"bounties","method":"closeBounty","args":[{"name":"bountyId","type":"Compact<u32>","value":39}]}]}]}},"proposalHash":"0x633f7b0eae4d46fe54db511a3b5dde0036334da85f7c3aaa1e99258e90ccef86","treasuryBounties":[{"index":34,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":35,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":36,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":37,"method":"closeBounty"},{"index":39,"method":"closeBounty"}],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35854313,"index":0},"approved":[35839913,{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333},{"who":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs","amount":33333333333000}],"electorate":"18109930562029781385","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":22987161,"blockHash":"0xc6a3252828a9df5b2b93a544aa8a24e9f88f45e7d9773fd282decdd4d44a1cb7","blockTime":1792910256000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6acf09cecd583df1184b4897","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22545819,"blockHash":"0xbeb83f1b0bff62b316a9d77424c0a8906c19552cb76670e95df0fcc14cbb9220","blockTime":1791953304000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmUcMapNcN8ycXuGgHbAEYystkJUoPiYFjHELi8LC7HWW8","createdAt":"2026-10-14T04:48:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-14T04:54:11.677Z","referendumIndex":669,"contentHash":"7c5eda08f6b673facfc6a5e81aba992d"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6acf09cecd583df1184b4897","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x641768da63aab1ad01b2ffed1a44b41c4475f3efdcb74d1e45cf3c490db0c11b","publicKey":"641768da63aab1ad01b2ffed1a44b41c4475f3efdcb74d1e45cf3c490db0c11b","emailMd5":"7dbaa2cbffb0e342b3b2b12191d99d18","address":"EqZG45vbcbgCyEF15jrcZwsThNEu4gCAdbGjJTacV9rDnCs"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6ac6bf32a04636a85dbabf24","referendumIndex":668,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22289250,"blockHash":"0x532e49b1301987bedda367a9a01ab7fed4c0955278413003606da80a69376def","blockTime":1791409896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ","title":"[Whitelisted Caller] Unblock Referendum 664: free the Root track's stuck deciding slot","content":"## Summary\n\nReferendum 664 has been waiting in the Root track queue since relay block 35,318,657. The Root track allows one deciding referendum at a time. Its counter, `DecidingCount(0)`, reads 1, but no Root referendum is deciding, so 664 can never start.\n\nThis referendum calls `referenda.one_fewer_deciding(0)` as Root, through the Whitelisted Caller track. With 664 alone in the queue, the call starts 664's decision period. The counter stays at 1 and from then on counts a real referendum.\n\n## The call\n\n| | |\n| --- | --- |\n| Proposal (inline) | `0x5e035c060000` |\n| Decoded | `whitelist.dispatch_whitelisted_call_with_preimage(referenda.one_fewer_deciding(0))` |\n| hash to be Whitelisted  | `0x2889dc24ab38fab7212e6f81adde354da22e3a24fc717dbf660e52e32afecf87` (blake2-256 of `0x5c060000`) |\n\n## Why the Whitelisted Caller track\n\nA Root-track referendum would queue behind 664 on the same blocked track and never start. The Fellowship whitelists the hash, and this track 1 referendum dispatches the call as Root.\n\n## Testing\n\nOn a Chopsticks fork of live Kusama Asset Hub (block 22,276,769), this exact call went through submission, the Fellowship's whitelist XCM, voting and enactment. It moved 664 from the Root queue into Deciding. The live relay chain's dry run confirms the Fellowship sends the same whitelist message.\n\nFull test report, with steps to verify everything yourself: [Link](https://github.com/dhirajs0/polkadot-governance/blob/main/kusama/referendum-664-root-track-fix/README.md)\n\n## Verify in two minutes\n\n1. Paste `0x5e035c060000` into [Polkadot.js Apps → Extrinsics → Decode](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/extrinsics/decode). It should decode to `referenda.oneFewerDeciding(track: 0)` wrapped in `whitelist.dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage`.\n2. In [Chain state](https://polkadot.js.org/apps/?rpc=wss%3A%2F%2Fkusama-asset-hub-rpc.polkadot.io#/chainstate), `referenda.decidingCount(0)` returns `1` and `referenda.trackQueue(0)` holds only `664`.\n\n## Out of scope\n\nTrack 1 (Whitelisted Caller) is also off by one: its counter reads 1 with no referendum deciding. With 100 slots it blocks nothing, and this referendum does not touch it.\n","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-10-07T21:51:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-13T10:30:11.120Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-13T10:30:11.120Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":22514363,"blockHash":"0xd0728b8cbac0cb41e4e458dfcdb3c53f30f55c0927764cd4c8a8e5c7353962b8","blockTime":1791885648000,"eventIndex":3},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmfFCpkYWzDpKJyYBYSzDdkNwnipy1HDJqL6QsWa8SCNwB","contentHash":"f4490ab19f5aeba5c6356aa5d4045ff0","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"f4490ab19f5aeba5c6356aa5d4045ff0","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Referendum 664 Root Track Fix\n\n**Referendum 664** is a vote on the **Kusama** network. It got stuck because of a counting mistake.\n\n## The Problem\n- Referendum 664 was waiting in a line called the **Root track**.\n- The Root track only lets **one** referendum happen at a time.\n- A counter said \"1\" was already happening, but **no referendum was actually happening**.\n- So 664 could never start.\n\n## The Fix\n- The referendum asks the system to lower the counter by one: `one_fewer_deciding(0)`.\n- It does this through a special track called the **Whitelisted Caller** track.\n- Once the counter is fixed, 664 can start its voting period.\n\n## Why Use the Whitelisted Caller Track?\n- A normal Root vote would get stuck behind 664 in the same line.\n- So instead, the **Fellowship** (a group of trusted members) approves the call.\n- Then it gets sent as Root.\n\n## Testing\n- They tested it on a **copy of Kusama** (called a fork).\n- Everything worked: the call passed, the Fellowship approved it, people voted, and it happened.\n- This moved 664 out of the waiting line and into voting.\n\n## How You Can Check It Yourself\n1. Go to Polkadot.js Apps and paste `0x5e035c060000` to decode the call.\n2. Check the chain state — the counter shows `1` and only 664 is in the queue.\n\n## Not Part of This Fix\n- Track 1 (Whitelisted Caller) also has a counting problem.\n- But it has 100 slots, so nothing is blocked, and this fix does not touch it."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ac6bf24d5df5ee73119ff94","referendumIndex":668,"indexer":{"blockHeight":22289250,"blockHash":"0x532e49b1301987bedda367a9a01ab7fed4c0955278413003606da80a69376def","blockTime":1791409896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ","authors":["JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":22514363,"blockHash":"0xd0728b8cbac0cb41e4e458dfcdb3c53f30f55c0927764cd4c8a8e5c7353962b8","blockTime":1791885648000,"eventIndex":3},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x5e035c060000"},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":35567911,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":35574934,"confirming":35644800},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000028acdd2c55da000","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018b0f8ca2b025000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35644800,[35644800,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000028acdd2c55da000","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018b0f8ca2b025000","electorate":"18068599622804706933"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0x2889dc24ab38fab7212e6f81adde354da22e3a24fc717dbf660e52e32afecf87"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x5e035c060000","hash":"0x886f7270048667f524fd3a0c9bd71e536ef1042302a6ab7d292c7ec9db9b8c81","call":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage","args":[{"name":"call","type":"Call","value":{"callIndex":"0x5c06","section":"referenda","method":"oneFewerDeciding","args":[{"name":"track","type":"u16","value":0}]}}]}},"proposalHash":"0x886f7270048667f524fd3a0c9bd71e536ef1042302a6ab7d292c7ec9db9b8c81","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35644900,"index":0},"approved":[35644800,{"who":"JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ","amount":33333333333},{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"18068599622804706933","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":22513765,"blockHash":"0x7ae4abd6009cab3130a3044f85cf9e152e6933fb2401c83a9ce6f0187cfc375c","blockTime":1791884400000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ac6bf24d5df5ee73119ff96","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":22289250,"blockHash":"0x532e49b1301987bedda367a9a01ab7fed4c0955278413003606da80a69376def","blockTime":1791409896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmfFCpkYWzDpKJyYBYSzDdkNwnipy1HDJqL6QsWa8SCNwB","createdAt":"2026-10-07T21:51:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-13T10:30:11.120Z","referendumIndex":668,"contentHash":"f4490ab19f5aeba5c6356aa5d4045ff0"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ac6bf24d5df5ee73119ff96","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xfe65a6d306be82752f79eb673c076351f44a4026b082b80531af67f08a65044a","publicKey":"fe65a6d306be82752f79eb673c076351f44a4026b082b80531af67f08a65044a","address":"JKssqfCAWuENDwzbEQ6mghDGWJq4uJjd7TJjTnmCGbWH8bQ"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6abb6a63a04636a85d20bbf6","referendumIndex":667,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21952197,"blockHash":"0x449713163e7dc683054ce77ebf1ab1731745b87ec7a63d8aeea86da8e016993f","blockTime":1790667288000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","title":"Kusama Shield Audit revised - v2","content":"Greetings *, \n\nThis is a revised proposal to cover the audit cost of the Zero Knowledge privacy protocol “Kusama Shield”. The project aims to bring in expert help to spot future bugs and security issues, giving the project a proper audit. The price has been squeezed down and everything has been done \n\n\n**Previous feedback:**\n\n- Broken unused function in smart contracts(now fixed)                                    \n- Ci not up to date(Continuous integration has been fixed and extended to cover majority of low hanging bugs across multiple code basis)\n- Retro Active funding\nhas now been removed\n- Will future funding be requested to cover ui work?   \nNo, the project simply asks to cover the audit costs so that we can move forward with features that we aim to put in the hands of new users, mostly targeted towards telegram crypto users. The project will enforce a 0.5% tx fee to cover future development. 7 themes have been added to help users have more options. \n- Clear guidelines on the files being audited\nScope has been clearly defined in the proposal \n\n\nAsked Amount: 39330 USD\nNow: 39330 / 4.13 = 9523  KSM \nPrevious: 56605 / 3.2862 = 17225\n\nPreviously 17225 KSM old vs 9523 KSM new, the new proposal is 44.72% cheaper in KSM. EMA30 rate taken at, 2026-09-28 13:00:00 (+UTC), Block #21923279, verify here: \nhttps://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/tools/price_converter?value=1&type=block&from=KSM&to=USD&time=21923279 \n\nBudget overview:\n\n\nTask / hours\n\nCoordinated Trusted Setup\n20\n\n\nCode review by ZK expert\n90\n\n\nBug fixes and implementation of fixes\n150\n\n\nTogether we can bring audited privacy tools to Kusama!\n\n\nRead full proposal here:\nhttps://docs.google.com/document/d/1yIEtCjgcXViHaNxKVkXYjS0UFhDVVuUsnVMMnuNC3EA/edit?usp=sharing \n","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-09-29T07:34:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-29T07:38:58.358Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-16T17:07:12.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":22646037,"blockHash":"0x0c2d3f0bbc6db0c30b382f0ea6a13c0b933193f8ade492dc833c202914163e5a","blockTime":1792170432000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"Qma2ejbmWuJyknxK1DGYMTaKjLRsFupusFT13k5Tn7a818","contentHash":"6db0d7795a8e536de17a6a618985e447","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"6db0d7795a8e536de17a6a618985e447","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Shield Audit Proposal\n\n**Kusama Shield** is a privacy project on the Kusama network. It asked for money to pay for a security audit.\n\n## What is it?\n\n- A privacy tool built on Kusama\n- It wants experts to check the code for bugs\n- The team fixed problems people mentioned before\n\n## What changed?\n\n- Fixed broken code in smart contracts\n- Updated the CI (the system that checks code automatically)\n- Removed \"retro active funding\"\n- Made the list of files to be checked clear\n- Made the project cheaper — 44.72% less KSM than before\n\n## Cost\n\n- Asking for **39,330 USD**\n- That is **9,523 KSM** (was 17,225 KSM before)\n\n## How the money is used\n\n- Trusted setup: 20 hours\n- Code review by ZK expert: 90 hours\n- Bug fixes: 150 hours\n\n## Future plans\n\n- No more money will be asked for UI work\n- A small fee (0.5%) on transactions will pay for future work\n- 7 themes added so users have more choices\n\n## Goal\n\nTo bring audited privacy tools to Kusama!"},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"9523000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6abb6a4a69020b8a32e20ac0","referendumIndex":667,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21952197,"blockHash":"0x449713163e7dc683054ce77ebf1ab1731745b87ec7a63d8aeea86da8e016993f","blockTime":1790667288000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","authors":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":22646037,"blockHash":"0x0c2d3f0bbc6db0c30b382f0ea6a13c0b933193f8ade492dc833c202914163e5a","blockTime":1792170432000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x21e22722d3764a1e03a8edfcd172458a68dbaeb80ab0e2cca68afe9efec9de4f","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":35447579,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":35449979,"confirming":35676653},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007c47374fd12000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003ea7e4df7db400","support":"0x00000000000000000025014bfbfb0000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35676653,[35676653,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007c47374fd12000","nays":"0x0000000000000000003ea7e4df7db400","support":"0x00000000000000000025014bfbfb0000","electorate":"18077268960303879656"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x21e22722d3764a1e03a8edfcd172458a68dbaeb80ab0e2cca68afe9efec9de4f","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"9523000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"}}]}],"amount":"9523000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","beneficiaries":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"9523000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"enactment":{"when":35691053,"index":0},"approved":[35676653,{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":13333333333200}],"electorate":"18077268960303879656","treasuryProposalIndex":461,"treasuryProposalIndexes":[461],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":22522873,"blockHash":"0xe701ed22cd54034b1b24a60207d1c4677bbbe23774b9d27613d96e8908d9689a","blockTime":1791903840000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6abb6a4a69020b8a32e20ac2","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21952197,"blockHash":"0x449713163e7dc683054ce77ebf1ab1731745b87ec7a63d8aeea86da8e016993f","blockTime":1790667288000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"Qma2ejbmWuJyknxK1DGYMTaKjLRsFupusFT13k5Tn7a818","createdAt":"2026-09-29T07:34:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-29T07:38:58.358Z","referendumIndex":667,"contentHash":"6db0d7795a8e536de17a6a618985e447"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6abb6a4a69020b8a32e20ac2","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf621771ddf37d482210b8c59617952eb1c2b40cfec55df47215231365186a057","publicKey":"f621771ddf37d482210b8c59617952eb1c2b40cfec55df47215231365186a057","emailMd5":"c102b6392e99147dbc4f2f7e94503df4","address":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"6aba3f93a04636a85d61a576","referendumIndex":666,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21918463,"blockHash":"0x93e1799baeb7f906dfe35f74d2b6f3cc81d70d73ec01a5ae5669e45d44fb7f98","blockTime":1790590824000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","title":"Kusama Asset Hub — Invulnerable Collator Set Adjustment - Resubmission","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis is a resubmission of a referendum to adjust the collators for Kusama Asset Hub.  It was previously submitted as [referendum 660](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/660) but I mistakenly used the same preimage for [the adjustment of invulnerables on Kusama Bridge Hub](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/661).\n\nI've since updated the preimage and we can see it is a direct submission instead of and XCM call.\n\nMy apologies.\n\nOriginal text follows.\n____________________________________________________________\n\nThis referendum seeks to adjust the invulnerable collator set of **Kusama Asset Hub**.\n\nThe main objective is to make the invulnerable set better aligned with the risk profile and importance of the respective System Chain, while also keeping the assignment process efficient and consistent across the programme.\n\nThe curators also considered the historical assignment of slots across the System Chains. Where possible, the revised assignments favour operators with longer tenure and a demonstrated record of providing reliable service. At the same time, the changes are intended to help even the field for operators who have shown capability and interest in supporting additional System Chains.\n\nFinally, this referendum adjusts the number of permissionless collator slots to ensure that permissionless collators do not outweigh the intended invulnerable set.\n\nTo support this, the curators applied a tiering model where each System Chain is categorised from **Tier 1 to Tier 3**, based on its perceived importance and risk profile. Under this model, **Kusama Asset Hub** is categorised as a **Tier-1** chain, with **8 funded community invulnerable collators**.\n\nFor **Kusama Asset Hub**, the proposed configuration is:\n\n- **Tier:** Tier 1\n- **Community-funded invulnerable collators:** 8\n- **Permissionless collator slots:** 4\n\nThis referendum performs the following changes.\n\n### Collators being added\n\n- **MegaTron / Eric** — `FPJeeKkKhDE8uyid4MKvTj7KJNVczkobiDsxuMmrjPA4Wec`\n- **DPSTK / Dapestake** — `FCt4UxC6BfP6769winMs2YR6FdyL4dLcaw9qowekFySG3J2`\n\n### Collators being removed\n\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `CbLdvHtKPVr1bvt7poBKwJsQUokfjC4kqoMkjeyCDtFs8wQ`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `E5G5qLNBF7nwhemokqNrNwUCQ7oHrLsBVjSc7XhTdRq8672`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s`\n\n### Collators retained\n\nThe following community invulnerables are already in place and remain part of the final Asset Hub set:\n\n- **Polkadotters / pmensik** — `EPGHRDFaBbQz4uF8DgnuScxYp4rvvtpL5MTed7VvGprNQmm`\n- **Iceberg Nodes** — `Eicei1RVHvqHBPJAY2fZpLy2KtCMjY7Kwjo3svjmGLH7FmT`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n- **LuckyFriday** — `HPUEzi4v3YJmhBfSbcGEFFiNKPAGVnGkfDiUzBNTR7j1CxT`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n\n### Final community invulnerable set\n\n- **MegaTron / Eric** — `FPJeeKkKhDE8uyid4MKvTj7KJNVczkobiDsxuMmrjPA4Wec`\n- **Polkadotters / pmensik** — `EPGHRDFaBbQz4uF8DgnuScxYp4rvvtpL5MTed7VvGprNQmm`\n- **Iceberg Nodes** — `Eicei1RVHvqHBPJAY2fZpLy2KtCMjY7Kwjo3svjmGLH7FmT`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n- **LuckyFriday** — `HPUEzi4v3YJmhBfSbcGEFFiNKPAGVnGkfDiUzBNTR7j1CxT`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n- **DPSTK / Dapestake** — `FCt4UxC6BfP6769winMs2YR6FdyL4dLcaw9qowekFySG3J2`\n\nBest Regards,  \nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T10:20:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T10:28:11.694Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-30T13:10:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21998961,"blockHash":"0x00176a27eaab55cd6f6fbff43d62b2d4e2224f553ab547cd99005683f5c1d90b","blockTime":1790773824000,"eventIndex":17},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmVVoGkthgdGUFeiWV9Fbz2FARW71fXxLDn7n1zFhki9sU","contentHash":"9436ade721fe8ad4c6f61febeeb3c728","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"9436ade721fe8ad4c6f61febeeb3c728","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Asset Hub Collator Referendum\n\nThis is a vote about who helps run **Kusama Asset Hub**, a system chain.\n\n- The plan is to change the list of special helpers called **invulnerable collators**.\n- Asset Hub is called a **Tier-1** chain, which means it is very important.\n- It will have **8 community-funded invulnerable collators**.\n- It will have **4 permissionless collator slots**.\n- **2 new collators** are being added: MegaTron / Eric and DPSTK / Dapestake.\n- **3 old collators** are being removed.\n- **6 collators** are staying on the list.\n- The goal is to pick helpers who are reliable and fair."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aba3f8bb2689fa0041c87c8","referendumIndex":666,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21918463,"blockHash":"0x93e1799baeb7f906dfe35f74d2b6f3cc81d70d73ec01a5ae5669e45d44fb7f98","blockTime":1790590824000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":10,"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x2804","section":"utility","method":"forceBatch"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21998961,"blockHash":"0x00176a27eaab55cd6f6fbff43d62b2d4e2224f553ab547cd99005683f5c1d90b","blockTime":1790773824000,"eventIndex":17},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":10,"origin":{"origins":"StakingAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x7c67273d800717a7d7fd0781bfd3e32ed5978955fc1399a306b817e53fc0adcc","len":496}},"enactment":{"at":0},"submitted":35435125,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":35436327,"confirming":35464767},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018acb9946aa50000","nays":2835030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad14877b1f4000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35464767,[35464767,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018acb9946aa50000","nays":2835030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad14877b1f4000","electorate":"18021831386254598508"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["Asset Hub: add new invulnerables before removals to preserve minimum invulnerable count","Adding 2 invulnerable collators: MegaTron, DPSTK / Dapestake","Removing 3 obsolete invulnerable collators: previous invulnerable, previous invulnerable, previous invulnerable","Asset Hub, Tier 1, 4 Permissionless Collators"],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x7c67273d800717a7d7fd0781bfd3e32ed5978955fc1399a306b817e53fc0adcc","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35464867,"index":0},"approved":[35464767,{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"18021831386254598508","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21993876,"blockHash":"0xca847e5b9bed7eb5b3e770f197732335d8ab269bcf6dffc3bfa2084f91251e0a","blockTime":1790762040000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aba3f8bb2689fa0041c87ca","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21918463,"blockHash":"0x93e1799baeb7f906dfe35f74d2b6f3cc81d70d73ec01a5ae5669e45d44fb7f98","blockTime":1790590824000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmVVoGkthgdGUFeiWV9Fbz2FARW71fXxLDn7n1zFhki9sU","createdAt":"2026-09-28T10:20:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T10:28:11.694Z","referendumIndex":666,"contentHash":"9436ade721fe8ad4c6f61febeeb3c728"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aba3f8bb2689fa0041c87ca","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"]},"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xe8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","publicKey":"e8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","address":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6ab40512a04636a85d190940","referendumIndex":665,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21738560,"blockHash":"0x3e9f476b83bff4dfa2d30a5034b8b4473b5da5c4e1d2817143a71831b32cf918","blockTime":1790182608000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","title":"Bounty: fund memberships only for people the room can vouch for","content":"## In short\n\nThis is a request for **8 KSM** from the Kusama treasury, as a bounty on the **Small Tipper track (30)**. It is an experiment, sized so that the treasury learns something whichever way it goes.\n\nIt tries two things at once.\n\n**A different way to run a bounty.** A Kusama bounty needs a curator, and the curator decides when money is released. Normally that decision rests on the curator's judgement. Here the curator is bound to a published condition that anyone can recompute with a published checker, so the curator's only decision is whether the checker passed. A third party who was never involved can rerun it and dispute the result, and the dispute is settled by recomputation rather than by argument.\n\n**A way to bootstrap proof of individuality.** The condition is attendance at a live session, witnessed by the other people in the room. The KSM pays for one thing: the on-chain membership that is minted for a person when they join the community. Nobody is paid. Money is released from the approved funds to cover a membership only for an attendee the room can vouch for, and only once per person, however many accounts that person holds. The amounts are small and the witnessing is informal. What it tests is whether treasury money can be settled against a record of recognition between people, which is the settlement half of any personhood system, before the recognition half is cryptographic.\n\n## The setting\n\nBirdbrain is a community on Kreivo, a Kusama parachain, where membership of a community is an on-chain item. Chaos Sessions are Birdbrain's open weekly video calls, held every Monday. There have been thirty-four. People sign into each call with a passkey, which gives us a sign-in log for every session, and everyone on the call can see who else is there.\n\nEach membership costs about 0.3 KSM on Kreivo. Until now that cost has been paid out of pocket by the people running the community. This bounty would fund it from the treasury, one membership per verified attendee. The KSM goes to the community's own account and is spent on minting memberships. None of it goes to the attendees themselves.\n\n## Why Small Tipper, and why 8 KSM\n\nThe Small Tipper track can spend at most **8.33333333325 KSM** in one referendum. Every figure in this proposal was read from Kusama Asset Hub rather than taken from documentation, and this one was tested a planck either side through the funding call itself: at the ceiling it is accepted, one planck over it is refused. The request is 8 KSM, inside that limit.\n\nIt is deliberately small. This is a test of a mechanism, not a funding round. 8 KSM pays for roughly 25 memberships. If the mechanism is wrong, Kusama will have spent the price of a round of drinks finding out, in public.\n\n## How a payout is decided\n\nAfter each session, the people who signed in are turned into a list of attendees, and the list is turned into a Merkle root. The root is written to Kusama Asset Hub before any payout is made against it. Each leaf binds three things:\n\n```markdown\nleaf = blake2_256( 0x00 ‖ blake2_256(person_id) ‖ account ‖ blake2_256(session_id) )\nnode = blake2_256( 0x01 ‖ sort(a, b) )\n```\n\nA person's membership is funded if and only if all four of these hold.\n\n1. The session's root is on Kusama Asset Hub **before** any award against it.\n2. Their leaf is in that root, with a valid Merkle path.\n3. Their account holds a Kreivo membership minted at or after the session.\n4. This bounty has not already funded a membership for this person.\n\nThe first condition is enforced by the chain, not by us. Each session is funded through its own child bounty, and the session's root is that child bounty's metadata. The chain refuses to create the child unless the root is already stored on chain and readable by anyone, so the award cannot be made without it.\n\nThe fourth condition is the one most attendance schemes leave out. Attendance answers *was a human in the room*. It does not answer *is this the same human whose membership has already been funded*. The chain cannot answer that either, because it knows accounts, not people: someone who opens a fresh account looks like a newcomer. Without the second question, one person with five accounts is funded five times, and every one of those accounts looks legitimate. So the person is part of the leaf, and the checker refuses to build a root in which one person appears with two accounts, or two people share one account. A duplicate is stopped before a root exists, not discovered after a payout.\n\nThe same person turning up the following week is checked too. Before each session's child bounty is created, every person in its root is compared against the people in every session already funded, and anyone found there is dropped. The child bounty is then sized to the people who are left, at the cost of one membership each. The earlier rosters are public and each funded session is a child bounty carrying its root, so anyone can rerun that comparison.\n\nA leaf is only given to someone who signed in with a passkey they control themselves. Some members hold their membership on an account whose key the community's administrator holds on their behalf. Funding a membership on one of those accounts would be funding ourselves, so those people are left out of the root and listed in the roster with the reason.\n\n## Where the community starts from\n\nThe case for the fourth condition is our own register. At Kreivo block #38,961,176 the Birdbrain community holds **37 memberships across 36 accounts**:\n\n- **33** belong to **15 people** we can name\n- **1** belongs to an account we have not yet matched to a person\n- **3** belong to test identities with nobody behind them\n\nSeven of those fifteen people hold more than one membership. One holds nine, most of them left over from testing the sign-in flow. Nothing in the register itself could have told you which accounts belonged to the same person, because that information was never recorded in it.\n\nCustody splits the fifteen:\n\n- **10** hold at least one membership on an account only they can sign for\n- **5** hold memberships only on accounts the administrator's key controls\n\nHolding an account is not the same as being able to use it. At the most recent session, CS34 on 21 September 2026, two people who were failing to sign in registered fresh passkeys during the call. Each new passkey was minted a membership, one of them twice over, and both people still ended up joining on a guest link with no passkey at all. A failed sign-in added memberships to the register and nobody to the room. That is how a community of fifteen people comes to hold thirty-seven memberships.\n\nSo before the first membership is funded, the community is reset. All 37 memberships are burned and the list of what was burned is published. After that, memberships are rebuilt at one per person, for people who turn up and sign in with their own key. The before and after is part of the evidence.\n\n## What the sessions actually produce\n\n**CS33, 14 September 2026.** Eight people were in the room and four have leaves. Two held memberships only on administrator-held accounts. Two joined on guest links with no passkey. A ninth sign-in was a second device belonging to someone who already has a leaf, and it is counted once.\n\n**CS34, 21 September 2026.** Twelve names in the sign-in log, from ten or eleven people, and five have leaves. Two people held memberships only on administrator-held accounts. The two whose sign-in failed came in on guest links, and so did one person who has never registered a passkey. Of the other three guest links, two were second logins by people already counted, and one we cannot place from the log.\n\nFour or five eligible people a session is the honest rate today, out of the eight to eleven who come. Moving people onto accounts they control, and fixing sign-in so that a failure does not leave them stranded, is our work and is not funded by this bounty. How many people the mechanism can admit week to week is one of the things the experiment measures.\n\n## Check it yourself\n\nThe checker and every anchored roster are public at **https://github.com/Birdbrain-wtf/attendance-checker**, alongside Birdbrain's identity layer, [Seeds](https://github.com/Birdbrain-wtf/seeds).\n\nThe published rosters name nobody. Each attendee is given as the hash `blake2_256(person_id)`, which is exactly what the leaf contains, so a roster with no names rebuilds the same root. This is pseudonymity rather than anonymity: the identifiers are short, and someone who guesses one can confirm it. The accounts are public on chain regardless.\n\nOne root is on chain so far. It was anchored before this bounty was proposed, which matters, because a root published after a payout could have been chosen to fit it.\n\n|  |  |\n| --- | --- |\n| session | CS33, 14 September 2026 |\n| root | `0xcc04a401c1900bc950f297d83025a930fb3a6250b5b115d9bddb8007c4d686a0` |\n| remark | `birdbrain/attendance/v2:CS33:0xcc04a401…` |\n| block | Kusama Asset Hub #21,513,860 |\n| extrinsic | `0x0a04550ef4ec44a2d067553b6dcba3aa1a415ae4607cb975efbf59ed298680dd` |\n| cost | 0.0000767 KSM |\n\nTo rebuild it and compare it with the chain:\n\n```markdown\nbun install\nbun run attendance-root.ts self-test\nbun run attendance-root.ts build rosters/CS33.json\nbun run verify-chain.ts rosters/CS33.json\n```\n\nThe last command reads the anchoring transaction off Kusama Asset Hub, decodes it, and compares it with the root rebuilt from the published roster. It signs nothing and needs no keys.\n\nCS34's root is built but not yet anchored. It will be anchored before any award is made against it, and published at the same time.\n\n## What we are not claiming\n\n**This is falsifiable, not trustless.** The list linking each person to their account comes from the session's own sign-in log, and everyone who was in the room can see it and challenge it. That is a real cost to anyone trying to fake attendance, and a cheap one to contest. It is not a cryptographic guarantee, and calling it one would be dishonest.\n\nThe planned sequence is:\n\n- **Now**: the room's own record, checked against the sign-in log.\n- **Next**: continuity. A person counts only after two attendances, the second witnessed by someone who was at the first, so a fabricated person costs a second real person's hour, twice.\n- **Later**: Polkadot's `pallet-people`, from Parity's Individuality work, takes over the person slot once it is available. Nothing else in the award condition changes when it does.\n\nThat last step is why we think this is worth Kusama's money rather than only ours. Individuality builds personhood out of a recurring game of people recognising each other. Chaos Sessions are a recurring game of people recognising each other, now on their thirty-fourth round. This bounty tests what it looks like to release treasury money against that recognition, and it is built so the recognition can be swapped for a better one without touching the rest.\n\n## Who is asking, and who curates\n\nThe referendum is submitted by `DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh`, the Birdbrain community's operator account, registered on the Kusama People Chain under the name **Birdbrain** (not yet verified by a registrar). The same account is named as curator.\n\nWe would rather say that plainly than bury it. Three things limit what the curator can do:\n\n- The curator fee is **zero**. There is no cut to take.\n- The condition and the checker are published, so a wrong award can be detected by anyone.\n- The payout goes to an account nobody holds a key for (below), not to the curator.\n\nThe curator key is an online one rather than a cold one, because the same account signs members into the community. The worst a compromise of it could do is make an award early. It could not send money anywhere other than the fixed beneficiary.\n\nThe intended end state is for the community's own account to hold the curator role, so that a vote inside the community makes each award and no individual does. That needs Kreivo to act on Asset Hub through a cross-chain message, which we have not yet rehearsed.\n\n## Where the money lands\n\nThe beneficiary is `DfjYNoRLGy2q6PoMVQydCe6tUdAhgSZ7VULVmec28vvrimB`, the Birdbrain community's own account on Kusama Asset Hub. It is derived by Kreivo from the community's identity, `Parachain(2281) + Plurality(Index 1786, Voice)`.\n\nNo key controls that account. It can only be spent by a referendum inside the Birdbrain community. Treasury money does not pass through a personal account at any point.\n\nFrom there, the KSM has to move to Kreivo, where memberships are paid for. The bounty pallet cannot send it there directly: Kusama Asset Hub pays bounty awards only to local accounts, and refuses every other destination, on the live chain as in testing. So the onward transfer is ours to run. Both halves of it already dry-run cleanly against live Asset Hub, including the message as Kreivo actually sends it. Nothing on that path has been broadcast yet, and nothing needs to be until the bounty is funded.\n\nThe parent bounty is carved into one child bounty per session, each awarded only after the checker passes against that session's root. Every cohort leaves its own trace on chain, and a session that fails the checker simply gets no child bounty.\n\n## Why a bounty and not a treasury spend\n\nA treasury spend pays a fixed amount to a fixed recipient on a fixed schedule. There is nowhere in it for a condition to live, so the mechanism proposed here could not be tested through one. The curator role is the only place in Kusama's treasury machinery that can hold a spending condition, and binding that role to a published check is the proposal.\n\n## Cost and risk to the treasury\n\nThe treasury's exposure is 8 KSM. Ours is about 0.25 KSM in deposits to get the bounty funded and active, plus about 0.045 KSM per session, all of it refundable:\n\n|  | KSM | returned when |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| referendum submission deposit | 0.0333 | the referendum concludes |\n| decision deposit | 0.0333 | the referendum concludes |\n| title preimage | \\~0.019 | the preimage is removed |\n| curator deposit | 0.1667 | the bounty closes |\n| each session's root preimage | \\~0.045 | the preimage is removed |\n\nThis bounty uses the newer multi-asset bounties pallet, which has no proposal step and so no proposer bond. If the referendum fails, nothing is forfeited to the treasury.\n\nThe whole sequence, from funding through to a settled payout, has been run in two ways. A read-only rehearsal walks every step against the live chain, twelve steps, no keys, nothing signed, and anyone can rerun it. At one planck over the Small Tipper ceiling it is refused, which is the control. The same sequence has also been run end to end on a copy of Kusama Asset Hub, signing with the operator account and the balance it really holds, from funding to a 2.5 KSM payout into the community account. Every deposit in this proposal has therefore been paid once already, from the money that would pay it for real.\n\nThe pallet also needs a nudge that the chain does not send by itself. A bounty and each of its children move to their next state only when someone calls `checkStatus`, and a curator who does not know this finds out when a payment sits unfinished for weeks. Our award command sends those calls as part of the award, and a daily job looks for anything left mid-payment and clears it.\n\n## Why this generalises\n\nNothing in the award condition is specific to Birdbrain, to memberships, or to video calls. It is an anchored root, a check that each person is funded once, a published checker, and a curator bound to it. Any bounty that funds something per verified person doing a verifiable thing can take the same shape: conference attendance, translation, moderation shifts, bug triage.\n\nIf it works, the curator stops being an allocator of funds and becomes a verifier of a public record. If it does not, it fails in public, for 8 KSM.\n","contentType":"markdown","track":30,"createdAt":"2026-09-23T16:56:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-23T17:14:04.105Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-30T21:22:48.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":22011836,"blockHash":"0xa9dad823b876ff3bc103ac2e7b200bd96436796485744daf979be3277d5a5c4b","blockTime":1790803368000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":60010000000000,"nays":4335030000000000,"support":59100000000000}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmWEek6gXWYBt4KwT3v9qMx8CTaZvPDXFjvTtjgrxta91C","contentHash":"dee6cc45eb6d551a7532449f0a2bf2e7","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"dee6cc45eb6d551a7532449f0a2bf2e7","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Birdbrain Attendance Bounty (Kusama)\n\n**Birdbrain** is a community on Kreivo, a Kusama blockchain. It is asking Kusama's treasury for **8 KSM** to pay for community memberships. Birdbrain holds open video calls every Monday called **Chaos Sessions**. People who show up can join the community on-chain.\n\n- **What the money is for:** Each membership costs about 0.3 KSM. The 8 KSM would pay for about 25 memberships. Nobody gets paid in cash.\n- **How someone gets a membership funded:** They must sign in with their own passkey, be seen in the call, and appear in a public list called a **Merkle root**. The root is written on the Kusama chain before any money is spent.\n- **One person, one membership:** The rule checks that the same person is not paid twice, even if they use multiple accounts. This is the part most systems miss.\n- **A reset is coming first:** Right now 15 known people hold **37 memberships** because of testing mistakes. All 37 will be burned and rebuilt at one per person.\n- **Who runs it:** A curator account named **Birdbrain**. The curator fee is **zero**, and the money goes to a community account that no single person controls.\n- **Built to be checked:** Anyone can rerun the checker using public code on GitHub and the on-chain record. The organizer calls it **falsifiable, not trustless**.\n- **Why Kusama should care:** If it works, it could be reused for other bounties, like paying for conference attendance or moderation. If it fails, it fails in public for 8 KSM.\n- **Small risk:** The treasury risks 8 KSM. Birdbrain risks about 0.25 KSM in refundable deposits. The whole process was already tested on a copy of the chain."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6ab40502104828b01bc499c7","referendumIndex":665,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21738560,"blockHash":"0x3e9f476b83bff4dfa2d30a5034b8b4473b5da5c4e1d2817143a71831b32cf918","blockTime":1790182608000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":30,"trackInfo":{"id":30,"name":"small_tipper","originalName":"small_tipper\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":200,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333","preparePeriod":10,"decisionPeriod":100800,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":10,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":357142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":1620729,"xOffset":3231018,"yOffset":-1615509}}},"proposer":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","authors":["DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":22011836,"blockHash":"0xa9dad823b876ff3bc103ac2e7b200bd96436796485744daf979be3277d5a5c4b","blockTime":1790803368000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":60010000000000,"nays":4335030000000000,"support":59100000000000}}},"info":{"track":30,"origin":{"origins":"SmallTipper"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x620005000001000b008028a546070020469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144c604248e43eac4f225b35184eec45278c6c62e904700a25007762788131bf38a"},"enactment":{"after":1},"submitted":35368836,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","amount":33333333333},"deciding":{"since":35368854,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":60010000000000,"nays":4335030000000000,"support":59100000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35469654,[35469654,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":60010000000000,"nays":4335030000000000,"support":59100000000000,"electorate":"18023318437196081206"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x620005000001000b008028a546070020469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144c604248e43eac4f225b35184eec45278c6c62e904700a25007762788131bf38a","hash":"0xdff36eadb9a01771f4722cf9cbfc751cce1590b0eaed3915ab33a9402b67ca88","call":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty","args":[{"name":"assetKind","type":"PolkadotRuntimeCommonImplsVersionedLocatableAsset","value":{"v5":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"assetId":{"parents":1,"interior":{"here":null}}}}},{"name":"value","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"8000000000000"},{"name":"curator","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"}},{"name":"metadata","type":"H256","value":"0xc604248e43eac4f225b35184eec45278c6c62e904700a25007762788131bf38a"}]}},"proposalHash":"0xdff36eadb9a01771f4722cf9cbfc751cce1590b0eaed3915ab33a9402b67ca88","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"allFundBounties":[{"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"8000000000000","curator":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"electorate":"18023318437196081206","rejected":[35469656,{"who":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","amount":33333333333},{"who":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh","amount":33333333333}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6ab40502104828b01bc499c9","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21738560,"blockHash":"0x3e9f476b83bff4dfa2d30a5034b8b4473b5da5c4e1d2817143a71831b32cf918","blockTime":1790182608000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmWEek6gXWYBt4KwT3v9qMx8CTaZvPDXFjvTtjgrxta91C","createdAt":"2026-09-23T16:56:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-23T17:14:04.105Z","referendumIndex":665,"contentHash":"dee6cc45eb6d551a7532449f0a2bf2e7"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6ab40502104828b01bc499c9","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"]},"trackInfo":{"id":30,"name":"small_tipper","originalName":"small_tipper\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":200,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333","preparePeriod":10,"decisionPeriod":100800,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":10,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":357142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":1620729,"xOffset":3231018,"yOffset":-1615509}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x20469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144","publicKey":"20469a0dcf3cdd18758dc98c5168199f5df59e1eaefbc1c4eb486a5f83475144","address":"DJe2JJvcMNjxjkhi3UsoNZwSaYnHQqQB7AAavEAz1wDrJGh"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"6aaf440da04636a85d12c4d3","referendumIndex":664,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21602977,"blockHash":"0x9377060a8f5da402b826dce9461d308edc3b2fa5498b33119ef015c23e4c2dfa","blockTime":1789871040000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj","title":"[Root] Deregister ParaId 2270 to release a locked 235.468 KSM registration deposit","content":"## Summary\n\nThis Root-track referendum deregisters ParaId 2270 on Kusama. It releases the 235.468 KSM registration deposit back to the manager account that already owns it and removes dead state from the relay chain. No treasury funds are requested and nothing is minted: the only effect is an existing reserved balance becoming free inside one account.\n\n## Why Root is the only route\n\nThe lease of ParaId 2270 ended long ago, the chain has not produced a block since, and the team that registered it no longer operates. registrar.paras(2270) still reports locked: true, so from the manager account registrar.deregister and registrar.swap return ParaLocked, and registrar.removeLock returns BadOrigin. LeaseAdmin and GeneralAdmin also return BadOrigin. The only other accepted origin is the parachain itself calling removeLock through its own ParachainsOrigin, which is unreachable in practice: the chain is dead and nobody can run it to emit that message.\n\n## The call, and how to verify it\n\nAfter the Asset Hub migration OpenGov lives on Kusama Asset Hub while the registrar pallet stays on the relay chain, so this is dispatched as polkadotXcm.send to the relay chain carrying UnpaidExecution followed by Transact with originKind Superuser.\n\nRelay chain call: 0x4602de080000 (registrar.deregister(2270))\n\nAsset Hub call: 0x1f0003010003082f000006020300286bee02350c00184602de080000\n\nDryRunApi.dryRunXcm on the relay chain, with origin location (0, X1(Parachain(1000))) and exactly the message above, returns Ok and Complete and emits precisely two events: balances.Unreserved for Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj of 235,467,996,471,199 planck, and registrar.Deregistered for paraId 2270. Nothing else is touched. The dry-run APIs are free, so anyone can reproduce this before voting rather than taking my word for it.\n\n## On the sell-pressure objection\n\nDeregistering does not mint anything. These 235.468 KSM already exist and are already counted in issuance; they only move from reserved to free within a single account. The alternative is not fewer KSM in circulation, it is the same KSM frozen forever in a registration for a chain that will never run again, plus permanent dead state on the relay chain.\n\n## Precedent\n\nThis is not a new category of request. Referendum 491 deregistered parathread 3390 on the Root track: a third party placed the same 3,333.33 KSM decision deposit on 2025-02-10 and it executed on 2025-02-26. Referendum 590 was the same ask for ParaId 2114 (Turing Network) and passed with roughly 1.62M KSM aye and zero nay across 140 votes, but was cancelled before execution, so registrar.paras(2114) still reports locked: true with 63.14 KSM stuck.\n\n## What this needs\n\nThe referendum is in the preparing phase and needs the Root track decision deposit of 3,333.33 KSM before it can start deciding. I cannot fund that myself. It can be placed by any account via referenda.placeDecisionDeposit(664) on Kusama Asset Hub, and it is returned to whoever places it once the referendum concludes, whether approved or rejected. To be straightforward about the one real risk rather than overselling it: deposits are slashed only if a referendum is killed through the Referendum Killer track. If nobody places the deposit, this times out and the KSM stay locked for good.\n\nTwo points I would welcome input on. First, I am happy for a single referendum to deregister both 2270 and 2114, so that one deposit clears two stuck cases and sets a reusable precedent for the abandoned ParaIds that will keep accumulating. The manager of 2114 is CmxJEdEniSV6hGWoKfHWLR6h4A1dh5gD1vgzmD12osJvGsk. Second, if a cheaper origin is allowed to send a Superuser Transact to the relay chain, for example Whitelisted Caller after a Fellowship whitelist, the deposit requirement drops enormously and I would gladly withdraw this one and resubmit there. If anyone familiar with the post-migration Asset Hub XCM origin configuration can confirm or rule that out, it would help a great deal.\n\nFull write-up and discussion: https://forum.polkadot.network/t/kusama-request-for-a-root-referendum-deregister-paraid-2270-to-release-a-locked-235-468-ksm-registration-deposit/18703","contentType":"markdown","track":0,"createdAt":"2026-09-20T02:24:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-22T01:35:44.624Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-10-29T20:22:00.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23168779,"blockHash":"0x5677ac90777de6d55637e02d18ad977c6455de66270814b004689008fe876cda","blockTime":1793305320000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmQRWFyGyKwiiuFQ4NvD5X5wcdF7p7EgzYhi223451rZ3C","contentHash":"2177cc433d7de06d852071f0551fdf13","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"2177cc433d7de06d852071f0551fdf13","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"## Kusama Referendum to Deregister ParaId 2270\n\n- This is a **Kusama vote** called a \"Root referendum.\"\n- It would **remove a dead parachain** called ParaId 2270.\n- A parachain is like a **separate chain connected to Kusama**.\n- That parachain **stopped working long ago**, so it cannot fix itself.\n- The **only way to remove it is through Kusama's Root track**.\n- Removing it **frees up 235.468 KSM** that was locked as a deposit.\n- The KSM **is not new money** — it already exists and just becomes usable.\n- The vote **needs a deposit of 3,333.33 KSM** to start, which is returned later."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aaf43f4b9d79fbd5180bd7a","referendumIndex":664,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21602977,"blockHash":"0x9377060a8f5da402b826dce9461d308edc3b2fa5498b33119ef015c23e4c2dfa","blockTime":1789871040000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":0,"trackInfo":{"id":0,"name":"root","originalName":"root\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":1,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj","authors":["Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":23168779,"blockHash":"0x5677ac90777de6d55637e02d18ad977c6455de66270814b004689008fe876cda","blockTime":1793305320000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":0,"origin":{"system":{"root":null}},"proposal":{"inline":"0x1f0003010003082f000006020300286bee02350c00184602de080000"},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":35318657,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":3333333333300000},"deciding":{"since":35644900,"confirming":35860839},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001f991762dd5400","nays":900000000000000,"support":2784500000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35860839,[35860839,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001f991762dd5400","nays":900000000000000,"support":2784500000000000,"electorate":"18094935347444540331"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x1f0003010003082f000006020300286bee02350c00184602de080000","hash":"0x19e84288ad42aebacf3079122019a53f361d0330dc23b9c710bd0ec65125617c","call":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send","args":[{"name":"dest","type":"XcmVersionedLocation","value":{"v3":{"parents":1,"interior":{"here":null}}}},{"name":"message","type":"XcmVersionedXcm","value":{"v3":[{"unpaidExecution":{"weightLimit":{"unlimited":null},"checkOrigin":null}},{"transact":{"originKind":"Superuser","requireWeightAtMost":{"refTime":4000000000,"proofSize":200000},"call":{"encoded":"0x4602de080000"}}}]}}]}},"proposalHash":"0x19e84288ad42aebacf3079122019a53f361d0330dc23b9c710bd0ec65125617c","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35875239,"index":0},"approved":[35860839,{"who":"Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj","amount":33333333333},{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":3333333333300000}],"electorate":"18094935347444540331","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":23087338,"blockHash":"0x66bf8a3fbd31605f593537e21bd6683c9fdc439bc611cb1b31a8ba17b37f90cd","blockTime":1793127744000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aaf43f4b9d79fbd5180bd7c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21602977,"blockHash":"0x9377060a8f5da402b826dce9461d308edc3b2fa5498b33119ef015c23e4c2dfa","blockTime":1789871040000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmQRWFyGyKwiiuFQ4NvD5X5wcdF7p7EgzYhi223451rZ3C","createdAt":"2026-09-20T02:24:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-22T01:35:44.624Z","referendumIndex":664,"contentHash":"2177cc433d7de06d852071f0551fdf13"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aaf43f4b9d79fbd5180bd7c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj"]},"trackInfo":{"id":0,"name":"root","originalName":"root\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":1,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xb605c887d5e45e98a3550869ec5b5c7193dcaee16c93b3716e8215f1c0204e1e","publicKey":"b605c887d5e45e98a3550869ec5b5c7193dcaee16c93b3716e8215f1c0204e1e","address":"Ggyx6maeuWuKR6RkF4UiSEANZLejTVypJ9atP6jwCVvthJj"},"commentsCount":7},{"_id":"6aa96012a04636a85d1fb5ac","referendumIndex":663,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434416,"blockHash":"0x57df74ad90393d5aacab4d0fcc6f9af7cef2056b8b2d897b831aa7601cfcd287","blockTime":1789485000000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","title":"Kusama Coretime — Invulnerable Collator Set Adjustment","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis referendum seeks to adjust the invulnerable collator set of **Kusama Coretime**.\n\nThe main objective is to make the invulnerable set better aligned with the risk profile and importance of the respective System Chain, while also keeping the assignment process efficient and consistent across the programme.\n\nThe curators also considered the historical assignment of slots across the System Chains. Where possible, the revised assignments favour operators with longer tenure and a demonstrated record of providing reliable service. At the same time, the changes are intended to help even the field for operators who have shown capability and interest in supporting additional System Chains.\n\nFinally, this referendum adjusts the number of permissionless collator slots to ensure that permissionless collators do not outweigh the intended invulnerable set.\n\nTo support this, the curators applied a tiering model where each System Chain is categorised from **Tier 1 to Tier 3**, based on its perceived importance and risk profile. Under this model, **Kusama Coretime** is categorised as a **Tier-2** chain, with **4 funded community invulnerable collators**.\n\nFor **Kusama Coretime**, the proposed configuration is:\n\n- **Tier:** Tier 2\n- **Community-funded invulnerable collators:** 4\n- **Permissionless collator slots:** 2\n\nThis referendum performs the following changes.\n\n### Collators being added\n\n- **STKD** — `CgN2b8aDDH2TrP5bysEmnd7hFWmRRYbXMAdW4aPrUedsPWc`\n- **Chris-Staking** — `HU8jDBY3Pm1iM8SjCk8Zq8GJKEH38u6rizvz3gydpedrzNC`\n- **HYPERSPEED** — `DV7b5AL9zNbsnQ8CWCwvw2tzc3pz74EVDLGQdNU1tujA2L5`\n- **TUXEDO** — `EwnsRbWsCBpL334uY1hnw4beZKvQkqDSmrBcrhyHpyqtqQ2`\n\n### Collators being removed\n\n- **CoinStudio** — `CdW8izFcLeicL3zZUQaC3a39AGeNSTgc9Jb5E5sjREpryA2`\n- **YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna** — `DtuntvQBh9vajFTnd42aTTCiuCyY3ep6EVwhhPjj2ejyyhW`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n- **LuckyFriday** — `HPUEzi4v3YJmhBfSbcGEFFiNKPAGVnGkfDiUzBNTR7j1CxT`\n- **Mile** — `HmatizNhXrZtXwQK2LfntvjCy3x1EuKs1WnRQ6CP3KkNfmA`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s`\n\n### Collators retained\n\nNone of the community invulnerables in the previous Coretime set are retained in the final community-funded assignment.\n\n### Final community invulnerable set\n\n- **STKD** — `CgN2b8aDDH2TrP5bysEmnd7hFWmRRYbXMAdW4aPrUedsPWc`\n- **Chris-Staking** — `HU8jDBY3Pm1iM8SjCk8Zq8GJKEH38u6rizvz3gydpedrzNC`\n- **HYPERSPEED** — `DV7b5AL9zNbsnQ8CWCwvw2tzc3pz74EVDLGQdNU1tujA2L5`\n- **TUXEDO** — `EwnsRbWsCBpL334uY1hnw4beZKvQkqDSmrBcrhyHpyqtqQ2`\n\nBest Regards,  \nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:10:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:08:46.877Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-25T17:37:12.000Z","cid":"QmWPNdWe5d5f9pEAUpTbx7j4UpwvXFVMW5J5Rg7it6q4o7","contentHash":"48607647d2f8034c8fe58f85d6e49173","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815555,"blockHash":"0xa1749be16fd0fe6f0f73a789abcaa0be9cc4bca83858f00ae4307bb936b73ab8","blockTime":1790357832000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"48607647d2f8034c8fe58f85d6e49173","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Coretime Referendum\n\n## What is this?\nThis is a vote about who helps run **Kusama Coretime**, a part of the Kusama network.\n\n## What is changing?\n- Kusama Coretime is called a **Tier-2** chain, which means it is somewhat important.\n- It will have **4 special collators** (helpers) paid by the community.\n- It will also have **2 open slots** anyone can apply for.\n\n## New helpers being added\n- STKD\n- Chris-Staking\n- HYPERSPEED\n- TUXEDO\n\n## Helpers being removed\n- CoinStudio\n- YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna\n- Turboflakes\n- LuckyFriday\n- Mile\n- The previous invulnerable helper\n\n## What stays the same?\n- None of the old helpers are kept in the new group.\n\n## Final list of helpers\n- STKD\n- Chris-Staking\n- HYPERSPEED\n- TUXEDO\n\n## Who wrote this?\nWill from Paradox (ParaNodes.io)."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aa95ffdd83e66628bb0d97a","referendumIndex":663,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434416,"blockHash":"0x57df74ad90393d5aacab4d0fcc6f9af7cef2056b8b2d897b831aa7601cfcd287","blockTime":1789485000000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":10,"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815555,"blockHash":"0xa1749be16fd0fe6f0f73a789abcaa0be9cc4bca83858f00ae4307bb936b73ab8","blockTime":1790357832000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":10,"origin":{"origins":"StakingAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xc65942b650b00f8818cfeb572a4a411d71e33df0d3a07cf5dc9faa45587ca00a","len":719}},"enactment":{"at":0},"submitted":35256190,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":35257390,"confirming":35397142},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018b60646f0310f4d","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018b5ab68d421d34d"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35397142,[35397142,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018b60646f0310f4d","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018b5ab68d421d34d","electorate":"18004259922308456197"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xc65942b650b00f8818cfeb572a4a411d71e33df0d3a07cf5dc9faa45587ca00a","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35397245,"index":0},"approved":[35397145,{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"18004259922308456197","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21810468,"blockHash":"0x7753214b4683dfd9a354cbde57c15ca76d7e285cc987405a4f8b3f2836204322","blockTime":1790346168000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aa95ffdd83e66628bb0d97c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21434416,"blockHash":"0x57df74ad90393d5aacab4d0fcc6f9af7cef2056b8b2d897b831aa7601cfcd287","blockTime":1789485000000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmWPNdWe5d5f9pEAUpTbx7j4UpwvXFVMW5J5Rg7it6q4o7","createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:10:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:08:46.877Z","referendumIndex":663,"contentHash":"48607647d2f8034c8fe58f85d6e49173"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aa95ffdd83e66628bb0d97c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"]},"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","publicKey":"f00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","address":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"6aa95f98a04636a85d1ed546","referendumIndex":662,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434372,"blockHash":"0xb276b1d686a3a29f6383a5d2d201d027c04b56325704d786939f2f2262a86c29","blockTime":1789484904000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","title":"Kusama People — Invulnerable Collator Set Adjustment","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis referendum seeks to adjust the invulnerable collator set of **Kusama People**.\n\nThe main objective is to make the invulnerable set better aligned with the risk profile and importance of the respective System Chain, while also keeping the assignment process efficient and consistent across the programme.\n\nThe curators also considered the historical assignment of slots across the System Chains. Where possible, the revised assignments favour operators with longer tenure and a demonstrated record of providing reliable service. At the same time, the changes are intended to help even the field for operators who have shown capability and interest in supporting additional System Chains.\n\nFinally, this referendum adjusts the number of permissionless collator slots to ensure that permissionless collators do not outweigh the intended invulnerable set.\n\nTo support this, the curators applied a tiering model where each System Chain is categorised from **Tier 1 to Tier 3**, based on its perceived importance and risk profile. Under this model, **Kusama People** is categorised as a **Tier-1** chain, with **8 funded community invulnerable collators**.\n\nFor **Kusama People**, the proposed configuration is:\n\n- **Tier:** Tier 1\n- **Community-funded invulnerable collators:** 8\n- **Permissionless collator slots:** 4\n\nThis referendum performs the following changes.\n\n### Collators being added\n\n- **ExtraCoin / Yaron** — `EXTrPKwb8ovrnaQMsBsf3nDZu4A4YdHgvNedAiY5DFyM3zB`\n- **Mile** — `HmatizNhXrZtXwQK2LfntvjCy3x1EuKs1WnRQ6CP3KkNfmA`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n- **HYPERSPEED** — `DV7b5AL9zNbsnQ8CWCwvw2tzc3pz74EVDLGQdNU1tujA2L5`\n- **YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna** — `DtuntvQBh9vajFTnd42aTTCiuCyY3ep6EVwhhPjj2ejyyhW`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n\n### Collators being removed\n\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `CbLd7BdUr8DqD4TciR1kH6w12bbHBCW9n2MHGCtbxq4U5ty`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `DGHxPHM19z1C6tvRhf1tBARB38uV8tudHQsSm2a3bonuSU4`\n- **openbitlab** — `E8X4LxU9zEiNVAYM95ERDeomMmwwwqn7RBCuRMEZCfgFm3JI`\n- **MathCrypto** — `F7TKjT2EBVqfquyN5G4s4FLSxHM7nR3WbdRAgxQLeJYVG53`\n- **BESTVALIDATOR / Zurich** — `GHW6TB6awErp2VaySKN6dLdjmzKET1LzCKMMTYMnGMUXs7n`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `HWBh4YQ69iopm9G8x938dEivMENXeHaHZraannpg4U4aib2`\n\n### Collators retained\n\nThe following community invulnerables are already in place and remain part of the final People set:\n\n- **CoinStudio** — `CdW8izFcLeicL3zZUQaC3a39AGeNSTgc9Jb5E5sjREpryA2`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n\n### Final community invulnerable set\n\n- **CoinStudio** — `CdW8izFcLeicL3zZUQaC3a39AGeNSTgc9Jb5E5sjREpryA2`\n- **ExtraCoin / Yaron** — `EXTrPKwb8ovrnaQMsBsf3nDZu4A4YdHgvNedAiY5DFyM3zB`\n- **Mile** — `HmatizNhXrZtXwQK2LfntvjCy3x1EuKs1WnRQ6CP3KkNfmA`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n- **HYPERSPEED** — `DV7b5AL9zNbsnQ8CWCwvw2tzc3pz74EVDLGQdNU1tujA2L5`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n- **YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna** — `DtuntvQBh9vajFTnd42aTTCiuCyY3ep6EVwhhPjj2ejyyhW`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n\nBest Regards,  \nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:08:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:08:18.270Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-25T17:30:48.000Z","cid":"QmUSKbpPHGXvkorm1UipNssta6cDnK7JSdgmsFyMJEsdVv","contentHash":"e057b7c568b8426ee85f4f0d9be5352c","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815408,"blockHash":"0x174fa3d63a85e2ff2f4bd8130a6c21d4e6b0e832104aaf327f8ad36d0507fa2c","blockTime":1790357448000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"e057b7c568b8426ee85f4f0d9be5352c","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama People Referendum\n\nThis is a vote about **Kusama People**, a blockchain in the Kusama network.\n\n- Kusama People is a **Tier 1** chain. That means it is very important.\n- It will have **8 special collators**. Collators are computers that help run the chain.\n- These 8 collators are paid by the community.\n- There will also be **4 open slots** for anyone to become a collator.\n- **6 new collators** are being added to the team.\n- **6 old collators** are being removed.\n- **2 collators** are staying: CoinStudio and Stakeworld.\n\nThe goal is to pick collators who have done a good job for a long time."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aa95f96d83e66628bb0c387","referendumIndex":662,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434372,"blockHash":"0xb276b1d686a3a29f6383a5d2d201d027c04b56325704d786939f2f2262a86c29","blockTime":1789484904000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":10,"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815408,"blockHash":"0x174fa3d63a85e2ff2f4bd8130a6c21d4e6b0e832104aaf327f8ad36d0507fa2c","blockTime":1790357448000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":10,"origin":{"origins":"StakingAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xe4985fc0c79606c0c2c3189e710d9487bf0d2d9b8bc5b26a2551a09d347e1da4","len":860}},"enactment":{"at":0},"submitted":35256171,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":35257371,"confirming":35397083},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35397083,[35397083,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800","electorate":"18004259922308456197"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xe4985fc0c79606c0c2c3189e710d9487bf0d2d9b8bc5b26a2551a09d347e1da4","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35397183,"index":0},"approved":[35397083,{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"18004259922308456197","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21810306,"blockHash":"0xaaae22af59f200c0740f0171b815ba160a5258ed3e9ed44168dcd1e23274ea86","blockTime":1790345808000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aa95f96d83e66628bb0c389","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21434372,"blockHash":"0xb276b1d686a3a29f6383a5d2d201d027c04b56325704d786939f2f2262a86c29","blockTime":1789484904000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmUSKbpPHGXvkorm1UipNssta6cDnK7JSdgmsFyMJEsdVv","createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:08:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:08:18.270Z","referendumIndex":662,"contentHash":"e057b7c568b8426ee85f4f0d9be5352c"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aa95f96d83e66628bb0c389","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"]},"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","publicKey":"f00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","address":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"6aa95f3ca04636a85d1e428d","referendumIndex":661,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434316,"blockHash":"0xa11bcdb56ca1385b544a6d650dc88ad23a2f73cd83f672116465748762bb197b","blockTime":1789484784000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","title":"Kusama Bridge Hub — Invulnerable Collator Set Adjustment","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis referendum seeks to adjust the invulnerable collator set of **Kusama Bridge Hub**.\n\nThe main objective is to make the invulnerable set better aligned with the risk profile and importance of the respective System Chain, while also keeping the assignment process efficient and consistent across the programme.\n\nThe curators also considered the historical assignment of slots across the System Chains. Where possible, the revised assignments favour operators with longer tenure and a demonstrated record of providing reliable service. At the same time, the changes are intended to help even the field for operators who have shown capability and interest in supporting additional System Chains.\n\nFinally, this referendum adjusts the number of permissionless collator slots to ensure that permissionless collators do not outweigh the intended invulnerable set.\n\nTo support this, the curators applied a tiering model where each System Chain is categorised from **Tier 1 to Tier 3**, based on its perceived importance and risk profile. Under this model, **Kusama Bridge Hub** is categorised as a **Tier-1** chain, with **8 funded community invulnerable collators**.\n\nFor **Kusama Bridge Hub**, the proposed configuration is:\n\n- **Tier:** Tier 1\n- **Community-funded invulnerable collators:** 8\n- **Permissionless collator slots:** 4\n\nThis referendum performs the following changes.\n\n### Collators being added\n\n- **BESTVALIDATOR / Zurich** — `GHW6TB6awErp2VaySKN6dLdjmzKET1LzCKMMTYMnGMUXs7n`\n- **CoinStudio** — `CdW8izFcLeicL3zZUQaC3a39AGeNSTgc9Jb5E5sjREpryA2`\n- **MathCrypto** — `F7TKjT2EBVqfquyN5G4s4FLSxHM7nR3WbdRAgxQLeJYVG53`\n- **openbitlab** — `E8X4LxU9zEiNVAYM95ERDeomMmwwwqn7RBCuRMEZCfgFm3JI`\n- **Staker Space** — `Etbi7EDExZ5GC5zVicHDXNLV1ygxMCTR3QscnkL2nku29v1`\n- **Faraday** — `HLsPiB2amYFPFYMcYqKxGFLgDUVd4UP1kdA4QdZsH3e91LP`\n\n### Collators being removed\n\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `CbLdvHtKPVr1bvt7poBKwJsQUokfjC4kqoMkjeyCDtFs8wQ`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `EXTRGokoMvv1BKrRKhjsz97tjHo8RCkNc1xcEQukLBN2NNH`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `GXm3xhzGWeofhBZiHHzGR9cB1UapoSApTE4GRbV5hDYv4vY`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n\n### Collators retained\n\nThe following community invulnerables are already in place and remain part of the final Bridge Hub set:\n\n- **YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna** — `DtuntvQBh9vajFTnd42aTTCiuCyY3ep6EVwhhPjj2ejyyhW`\n- **Mile** — `HmatizNhXrZtXwQK2LfntvjCy3x1EuKs1WnRQ6CP3KkNfmA`\n\n### Final community invulnerable set\n\n- **BESTVALIDATOR / Zurich** — `GHW6TB6awErp2VaySKN6dLdjmzKET1LzCKMMTYMnGMUXs7n`\n- **CoinStudio** — `CdW8izFcLeicL3zZUQaC3a39AGeNSTgc9Jb5E5sjREpryA2`\n- **YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna** — `DtuntvQBh9vajFTnd42aTTCiuCyY3ep6EVwhhPjj2ejyyhW`\n- **MathCrypto** — `F7TKjT2EBVqfquyN5G4s4FLSxHM7nR3WbdRAgxQLeJYVG53`\n- **Mile** — `HmatizNhXrZtXwQK2LfntvjCy3x1EuKs1WnRQ6CP3KkNfmA`\n- **openbitlab** — `E8X4LxU9zEiNVAYM95ERDeomMmwwwqn7RBCuRMEZCfgFm3JI`\n- **Staker Space** — `Etbi7EDExZ5GC5zVicHDXNLV1ygxMCTR3QscnkL2nku29v1`\n- **Faraday** — `HLsPiB2amYFPFYMcYqKxGFLgDUVd4UP1kdA4QdZsH3e91LP`\n\nBest Regards,  \nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:06:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:07:50.901Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-25T17:24:24.000Z","cid":"QmPQBXEHCT4YQQRrT2U2V97PF6cXchAJkYEewnx7QdyZjx","contentHash":"7ebb2f01e1e4f0a91f39f6d9d339bf39","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815240,"blockHash":"0x85c209e41a99d7119932d5b0f9bc4a328d6b0b83ea4ac88a82a09cc73970e35a","blockTime":1790357064000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"7ebb2f01e1e4f0a91f39f6d9d339bf39","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Bridge Hub Referendum\n\n## What is this?\nThis is a vote to change the special computer helpers for Kusama Bridge Hub.\n\n## What are the changes?\n- Kusama Bridge Hub is a **Tier 1** chain. That means it is very important.\n- It will have **8 special helpers** paid by the community.\n- It will have **4 open slots** for other helpers.\n\n## Who is joining?\n- BESTVALIDATOR / Zurich\n- CoinStudio\n- MathCrypto\n- openbitlab\n- Staker Space\n- Faraday\n\n## Who is leaving?\n- Four old helpers are being removed.\n\n## Who is staying?\n- YellowFin / Bluefin Tuna\n- Mile\n\n## Why does this matter?\n- The goal is to pick helpers who are reliable and have been around a long time.\n- The change also keeps the open helper slots from being too many compared to the special helpers."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aa95f23d83e66628bb0b52a","referendumIndex":661,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434316,"blockHash":"0xa11bcdb56ca1385b544a6d650dc88ad23a2f73cd83f672116465748762bb197b","blockTime":1789484784000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":10,"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815240,"blockHash":"0x85c209e41a99d7119932d5b0f9bc4a328d6b0b83ea4ac88a82a09cc73970e35a","blockTime":1790357064000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":10,"origin":{"origins":"StakingAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x46f331b2a1d1b32f712487577ec1d39b328eed1ec58ed169d4d75d7dfd3ae5e8","len":759}},"enactment":{"at":0},"submitted":35256152,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":35257352,"confirming":35397019},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35397019,[35397019,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800","electorate":"18004259922308456197"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x46f331b2a1d1b32f712487577ec1d39b328eed1ec58ed169d4d75d7dfd3ae5e8","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35397119,"index":0},"approved":[35397019,{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"18004259922308456197","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21810141,"blockHash":"0x07c5bec679f88276bd6c0fb85aa147027444dfd77fdde828d1a8cb5517717602","blockTime":1790345424000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aa95f23d83e66628bb0b52c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21434316,"blockHash":"0xa11bcdb56ca1385b544a6d650dc88ad23a2f73cd83f672116465748762bb197b","blockTime":1789484784000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"QmPQBXEHCT4YQQRrT2U2V97PF6cXchAJkYEewnx7QdyZjx","createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:06:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:07:50.901Z","referendumIndex":661,"contentHash":"7ebb2f01e1e4f0a91f39f6d9d339bf39"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aa95f23d83e66628bb0b52c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"]},"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","publicKey":"f00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","address":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6aa95ea3a04636a85d1d4587","referendumIndex":660,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434240,"blockHash":"0x265acc19b1939c2d3078984beac0413219dde064180d68e266f2ac6d9e5a5ab0","blockTime":1789484640000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","title":"Kusama Asset Hub — Invulnerable Collator Set Adjustment","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis referendum seeks to adjust the invulnerable collator set of **Kusama Asset Hub**.\n\nThe main objective is to make the invulnerable set better aligned with the risk profile and importance of the respective System Chain, while also keeping the assignment process efficient and consistent across the programme.\n\nThe curators also considered the historical assignment of slots across the System Chains. Where possible, the revised assignments favour operators with longer tenure and a demonstrated record of providing reliable service. At the same time, the changes are intended to help even the field for operators who have shown capability and interest in supporting additional System Chains.\n\nFinally, this referendum adjusts the number of permissionless collator slots to ensure that permissionless collators do not outweigh the intended invulnerable set.\n\nTo support this, the curators applied a tiering model where each System Chain is categorised from **Tier 1 to Tier 3**, based on its perceived importance and risk profile. Under this model, **Kusama Asset Hub** is categorised as a **Tier-1** chain, with **8 funded community invulnerable collators**.\n\nFor **Kusama Asset Hub**, the proposed configuration is:\n\n- **Tier:** Tier 1\n- **Community-funded invulnerable collators:** 8\n- **Permissionless collator slots:** 4\n\nThis referendum performs the following changes.\n\n### Collators being added\n\n- **MegaTron / Eric** — `FPJeeKkKhDE8uyid4MKvTj7KJNVczkobiDsxuMmrjPA4Wec`\n- **DPSTK / Dapestake** — `FCt4UxC6BfP6769winMs2YR6FdyL4dLcaw9qowekFySG3J2`\n\n### Collators being removed\n\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `CbLdvHtKPVr1bvt7poBKwJsQUokfjC4kqoMkjeyCDtFs8wQ`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `E5G5qLNBF7nwhemokqNrNwUCQ7oHrLsBVjSc7XhTdRq8672`\n- **Previous invulnerable** — `J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s`\n\n### Collators retained\n\nThe following community invulnerables are already in place and remain part of the final Asset Hub set:\n\n- **Polkadotters / pmensik** — `EPGHRDFaBbQz4uF8DgnuScxYp4rvvtpL5MTed7VvGprNQmm`\n- **Iceberg Nodes** — `Eicei1RVHvqHBPJAY2fZpLy2KtCMjY7Kwjo3svjmGLH7FmT`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n- **LuckyFriday** — `HPUEzi4v3YJmhBfSbcGEFFiNKPAGVnGkfDiUzBNTR7j1CxT`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n\n### Final community invulnerable set\n\n- **MegaTron / Eric** — `FPJeeKkKhDE8uyid4MKvTj7KJNVczkobiDsxuMmrjPA4Wec`\n- **Polkadotters / pmensik** — `EPGHRDFaBbQz4uF8DgnuScxYp4rvvtpL5MTed7VvGprNQmm`\n- **Iceberg Nodes** — `Eicei1RVHvqHBPJAY2fZpLy2KtCMjY7Kwjo3svjmGLH7FmT`\n- **Stakeworld** — `Et9M3rrA7H2kHQEGRXHxufcp9HTEmFirMWtKHvjoJ85r1C9`\n- **Turboflakes** — `H1tAQMm3eizGcmpAhL9aA9gR844kZpQfkU7pkmMiLx9jSzE`\n- **LuckyFriday** — `HPUEzi4v3YJmhBfSbcGEFFiNKPAGVnGkfDiUzBNTR7j1CxT`\n- **SIK / crifferent** — `HWyLYmpW68JGJYoVJcot6JQ1CJbtUQeTdxfY1kUTsvGCB1r`\n- **DPSTK / Dapestake** — `FCt4UxC6BfP6769winMs2YR6FdyL4dLcaw9qowekFySG3J2`\n\nBest Regards,  \nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:04:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:07:19.413Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-25T17:20:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815132,"blockHash":"0xdc68279a9b532e43ee18bc62c71283e3e64586555696a357745dc0a8dbcd54af","blockTime":1790356824000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmSoS47L6fZCU4gq5T3N6xbSqnrwAsaJWVx8kDSj3scSCY","contentHash":"c1cd9af50e519045d2a320e91d6f52ae","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"c1cd9af50e519045d2a320e91d6f52ae","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"**Kusama Asset Hub Collator Referendum**\n\n- This is a vote about who helps run **Kusama Asset Hub**.\n- Kusama Asset Hub is very important, so it is called a **Tier 1** chain.\n- It will have **8 special collators** that the community pays for.\n- It will also have **4 open spots** for anyone to join.\n- Two collators are **being added**: **MegaTron / Eric** and **DPSTK / Dapestake**.\n- Three old collators are **being removed**.\n- Six collators are **staying**.\n- This plan helps keep the important chain safe and working well."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6aa95e90d83e66628bb09e5e","referendumIndex":660,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21434240,"blockHash":"0x265acc19b1939c2d3078984beac0413219dde064180d68e266f2ac6d9e5a5ab0","blockTime":1789484640000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":10,"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21815132,"blockHash":"0xdc68279a9b532e43ee18bc62c71283e3e64586555696a357745dc0a8dbcd54af","blockTime":1790356824000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":10,"origin":{"origins":"StakingAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x46f331b2a1d1b32f712487577ec1d39b328eed1ec58ed169d4d75d7dfd3ae5e8","len":759}},"enactment":{"at":0},"submitted":35256127,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":35257327,"confirming":35396973},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35396973,[35396973,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018adf7e9785cc400","nays":3735030000000000,"support":"0x000000000000000018ad9d0b5c4d8800","electorate":"18004259922308456197"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x46f331b2a1d1b32f712487577ec1d39b328eed1ec58ed169d4d75d7dfd3ae5e8","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":35397073,"index":0},"approved":[35396973,{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"18004259922308456197","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21810002,"blockHash":"0x5e8bbcf85d3fce0e470d24dcb2ee70dc68b09a8d80c8561cc385756547ff01f8","blockTime":1790345136000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6aa95e90d83e66628bb09e60","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21434240,"blockHash":"0x265acc19b1939c2d3078984beac0413219dde064180d68e266f2ac6d9e5a5ab0","blockTime":1789484640000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmSoS47L6fZCU4gq5T3N6xbSqnrwAsaJWVx8kDSj3scSCY","createdAt":"2026-09-15T15:04:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:07:19.413Z","referendumIndex":660,"contentHash":"c1cd9af50e519045d2a320e91d6f52ae"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6aa95e90d83e66628bb09e60","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"]},"trackInfo":{"id":10,"name":"staking_admin","originalName":"staking_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","publicKey":"f00168a3d082a8ccf93945b1f173fdaecc1ce76fc09bbde18423640194be7212","address":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a9e539da04636a85d2d14a3","referendumIndex":659,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21117222,"blockHash":"0x05c4f0a13d2734fec8bcb7c790d30856c9d46095c5c43aca2c9204a60858bc2c","blockTime":1788760896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"proposer":"GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc","title":"Kusama System Collator Bounty 2nd Top-up - 2026","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis proposal requests a top-up for Kusama system parachain collators **covering seven months, from July 2026 through January 2027**.\n\nThe programme remains unchanged from Referendum [643](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/643):\n\n\n- **30 funded community invulnerable collators across AssetHub, BridgeHub, People, Coretime, and Encointer**\n- **3 curators at $250 per curator per month**\n- **$425 per month for hosting and local infrastructure**\n- **No funding for permissionless collators, staking rewards, tool development, or a separate coordinator fee**\n\nThe **total request is $60,725**. Using the **EMA7 KSM price of $3.5177** from 1 September 2026, this equals approximately **17,262.70 KSM**.\n\nThis top-up is needed earlier than expected because the lower KSM price has reduced the runway from Referendum [#643](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/643). The number of funded collators and the monthly funding model have not increased.\n\nNew proposal can be found here: https://gist.github.com/paradox-tt/61d47533f8d652c5ee380047e8ed00ac \nand an addendum for the updated calculation here: https://gist.github.com/paradox-tt/71aecb6d7ee3084492398aad2a19e201\n\nRegards,\n\nSystem Parachain Collator Bounty Curator Team\n","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-09-07T06:01:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-14T14:18:36.358Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-18T15:59:36.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21549015,"blockHash":"0xceb32fc53afb13dbee7e41c41332d7829ae49cee7d26e4c31c2666cf1bf1480e","blockTime":1789747176000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmUr82x8AJLvK1UnJNCzGaZQ5ySBZ3MqC6aCvG3Xa8cb5Y","contentHash":"645f8f6524896a0caf385eb3fa0da773","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"645f8f6524896a0caf385eb3fa0da773","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama System Parachain Collator Funding Top-Up\n\n- Kusama wants to give more money to help run small computer helpers called \"collators.\"\n- This money will pay for seven months, from July 2026 to January 2027.\n- It will pay for 30 helpers on five different Kusama projects.\n- It will also pay 3 people to watch over the work and pay for computers and internet.\n- The total cost is about $60,725, which is about 17,262 KSM.\n- They need this money sooner than planned because KSM is worth less now.\n- The plan is the same as before, and nothing costs more than last time."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"17262700000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a9e537f4b0bdfb0e9a06fa5","referendumIndex":659,"indexer":{"blockHeight":21117222,"blockHash":"0x05c4f0a13d2734fec8bcb7c790d30856c9d46095c5c43aca2c9204a60858bc2c","blockTime":1788760896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc","authors":["DPcLx1cnnJKvLfad4JTNzHA3T2vMmvwLHZSAj9gGim4qLjg","HLD3kgUaiwfi97wfLQSXAjhWf1NsbahcMYLijzNu3HNbG4B","HxyKNyZsr7gMAo2C4W4XKVt94MGLq71vJBm4Cs5YtbKgzxL","GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":21549015,"blockHash":"0xceb32fc53afb13dbee7e41c41332d7829ae49cee7d26e4c31c2666cf1bf1480e","blockTime":1789747176000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xa80d0bff66d0e7945772aa4c3f5988aeec08fb4b0ad0f79c823e82565c245e4e","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":35138726,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"HLD3kgUaiwfi97wfLQSXAjhWf1NsbahcMYLijzNu3HNbG4B","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":35141126,"confirming":35284251},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad4201035c6000","nays":"0x000000000000000003e7ae4e84632ee2","support":"0x000000000000000018ad4201035c6000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35284251,[35284251,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad4201035c6000","nays":"0x000000000000000003e7ae4e84632ee2","support":"0x000000000000000018ad4201035c6000","electorate":"17951868674661677047"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xa80d0bff66d0e7945772aa4c3f5988aeec08fb4b0ad0f79c823e82565c245e4e","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"17262700000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"}}]}],"amount":"17262700000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","beneficiaries":["F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"17262700000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"enactment":{"when":35298651,"index":0},"approved":[35284251,{"who":"GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc","amount":33333333333},{"who":"HLD3kgUaiwfi97wfLQSXAjhWf1NsbahcMYLijzNu3HNbG4B","amount":13333333333200}],"electorate":"17951868674661677047","treasuryProposalIndex":460,"treasuryProposalIndexes":[460],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21432430,"blockHash":"0xee89db2dca09e88eedb5d13889278025e484a68db318e83e2508573bb1d19991","blockTime":1789480488000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6a9e537f4b0bdfb0e9a06fa7","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":21117222,"blockHash":"0x05c4f0a13d2734fec8bcb7c790d30856c9d46095c5c43aca2c9204a60858bc2c","blockTime":1788760896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"cid":"QmUr82x8AJLvK1UnJNCzGaZQ5ySBZ3MqC6aCvG3Xa8cb5Y","createdAt":"2026-09-07T06:01:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-14T14:18:36.358Z","referendumIndex":659,"contentHash":"645f8f6524896a0caf385eb3fa0da773"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a9e537f4b0bdfb0e9a06fa7","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["DPcLx1cnnJKvLfad4JTNzHA3T2vMmvwLHZSAj9gGim4qLjg","HLD3kgUaiwfi97wfLQSXAjhWf1NsbahcMYLijzNu3HNbG4B","HxyKNyZsr7gMAo2C4W4XKVt94MGLq71vJBm4Cs5YtbKgzxL","GsGcRLXWFcVnxUaWVE9ojJpnDNM9R7QNxYBrshWtnTcohyc"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":3},{"_id":"6a969e1ea04636a85d7a1f85","referendumIndex":658,"indexer":{"blockHeight":20895080,"blockHash":"0x59a34c11fbaeedf655e8b0993fa059425dd001b4c3061c556b92dc05daa3ed44","blockTime":1788255696000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","title":"Kusama Shield Audit","content":"## Title Kusama Shield Audit\n\n\nSummary:\nThe Kusama Shield project is a treasury funded project that has been developing a privacy protocol for assets on Kusama, Polkadot and Paseo. Being one of the first Zero Knowledge smart contract protocol on the hub. After some time of developing, the project is in need of a code audit, as we are dealing with production systems with real peoples assets. User safety is a big priority and therefore we are asking the community to help us fund a security audit by a cherry picked talented Zero Knowledge auditor. \n\nProposal Total USD Amount:\n56605 USD \n\nAmount of milestones:\n1\n\nX link:\nhttps://x.com/KusamaShield \n\nPrevious proposals:\nhttps://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/631 - 99% Aye\nhttps://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/509 - 89% Aye\n\n\nCost comparison: \n Moonbeam by SRLabs  - https://dotpal.io/community_reports/2026-Q1 - 133,692 DOT\n\nStorageHub’s codebase Audit -  385,978 USD - https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/830\nInk 5 audit - 238,920 USD - https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1045 \nZero Knowledge engineers costs 140 000 - 350 000 USD / source: https://jobcannon.io/careers/zero-knowledge-proof-engineer\n\nThe Kusama Shield project has done lots to squeeze the price without affecting the quality of the Audit. \n\nRead full proposal here:\nhttps://docs.google.com/document/d/1yIEtCjgcXViHaNxKVkXYjS0UFhDVVuUsnVMMnuNC3EA/edit?usp=sharing \n\n\n\n> 4) What's the project's current usage? current tvl? number of users and txs?    \nWe have soft commitments from projects, but since most larger project really insist on integrating with Audited projects.. Here is some user numbers:\nPaseo: ~ 4-5000 shielded transactions\nPolkadot: ~200 shielded tx on the latest pool(the v7 contracts) | ~500 swaps | offramps user we dont know\nKusama: not sure, will update once knowing\n\n\n\n> Kusama Shield is doing important zk development \n\nTogether with our SDK:\nhttps://pypi.org/project/shielded-transfers/    \nhttps://pypi.org/project/light-poseidon-python/   \nhttps://www.npmjs.com/package/@kusamashield/shielded-transfers  \n\nWe have build fast indexers for EVM events, been the togo place for new people wanting to build zk projects as well as pioneering Poseidon on PolkadVM.      \n\n\n\n\n","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-09-01T09:41:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:04:44.959Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-09-15T22:54:48.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":21446420,"blockHash":"0x42f6462706fc781a91f535ce1aa9eb6a2d19ba3dff98f044bcc7917ac537a1c7","blockTime":1789512888000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007d536cf73aafb6","nays":"0x000000000000000000e6fbc310698ce1","support":"0x00000000000000000055d81ed351b149"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"QmR9yYiACxaxK4aCiDQVwHniF98Zg3TXpBAMqRyq3pH6WT","contentHash":"23628053ee973e84eda03c5d126b0708","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"23628053ee973e84eda03c5d126b0708","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"# Kusama Shield Audit\n\nKusama Shield is a project that keeps people's digital money safe and private on Kusama, Polkadot, and Paseo.\n\n- The project is one of the first to use special \"Zero Knowledge\" tech on the network.\n- It was paid for by the community's treasury.\n- The team now needs a security expert to check their code, because real people's money is involved.\n- They are asking the community to pay about 56,605 US dollars for this safety check.\n- There is only one step (milestone) in this plan.\n- The team says their price is much lower than other similar audits.\n- People have already used it: about 4,000 to 5,000 private transactions on Paseo, and around 200 on Polkadot.\n- Two earlier proposals were liked by the community, with 99% and 89% voting yes."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"17225000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a969e0e223a00dc579cdec3","referendumIndex":658,"indexer":{"blockHeight":20895080,"blockHash":"0x59a34c11fbaeedf655e8b0993fa059425dd001b4c3061c556b92dc05daa3ed44","blockTime":1788255696000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","authors":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":21446420,"blockHash":"0x42f6462706fc781a91f535ce1aa9eb6a2d19ba3dff98f044bcc7917ac537a1c7","blockTime":1789512888000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007d536cf73aafb6","nays":"0x000000000000000000e6fbc310698ce1","support":"0x00000000000000000055d81ed351b149"}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x863292e8ac0f4d23ca1742ffcb7f68ff051c8d95c02a3512e413b1359ff7b9db","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":1},"submitted":35056714,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":35059114,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007d536cf73aafb6","nays":"0x000000000000000000e6fbc310698ce1","support":"0x00000000000000000055d81ed351b149"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[35260714,[35260714,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000007d536cf73aafb6","nays":"0x000000000000000000e6fbc310698ce1","support":"0x00000000000000000055d81ed351b149","electorate":"17946069008425678367"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x863292e8ac0f4d23ca1742ffcb7f68ff051c8d95c02a3512e413b1359ff7b9db","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"17225000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"}}]}],"amount":"17225000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","beneficiaries":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"17225000000000000","beneficiary":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"electorate":"17946069008425678367","rejected":[35260714,{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ","amount":13333333333200}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":21419310,"blockHash":"0xd9f036f67c64ddc59dcca1b5a5e783dfbed798e63716e572a57a3e54e9fff8a4","blockTime":1789450512000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6a969e0e223a00dc579cdec5","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":20895080,"blockHash":"0x59a34c11fbaeedf655e8b0993fa059425dd001b4c3061c556b92dc05daa3ed44","blockTime":1788255696000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"QmR9yYiACxaxK4aCiDQVwHniF98Zg3TXpBAMqRyq3pH6WT","createdAt":"2026-09-01T09:41:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-15T16:04:44.959Z","referendumIndex":658,"contentHash":"23628053ee973e84eda03c5d126b0708"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a969e0e223a00dc579cdec5","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xf621771ddf37d482210b8c59617952eb1c2b40cfec55df47215231365186a057","publicKey":"f621771ddf37d482210b8c59617952eb1c2b40cfec55df47215231365186a057","emailMd5":"c102b6392e99147dbc4f2f7e94503df4","address":"J93EoDa5dpL1EiF4pKj3Q7gFmcSYL7kwTKuECemKDLVQohQ"},"commentsCount":11},{"_id":"6a625a3fa04636a85d604005","referendumIndex":657,"indexer":{"blockHeight":19383125,"blockHash":"0xd959e8ce6c60e06b2677e6edcacfe061cbed69abe15b162a5c52c8239915fc1e","blockTime":1784830464000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","title":"Runtime Upgrade 2.3.2","content":"Update all system chains to [Release v2.3.2](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/releases/tag/v2.3.2).\n\nWhitelisted by https://collectives.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/586","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-07-23T18:14:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-07-24T08:50:52.992Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-07-27T12:02:00.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":19533166,"blockHash":"0x591ae0bdb1fdada129a918e97278247e10b5bcd9fa7f5e5efeb1dc2c4bae1f8e","blockTime":1785153720000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"cid":"bafybeics2xrqzevals4qzf3jhj7rjoeks6u4iro77u3xl2fqpmor2fmgsu","contentHash":"7a5efcef79d5a5c3ba4fea31a4ef5d4c","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a625a369a0627a15b066f98","referendumIndex":657,"indexer":{"blockHeight":19383125,"blockHash":"0xd959e8ce6c60e06b2677e6edcacfe061cbed69abe15b162a5c52c8239915fc1e","blockTime":1784830464000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":19533166,"blockHash":"0x591ae0bdb1fdada129a918e97278247e10b5bcd9fa7f5e5efeb1dc2c4bae1f8e","blockTime":1785153720000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x830467ede7768730e4f6a094aa8a0adcc02fe071a2a82258fb633961016bbe04","len":291}},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":34502080,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":34502381,"confirming":34554231},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000032e40666ac08e22","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018e0494ed47bdb7c"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34554231,[34554231,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000032e40666ac08e22","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018e0494ed47bdb7c","electorate":"17751157402730493090"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0x1ad7e31dc39fbf61bb3ba7aff65086f5fa75c7b8b735ddf4cc1ebd8c0289f0f4"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x830467ede7768730e4f6a094aa8a0adcc02fe071a2a82258fb633961016bbe04","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":34554331,"index":0},"approved":[34554231,{"who":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","amount":33333333333},{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"17751157402730493090","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":19532569,"blockHash":"0xd4b595269d3f60b4709e0a8e7f449ce5c35729c2bac9c6ed0bcb7b891a93d519","blockTime":1785152520000,"eventIndex":0}},"polkassemblyCommentsCount":null,"polkassemblyId":null,"polkassemblyPostType":null,"refToPost":{"postId":"6a625a369a0627a15b066f9a","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":19383125,"blockHash":"0xd959e8ce6c60e06b2677e6edcacfe061cbed69abe15b162a5c52c8239915fc1e","blockTime":1784830464000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"bafybeics2xrqzevals4qzf3jhj7rjoeks6u4iro77u3xl2fqpmor2fmgsu","createdAt":"2026-07-23T18:14:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-07-24T08:50:52.992Z","referendumIndex":657,"contentHash":"7a5efcef79d5a5c3ba4fea31a4ef5d4c"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a625a369a0627a15b066f9a","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a3c05e1a04636a85d8e37ed","referendumIndex":656,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18290039,"blockHash":"0xa9e9182d6ae3eb772f2f9b4fa0b2454c5295afb194d9c47913fd247eb4272cd0","blockTime":1782318480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi","title":".ID username authority registration for the dotID identity registrar","content":"Dear Kusama community,\n\nThis proposal requests to add dotID as a username authority for the `.id` suffix on Kusama People Chain.\n\nThis same referendum was proposed, already approved and executed on Polkadot, granting dotID the authority over `.id` usernames on Polkadot People Chain, and this same authority is now requested on Kusama.\n\nReference of the Polkadot referendum: https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1898\n\ndotID is operated by Adam / ECH0.RE, a long-time Polkadot ecosystem contributor, validator operator, and OpenGov-approved People Chain registrar on both Polkadot and Kusama. Referendum #626 granted ECH0.RE registrar status with 100% approval.\n\nReference: https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/626\n\ndotID is an identity-focused platform for the Polkadot ecosystem: https://dotid.app\n\nIt provides a complete end-to-end flow for People Chain identity without requesting any fee: users can manage their on-chain identity, verify signals such as social accounts and e-mail, complete KYC verification, request Reasonable or KnownGood judgements, and explore identities through a public directory.\n\nTo the best of my knowledge, dotID is currently the only automated platform offering all these features free of charge.\n\nBeyond the web application itself, dotID also actively monitors on-chain identities across the ecosystem. This includes identifying outdated, low-quality, suspicious, or potentially malicious identities, and helping keep the identity layer cleaner and more useful for users.\n\nAdding the `.id` suffix would complete this identity flow with a human-readable username layer. Users, projects, teams, and organizations could receive curated `.id` usernames directly through dotID.\n\nThe `.id` username request would be integrated directly into the dotID.app workflow, alongside identity management, verification and judgement requests.\n\nThe `.id` suffix is naturally associated with identity and public profiles. It is also aligned with the dotID name, as `.id` can be read as “dot ID”.\n\n## FAQ\n\n**Does this affect `.dot` usernames?**  \nEven though there is currently no `.dot` authority on Kusama, no, this proposal only concerns authority over usernames using the `.id` suffix. It does not affect other future username suffixes such as `.dot`.\n\n**Is this competing with `.dot`?**  \nNo. There is no intended competition with `.dot`. The purpose of `.id` is to provide a dedicated namespace for verified or curated on-chain identities, aligned with dotID’s existing identity and verification workflow.\n\n**Does this affect on-chain identities or judgements?**  \nNo. This proposal does not modify the identity system, registrar judgements, or existing identities. It only grants dotID authority to issue usernames using the `.id` suffix.\n\n**Will `.id` usernames be forced on users?**  \nNo. Users must request or accept a username. The goal is to integrate `.id` username requests into the dotID.app workflow.\n\n**Why dotID?**  \ndotID is already an OpenGov-approved People Chain registrar and currently provides the only automated end-to-end platform for identity management, verification, Reasonable / KnownGood judgement requests, and identity directory exploration.  \nIn addition, dotID is currently the authority over `.id` usernames on Polkadot.","contentType":"markdown","track":14,"createdAt":"2026-06-24T16:28:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-24T16:39:17.450Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-07-08T05:50:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18789485,"blockHash":"0xaa787d8b8789228089cb4b91a1bc538bdef2aab0698a4da649d09050560eac2a","blockTime":1783489824000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":0,"polkassemblyId":656,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeiaubo2rx6bldgfo7bp3kisq3zj6zrqc7bx7ondez7pueprs7q7siq","contentHash":"357a30b12a17664340dc0a31d7637036","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"357a30b12a17664340dc0a31d7637036","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- dotID wants to be the boss of `.id` usernames on Kusama.\n- This already happened on Polkadot, and now it's asked for Kusama.\n- dotID helps people manage their online identity without charging money.\n- It checks social accounts, email, and gives special badges.\n- It also watches for fake or bad identities.\n- `.id` usernames are like readable name tags for people.\n- This won't change other usernames like `.dot`.\n- No one is forced to get a `.id` username."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a3c05d156efaf8d69b02d29","referendumIndex":656,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18290039,"blockHash":"0xa9e9182d6ae3eb772f2f9b4fa0b2454c5295afb194d9c47913fd247eb4272cd0","blockTime":1782318480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":14,"trackInfo":{"id":14,"name":"general_admin","originalName":"general_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":49586777,"xOffset":90909091,"yOffset":-45454546}}},"proposer":"JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi","authors":["JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x1f00","section":"polkadotXcm","method":"send"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18789485,"blockHash":"0xaa787d8b8789228089cb4b91a1bc538bdef2aab0698a4da649d09050560eac2a","blockTime":1783489824000,"eventIndex":2},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":14,"origin":{"origins":"GeneralAdmin"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xb71c3b0492dd441ff30c6e305a2b6c3f2b2f7d40100acb0006de6f0dd77633d3","len":59}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":34095795,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"CiDLYhmkbfwaUAuMqjNHLeK3xXnSikYWDpQgsW8R2vANNj9","amount":166666666665000},"deciding":{"since":34104794,"confirming":34285322},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000003f67ba2a94a634e","nays":0,"support":"0x0000000000000000014b79d50a4ae4b7"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34285322,[34285322,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000003f67ba2a94a634e","nays":0,"support":"0x0000000000000000014b79d50a4ae4b7","electorate":"17679350517110563940"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xb71c3b0492dd441ff30c6e305a2b6c3f2b2f7d40100acb0006de6f0dd77633d3","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":34285426,"index":0},"approved":[34285326,{"who":"JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi","amount":33333333333},{"who":"CiDLYhmkbfwaUAuMqjNHLeK3xXnSikYWDpQgsW8R2vANNj9","amount":166666666665000}],"electorate":"17679350517110563940","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":18784479,"blockHash":"0x4b0fe8791955ce3c971d15ef731f52587459616197fb8c1bb786cf9228b83172","blockTime":1783477968000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a3c05d156efaf8d69b02d2b","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":18290039,"blockHash":"0xa9e9182d6ae3eb772f2f9b4fa0b2454c5295afb194d9c47913fd247eb4272cd0","blockTime":1782318480000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"bafybeiaubo2rx6bldgfo7bp3kisq3zj6zrqc7bx7ondez7pueprs7q7siq","createdAt":"2026-06-24T16:28:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-24T16:39:17.450Z","referendumIndex":656,"contentHash":"357a30b12a17664340dc0a31d7637036"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a3c05d156efaf8d69b02d2b","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi"]},"trackInfo":{"id":14,"name":"general_admin","originalName":"general_admin\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"166666666665000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":1800,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":49586777,"xOffset":90909091,"yOffset":-45454546}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xfafe6ff6945e27f3c39fe8bf5a90cb0fa61b3c27c9faa3ba3741362643ee303f","publicKey":"fafe6ff6945e27f3c39fe8bf5a90cb0fa61b3c27c9faa3ba3741362643ee303f","address":"JFR5AdPzxoCjUVQzpUAkSTUZoGMdbEKtsqJSR8pVwMS6Voi"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6a32f6c7a04636a85d511720","referendumIndex":655,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18037107,"blockHash":"0xb4fac58b9fbf1a07ce66c139b958bd6fa76b6c793d588f95a33183f679b7fcf9","blockTime":1781724792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","title":"Validator set reduction to 700","content":"This referendum proposes carrying out the first step proposed by Daniel Olano ([@olanod](/user/EvoLanodoqDsgHb98Ymbu41uXXKfCPDKxeM6dXHyJ2JoVus)) in [Adapting Kusama to demand and its JAM future](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/proposal-discussion-adapting-kusama-to-demand-and-its-jam-future/17141): reducing the Kusama validator set size from 1000 to 700.\n\nIn addition to the long-term goal to have Kusama operate a lightweight version of JAM, as expressed in [WFC #573](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573) and approved by the Kusama community, this reduction will also provide relief to Kusama validators given the increased difficulty in operating a Kusama validator economically - especially operators of singleton validators.\n\n[Adapting Kusama to demand and its JAM future](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/proposal-discussion-adapting-kusama-to-demand-and-its-jam-future/17141) proposes a multistep reduction timeline to 120 validators over a 6 month timeframe.\nThis referendum is not a commitment to the full timeline, but only the first step.\nThe reasons for staging only the first step for now are:\n1. It removes the current over-provisioning: reducing the validator set to 700 aligns it with the paravalidator population of 700 (for 140 cores) that Kusama actually makes available today. Any further reductions would require reducing the available cores.\n2. While there may be broad agreement that a reduction to 700 is sensible, there could be diverging opinions on the final validator count the network should land on, and how many cores the network should provide. In particular, neither Polkadot nor Kusama have ever reduced their validator set sizes to date, so it's also prudent to gather relevant data from this first reduction's impact before proceeding with any further reductions.\n\nIf this referendum is approved, after a few weeks, we can assess the impact of reducing the validator set to 700 and decide whether to proceed with further reductions as outlined in Daniel's plan, or alter the path based on data and community feedback.\n\nFor the preimage and integration tests, see https://hackmd.io/@Lederstrumpf/referendum-kusama-validator-set-reduction-to-700-runtime-2_3_0\n\nWhitelisting referendum: https://kusama.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/132","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-06-17T19:33:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-22T19:55:57.314Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-27T02:03:12.000Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":655,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18378267,"blockHash":"0x1bd766eaca7142ef523b5d8a576a0130365d2ab3aacf88c6df4e1624a862f7dc","blockTime":1782525792000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeidfxnulwnfesv5qzod7aykxp2faouupbbgvfjnnyrqv75d6x3w4ra","contentHash":"d4b257bee6109ebe3612da1ae49dfc46","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"d4b257bee6109ebe3612da1ae49dfc46","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- Kusama validator set will shrink from 1000 to 700.  \n- This is the first step in a plan to possibly go down to 120 validators.  \n- The change matches Kusama's current need for only 700 validators.  \n- It helps validators who struggle to earn enough running a single validator.  \n- No more steps will happen until after this change is studied.  \n- This vote does not commit to future reductions, only this one."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a32f6c14ccad71ae5303c45","referendumIndex":655,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18037107,"blockHash":"0xb4fac58b9fbf1a07ce66c139b958bd6fa76b6c793d588f95a33183f679b7fcf9","blockTime":1781724792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","authors":["FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18378267,"blockHash":"0x1bd766eaca7142ef523b5d8a576a0130365d2ab3aacf88c6df4e1624a862f7dc","blockTime":1782525792000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xffb285c341ca3ba65c5b6a5c62980351ad2da532b8b664cd752b05d477568d5d","len":6}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":34000143,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":34002541,"confirming":34129154},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001bb32b7504a48322","nays":"0x00000000000000000053c6e759018000","support":"0x00000000000000000d64398abf769efc"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34129154,[34129154,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001bb32b7504a48322","nays":"0x00000000000000000053c6e759018000","support":"0x00000000000000000d64398abf769efc","electorate":"17579190463956782664"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0xc96ba133f1a5bfa8f00ac31f43b166a48129a56fb2499e4e89945e00d174a2cd"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xffb285c341ca3ba65c5b6a5c62980351ad2da532b8b664cd752b05d477568d5d","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[132],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":34129254,"index":0},"approved":[34129154,{"who":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","amount":33333333333},{"who":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"17579190463956782664","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":18377734,"blockHash":"0xc0cd83df869a1434fcaaa45c3cb9d6738f7eb28d96bbe72233a2d746a5b8a6fb","blockTime":1782524544000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a32f6c14ccad71ae5303c47","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":18037107,"blockHash":"0xb4fac58b9fbf1a07ce66c139b958bd6fa76b6c793d588f95a33183f679b7fcf9","blockTime":1781724792000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeidfxnulwnfesv5qzod7aykxp2faouupbbgvfjnnyrqv75d6x3w4ra","createdAt":"2026-06-17T19:33:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-22T19:55:57.314Z","referendumIndex":655,"contentHash":"d4b257bee6109ebe3612da1ae49dfc46"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a32f6c14ccad71ae5303c47","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x76016fc20a6457ff8953bf29686c5698c28bbfa860669ddd07b386c910f1107d","publicKey":"76016fc20a6457ff8953bf29686c5698c28bbfa860669ddd07b386c910f1107d","address":"FF3bTawSmxLcVAVFfze5gatuFec58fkp78ceL7Z9ivtXHRC"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a3242b8a04636a85d386981","referendumIndex":654,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18017269,"blockHash":"0x60a7d6517ce6f3b6f54e71b5e88cb9803e7d9a733fd447fa11e9ff38c5248b1e","blockTime":1781678712000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn","title":"Bifrost KSM Liquidity Loan — Renewal","content":"**Treasury Proposal | June 2026\nProposer:** Tyrone - Bifrost\n\n---\n\n## 1. Executive Summary\n\nBifrost successfully completed its KSM liquidity loan (Referendum #477). Over the 18-month period from Dec 2024 to May 2026, the 50,000 KSM loan generated 3,637.98 KSM in interest (blended APR: 4.85%), and Bifrost distributed 85,568.9838 BNC (~$7,950) in liquidity incentives to the vKSM-KSM pool.\n\nBifrost now proposes to:\n\n- Repay the interest (3,637.98 KSM) to the Kusama Treasury upon execution of the pending vKSM unstaking referendum. (Currently in processing: bifrost-kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/139, expected to complete June 23, 2026)\n- Renew the existing 50,000 KSM loan for a further 18 months at a blended interest rate of ~2% per annum. (Bifrost will **NOT** take any commission from it)\n\n---\n\n## 2. Performance Report (Dec 2024 – May 2026)\n\n### 2.1 Loan Structure & Returns\n\n| Item | Value | Notes |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **Principal** |  |  |\n| Total loan amount | 50,000 KSM |  |\n| **Liquidity Pool Deployment** |  |  |\n| Minted as vKSM (liquid staking) | 25,000 KSM | 50% in pool — generates staking yield |\n| Deployed as liquidity | 25,000 KSM | 50% in pool — does not generate staking yield |\n| **Returns (Dec 2024 – May 2026)** |  |  |\n| Total interest earned | 3,637.98 KSM |  |\n| Blended APR | **4.85%** |  |\n\nA total of 50,000 KSM was borrowed and deployed in vKSM/KSM liquidity: 25,000 KSM (50%) was minted into vKSM, while the remaining 25,000 KSM (50%) was deployed in the stable pool against vKSM. Over the 18-month period, the position generated 3,637.98 KSM in total interest, reflecting a blended APR of 4.85%.\n\n### 2.2 Liquidity Incentives — Bifrost's Continued Commitment\n\n| Item | Value | Value in USD |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **Liquidity Incentives (BNC)** |  |  |\n| Total BNC rewarded (Dec 2024 – May 2026) | 85,568.9838 BNC | ~$7,950 based on 1-yr avg. price |\n\nOver the 18-month loan period, Bifrost distributed a total of **85,568.9838 BNC (~$7,950)** in liquidity incentives to the vKSM-KSM pool — reflecting Bifrost's continued commitment to deepening KSM liquid staking liquidity throughout the loan term.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Repayment Commitment\n\nBifrost commits to repaying the interest in full to the Kusama Treasury upon execution of the pending vKSM unstaking referendum.\n\n| Item | Value | Notes |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| Principal | 50,000 KSM | Propose to roll into the next 18-month term |\n| Interest | 3,637.98 KSM | To be paid to Treasury upon execution of Referendum #139 |\n\nThe 3,637.98 KSM interest is currently being unstaked from vKSM under Bifrost-Kusama Referendum #139, expected to complete on **June 23, 2026**, after which it will be transferred directly to the Kusama Treasury.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Proposed Terms — Next Term\n\n| Parameter | Next Term | Notes |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| Loan amount | 50,000 KSM | Renewal of existing loan |\n| Loan duration | 18 months from enactment | Repayment due 18 months after enactment; specific date to be confirmed once enactment occurs |\n| Blended interest rate | **~2% per annum** (~3% cumulative over the 18-month term) | Contingent on Kusama staking APY ~4% |\n| vKSM allocation | 50% of principal | 25,000 KSM minted as vKSM |\n| Liquidity allocation | 50% of principal | 25,000 KSM deployed to vKSM-KSM pool |\n| Commission | None | Bifrost will **NOT** take any commission from this loan |\n| Repayment | Principal + interest at maturity | Full repayment due 18 months after enactment |\n\n### 4.1 Interest Rate Rationale\n\nThe blended interest rate for the next term is projected at **approximately 2% per annum** (~3% cumulative over the 18-month term), and **Bifrost will NOT take any commission from it**. This projection is based on the 25,000 KSM minted as vKSM (50% of principal) earning an assumed Kusama staking APY of ~4%; the remaining 25,000 KSM deployed to the vKSM-KSM liquidity pool does not generate staking yield. Actual returns will vary with Kusama network staking yields, which fluctuate with inflation, validator commission rates, and total stake participation.\n\n### 4.2 Capital Deployment\n\n- 50% (25,000 KSM) will be minted as vKSM via Bifrost SLP, accruing staking rewards through the vKSM yield-bearing mechanism.\n- 50% (25,000 KSM) will be paired with vKSM and deployed to the vKSM-KSM liquidity pool on Bifrost, deepening on-chain liquidity and reducing slippage for vKSM transactions.\n- No KSM will be used for speculative positions or off-protocol deployments.\n\n---\n\n## 5. LST Governance & vKSM Voting Rights\n\nBeyond liquidity and yield, vKSM carries full Kusama OpenGov participation rights. This section outlines vKSM's governance utility and clarifies how voting rights are handled for the vKSM minted under this loan.\n\n### 5.1 vKSM Holders Can Vote in Kusama OpenGov\n\nvKSM holders can participate directly in Kusama on-chain governance. Since the KSM underlying vKSM is staked via Bifrost's sovereign address and its derived keyless addresses on Kusama, these addresses carry full governance voting rights. Through the Bifrost DApp, vKSM holders can:\n\n- View active Kusama OpenGov referenda.\n- Vote Aye / Nay / Abstain with conviction multipliers (0.1x–6x).\n- Lock vKSM for voting without losing staking yield — exchange rate appreciation continues during lock.\n- Participate in multiple referenda simultaneously.\n\nThis means vKSM holders do not sacrifice governance rights when liquid-staking KSM.\n\n### 5.2 BNC Governance: Delegated vKSM Voting\n\nBifrost introduces a governance layer: BNC holders can direct the voting rights of vKSM that has been delegated to Bifrost but whose holders have not cast a vote themselves.\n\nSpecifically:\n\n- When vKSM holders delegate their voting proxy to Bifrost, their unexercised voting power becomes available for BNC-governed allocation.\n- BNC holders can then collectively decide how this delegated vKSM voting weight is cast in Kusama OpenGov referenda.\n- This mechanism does not affect vKSM holders who vote independently — only unclaimed delegated votes are subject to BNC governance.\n\nThis feature meaningfully increases Kusama governance participation and gives BNC holders a direct stake in the direction of the Kusama ecosystem — creating a deeper, more organic alignment between Bifrost and Kusama governance.\n\nReference: docs.bifrost.io/faq/what-is-lst-governance\n\n### 5.3 Note on Loan-Derived vKSM\n\nThe 25,000 vKSM minted under this loan and deployed into the vKSM-KSM liquidity pool will be held under Bifrost Treasury custody and will not participate in the delegated voting mechanism described in Section 5.2 — it is excluded from Kusama OpenGov voting entirely (neither voted directly by Bifrost nor delegated under BNC governance), avoiding any appearance of loan-derived capital being used to influence on-chain governance outcomes.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Risk Disclosure\n\n- **Interest rate variability:** The ~2% per annum blended interest rate is based on an assumed Kusama staking APY of ~4%, applied to the 25,000 KSM minted as vKSM. Kusama staking yields fluctuate with network inflation, validator commission rates, and total stake participation, so the realized blended return at maturity may differ materially from this projection.\n- **Governance risk:** Bifrost maintains an actively governed protocol with consistent on-chain participation. The team continuously monitors Bifrost governance for referenda involving sensitive method calls — including any that could affect SLP logic, fund movements, or protocol parameters — and responds promptly to ensure the security and integrity of deployed assets.\n- **Liquidity risk:** The vKSM-KSM liquidity pool carries no impermanent loss risk. Although the composition of the position may shift between vKSM and KSM as liquidity is deposited and withdrawn, vKSM can always be unstaked back to KSM after withdrawal. The principal is therefore recoverable in full regardless of pool rebalancing.\n\n---\n\n## 7. Track Record\n\n**Kusama**\n\n- 2022: https://kusama.polkassembly.io/post/1606\n    - The execution timeline of the proposal: https://kusama.subscan.io/treasury/177\n    - 2023: Repayment 53,745.5028 KSM via Bifrost Treasury via XCM, with **3,745.5028 KSM interest**.\n- 2023: https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/236\n    - The execution timeline of the proposal: https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/236?tab=timeline\n    - 2024: Repayment 54,625.0495 KSM via Bifrost Treasury via XCM, with **4,625.0495 KSM interest**.\n- 2023: https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/477 (this loan)\n    - The execution timeline of the proposal: https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/477?tab=timeline\n    - Loan period: Dec 2024 – May 2026 (18 months); generated **3,637.98 KSM interest** (blended APR 4.85%).\n    - Interest repayment (3,637.98 KSM) is being processed via vKSM unstaking under Bifrost-Kusama Referendum #139, expected to complete on **June 23, 2026**, after which it will be transferred to the Kusama Treasury.\n\nBifrost has brought a total income of **8,370.5523 KSM** to the Kusama Treasury to date; upon completion of the pending repayment above, cumulative income will rise to approximately **12,008.5323 KSM**.\n\n**Polkadot**\n\n- 2024: https://polkadot.polkassembly.io/treasury/613\n    - The execution timeline of the proposal: https://polkadot.polkassembly.io/treasury/613?tab=timeline\n    - Bifrost repaid its Subsidy loan to the Polkadot Treasury on March 26th.\n        - Principal: 500,000.00 DOT\n        - Staking rewards (interest from 216,313.34 vDOT): 42,723.02 DOT\n        - **Total Repayment: 542,723.02 DOT**\n\n---\n\n## References\n\n- Bifrost Website: bifrost.io\n- Documentation: docs.bifrost.io\n- LST Governance: docs.bifrost.io/faq/what-is-lst-governance\n- Twitter: https://x.com/Bifrost","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-06-17T06:45:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-17T06:46:49.047Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-07-05T10:05:36.000Z","cid":"bafybeifnue6xsovtx7tnzlxua4zeus3ny2zc3k7bscgek5oomeyzjzidaa","contentHash":"d7f99209a7db2eb742e59ca61fa55880","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":654,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18684554,"blockHash":"0x66fba5ff4daa00874d13976b6a5ba08d7f9a02ea219b1365f2813a4e49a2b151","blockTime":1783245936000,"eventIndex":0},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"contentSummary":{"contentHash":"d7f99209a7db2eb742e59ca61fa55880","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- Bifrost borrowed 50,000 KSM and earned 3,637.98 KSM in interest.\n- The interest will be paid back to the Kusama Treasury by June 23, 2026.\n- Bifrost wants to borrow the same 50,000 KSM again for another 18 months.\n- The new interest rate will be about 2% each year.\n- Half of the KSM will be used for staking, and half for trading pairs.\n- Bifrost has paid back over 8,000 KSM to the Treasury in previous loans."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a3242b21bf1ede2f5f9e629","referendumIndex":654,"indexer":{"blockHeight":18017269,"blockHash":"0x60a7d6517ce6f3b6f54e71b5e88cb9803e7d9a733fd447fa11e9ff38c5248b1e","blockTime":1781678712000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn","authors":["GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18684554,"blockHash":"0x66fba5ff4daa00874d13976b6a5ba08d7f9a02ea219b1365f2813a4e49a2b151","blockTime":1783245936000,"eventIndex":0},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x743eb29f283921350fd85dfe3f020b80da2310f66e23f6e49622e61f53ee556a","len":87}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":33992735,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":34067712,"confirming":34245888},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000003f372cad1d18394","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000016fefb211c481825"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34245888,[34245888,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000003f372cad1d18394","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000016fefb211c481825","electorate":"17666184208409411159"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["Bifrost KSM Liquidity Loan - Renewal, please read the full contents in description."],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x743eb29f283921350fd85dfe3f020b80da2310f66e23f6e49622e61f53ee556a","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":34245988,"index":0},"approved":[34245888,{"who":"GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn","amount":33333333333},{"who":"FrRVvtUNCnLvqvJxNrKAg9KVMtS52H574NCuSv98tUwhnMn","amount":666666666660000}],"electorate":"17666184208409411159","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":18646528,"blockHash":"0x0f67cebf917ab7dcacfc2e3f08e272d3413575dbd723846f876078630f69adc9","blockTime":1783156728000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a3242b21bf1ede2f5f9e62b","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":18017269,"blockHash":"0x60a7d6517ce6f3b6f54e71b5e88cb9803e7d9a733fd447fa11e9ff38c5248b1e","blockTime":1781678712000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeifnue6xsovtx7tnzlxua4zeus3ny2zc3k7bscgek5oomeyzjzidaa","createdAt":"2026-06-17T06:45:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-17T06:46:49.047Z","referendumIndex":654,"contentHash":"d7f99209a7db2eb742e59ca61fa55880"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a3242b21bf1ede2f5f9e62b","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xa894c4b52613609711d5e4701ddb6257f0983776f13aa0c3215d8e02d8dc976d","publicKey":"a894c4b52613609711d5e4701ddb6257f0983776f13aa0c3215d8e02d8dc976d","emailMd5":"8465b25652973914521d480af31d96a2","address":"GPMknxhTgz1M16tArT2qRpy3JqUb9WWj61uBJz7HqZWTEWn"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a30e8a8a04636a85d1df868","referendumIndex":653,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17979388,"blockHash":"0x0b566dec469b667b9d235e04371e147179d1e186e81c1dbf8d74c3aa62c1ed02","blockTime":1781590104000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","title":"Subscan Enterprise Explorer License - Kusama 2026 Milestone-Based Service","content":"**View Proposal Detail:**\n\n [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YZ5G_8e_FV7CzBwFHzlPReawwLrD9iFCs5JqUvYJeR0/edit?tab=t.taf9g8qs5qac](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YZ5G_8e_FV7CzBwFHzlPReawwLrD9iFCs5JqUvYJeR0/edit?tab=t.taf9g8qs5qac)\n\n## Executive Summary\n\nSubscan is the leading high-precision Web3 explorer and essential data infrastructure for the Polkadot, Kusama, and Substrate-based ecosystems. It provides a comprehensive, user-friendly interface for ecosystem participants to track extrinsics, events, transfers, and governance activities. Beyond a visual block explorer, Subscan serves as a critical developer tool, offering the free API plan that powers numerous wallets, DApps, and analytics platforms across the network.\n\nTo ensure the community can quickly understand the scope, cost, and structural changes of this service, we have prepared this one-page executive summary. This guide provides a clear overview of the 2026 forward-looking maintenance proposal, allowing the community to evaluate the structural changes and funding request at a glance.\n\n| Category                          | Details                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |\n| --------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |\n| Proposal                          | Subscan Enterprise Explorer License - Kusama 2026 Milestone-Based Service                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |\n| Network                           | Kusama Relaychain, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |\n| Period                            | January 2026 – December 2026 (12 Months)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |\n| Retroactive or forward-looking    | Forward-looking                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |\n| Amount requested                  | $229,152 - 55128.3 KSM  (Annual Total Cap)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 |\n| Monthly equivalent                | $18,096 - [EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM](https://kusama.subscan.io/tools/price_converter?value=18096&type=block&from=USD&to=KSM&time=33978281) (Jan-Jun)<br>$20,096 - [EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM](https://kusama.subscan.io/tools/price_converter?value=20096&type=block&from=USD&to=KSM&time=33978281)  (Jul-Dec)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |\n| What is included                  | Enterprise SaaS infrastructure maintenance, Subscan License, Kusama Trace, AssetHub Trace (H2), 24/7 DevOps, SLA Guarantees.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               |\n| What changed compared to Ref #641 | The 2026 maintenance is now completely separated into an independent, forward-looking subscription. We have transitioned to a strictly monthly subscription model with exactly 1 milestone per month. Payments are processed on a strictly monthly basis. The community has the absolute right to evaluate ongoing performance and terminate the subscription at any time. |\n\n## 1. Proposal Purpose & Background\n\nThis proposal establishes a forward-looking 2026 Enterprise SaaS Subscription for Subscan services covering the Kusama Relay Chain and selected public parachains. Subscan has consistently served as the foundational data layer for the Kusama ecosystem. Our goal for 2026 is to make ongoing maintenance highly predictable, easier to evaluate, and fully controllable by the Kusama community through monthly OpenGov milestones.\n\n## Past Proposals Reference\n\nSubscan has a proven track record of delivering robust infrastructure. This proposal builds on our history of reliable support while pivoting to a more community-friendly funding structure:\n\n#229 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine (from July to December 2022)\n\n#377 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Asset Hub (Kusama) Networks (from January 2023 to March 2024)\n\n#434 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine Networks (from April to June 2024)\n\n#482 Subscan Q2/Q3/Q4 2024 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n#581 Subscan 2025 Q1-Q2 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n#641 [Kusama] Subscan 2025 Q3-Q4 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n## 2. Moving to a Predictable Subscription Model\n\nWe have heard the community clearly: the era of large post-paid retroactive settlements should end. This proposal therefore separates the 2026 service year into a clean, forward-looking SaaS subscription with monthly deliverables and monthly payment control.\n\nInstead of asking the Treasury to approve a long period after costs have already been incurred, Subscan is proposing a structure where each month is treated as a separate milestone. This greatly improves evaluability, reduces approval ambiguity, and gives the community a practical governance lever throughout the year.\n\n**Forward-looking subscription:** The 2026 annual scope is proposed before the service period rather than as a retroactive settlement.\n\n**Milestone-based payment:** The annual service is divided into 12 independent monthly milestones.\n\n**Community termination right:** The community may stop approving future milestones at any time if the service no longer meets expectations, if priorities change, or if a better alternative emerges.\n\n## 3. GCP Optimization & 2026 Price Reductions\n\nThroughout 2025, Subscan invested heavily in optimizing our infrastructure to reduce long-term operational costs. Specifically, we transitioned to a Hot/Cold storage separation architecture, which drastically reduced our reliance on high-cost GCP operations.\n\nWe are proud to pass these savings directly to the Kusama community. Compared to Q4 2025, our 2026 pricing reflects significant cost reductions across our networks. For example, the Kusama Relay Chain monthly fee drops substantially from $19,063 in Q4 2025 to $10,000 in 2026—an approximate 48% reduction. This demonstrates our commitment to the long-term financial sustainability of the Kusama ecosystem.\n\n## 4. 2026 Subscription Fee Breakdown\n\n(Note: Because this proposal utilizes a month-to-month milestone payment structure rather than an upfront annual lump-sum payment, standard monthly subscription rates apply without annual prepayment discounts.)\n\n| Network / Service  | Service Tier              | Monthly Fee | Billed Duration         | Annual Total | Included Scope                                            |\n| ------------------ | ------------------------- | ----------: | ----------------------- | -----------: | --------------------------------------------------------- |\n| Kusama Relay Chain | Custom Optimized          |     $10,000 | 12 months               |     $120,000 | Core production explorer infrastructure and maintenance   |\n| Kusama Trace       | Custom Optional           |      $4,000 | 12 months               |      $48,000 | Trace capability and related infrastructure               |\n| AssetHub           | Advanced                  |      $1,699 | 12 months               |      $20,388 | AssetHub explorer service and maintenance                 |\n| AssetHub Trace     | Custom Optional           |      $2,000 | 6 months (Est. Jul-Dec) |      $12,000 | Billed only after delivery and inclusion in H2 milestones |\n| Coretime           | Standard public parachain |        $799 | 12 months               |       $9,588 | Explorer service and maintenance                          |\n| BridgeHub          | Standard public parachain |        $799 | 12 months               |       $9,588 | Explorer service and maintenance                          |\n| People             | Standard public parachain |        $799 | 12 months               |       $9,588 | Explorer service and maintenance                          |\n| Total              |                           |             |                         |     $229,152 | 2026 annual subscription cap                              |\n\n## Why Trace Remains Necessary for Kusama and AssetHub\n\nThe Trace-related fees are listed separately to make the scope and cost transparent. Subscan currently supports Kusama Trace, and the fee includes the additional Trace node costs required to maintain this capability.\n\nKusama Trace is not a standard explorer feature. It is a deeper infrastructure layer that enables historical state analysis and provides important technical and data foundations for future feature expansion. Trace currently supports several advanced use cases, including:\n\n**Account balance history:** fetching block-by-block account balance history.\n\nhttps://polkadot.subscan.io/account/13UVJyLnbVp9RBZYFwFGyDvVd1y27Tt8tkntv6Q7JVPhFsTB?tab=balance_history&chart_tab=block\n\n**Custom state tracing:** allowing developers to query on-chain storage changes.\n\nhttps://polkadot.subscan.io/state_tracing\n\n**Storage changes:** allowing users to inspect state changes directly from block or extrinsic pages.\n\nhttps://polkadot.subscan.io/block/31587572?tab=state_tracing&trace=31587572-37\n\nConvenient access to storage-change data is currently difficult to obtain across the Kusama ecosystem, and Subscan Trace provides one of the only readily accessible ways to query and inspect this information. This makes Trace an important developer tool, not only a data feature for end users.\n\nThe continued subscription of Kusama Trace in 2026 is necessary because the Kusama Relay Chain still has real user and developer demand for historical balance analysis and state-change queries. Taking Kusama as an example, in September 2025, before the AssetHub migration, Trace-related API access through the Subscan web frontend averaged approximately 5.4k requests per day, mainly for historical balance data. In May 2026, usage averaged approximately 1.1k requests per day, with the main use case shifting toward custom state queries.\n\nThis change reflects a shift in demand rather than the disappearance of demand. After the AssetHub migration, part of the original Relay Chain activity moved to AssetHub, which naturally reduces Relay Chain Trace usage while creating new demand for AssetHub Trace. For this reason, AssetHub Trace is proposed as an H2 2026 addition. It will only be added after community approval, delivery, and inclusion in the relevant monthly milestones.\n\n## 5. Monthly Milestone Delivery Plan\n\nThe annual subscription cap of $229,152 is strictly divided into 12 monthly milestones. Each month corresponds to one independently reviewable and payable milestone, ensuring continuous delivery and validation.\n\n| Milestone    | Service Month  |                         Amount | Included Scope                                                                          |\n| ------------ | -------------- | -----------------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |\n| Milestone 1  | January 2026   | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 2  | February 2026  | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 3  | March 2026     | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 4  | April 2026     | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 5  | May 2026       | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 6  | June 2026      | $18,096<br>EMA 30: 4353.45 KSM | Kusama, Kusama Trace, AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People. (AssetHub Trace excluded). |\n| Milestone 7  | July 2026      |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n| Milestone 8  | August 2026    |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n| Milestone 9  | September 2026 |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n| Milestone 10 | October 2026   |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n| Milestone 11 | November 2026  |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n| Milestone 12 | December 2026  |  $20,096<br>EMA 30: 4834.6 KSM | Phase 1 scope plus AssetHub Trace.                                                      |\n\nThe total requested amount for all 5 networks, including all maintenance, operational overhead, and mandatory compatibility work, is USD 229,152. This request will be submitted in KSM, and the fee is based on milestone, payable on the 1st of each month, converted based on the 30-day average price at the time of on-chain submission.\n\n## 6. SLA, Monitoring, and Refund Policy\n\nTransparent service accountability is paramount. Service uptime is publicly monitored 24/7 at https://subscan.statuspage.io/. For each monthly milestone, if Subscan fails to meet the uptime standards below, Subscan will credit or refund the applicable percentage of the monthly fee back to the Kusama Treasury. This ensures strict monthly accountability under community oversight.\n\n| Monthly Uptime Percentage | Percentage Credited to Treasury                    |\n| ------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------- |\n| < 95.00%                  | 50% of the monthly milestone fee credited/refunded |\n| 95.00% - < 98.00%         | 25% of the monthly milestone fee credited/refunded |\n| 98.00% - < 99.00%         | 10% of the monthly milestone fee credited/refunded |\n| >= 99.00%                 | No SLA credit required                             |\n\n## 7. Review Checklist for the Community\n\nTo make review practical and to underline our commitment to alignment with the community's desires, voters can evaluate this proposal using the following checklist:\n\n**Structure:** Is the 2026 service separated from past retroactive settlement items? Yes. This is the standalone 2026 forward-looking subscription.\n\n**Payment cadence:** Is treasury outflow monthly rather than lump-sum? Yes. 12 monthly milestones.\n\n**Termination control:** Can the community stop future payments? Yes. Future milestones can be stopped by the community at any time.\n\n**Pricing:** Does the proposal reflect reduced 2026 infrastructure cost? Yes. Kusama Relay Chain drops from $19,063/mo in Q4 2025 to $10,000/mo in 2026.\n\n**SLA accountability:** Are refunds/credits defined? Yes. Refund tiers are rigorously based on monthly uptime.\n\nApproval of this proposal confirms the 2026 subscription structure and maximum monthly milestone amounts. It does not remove the community’s ability to stop or reject future monthly milestones if service expectations are not met. We look forward to continuing to provide top-tier infrastructure support for the Kusama ecosystem.\n","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-06-16T06:08:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-16T06:23:44.735Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-07-02T11:29:12.000Z","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18576853,"blockHash":"0xe18d0a6af11bd455eddbad317ed15681231934e871f0edf717e7278bad5ca092","blockTime":1782991752000,"eventIndex":25},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeifmszrcj2owdncw3vusbws5d4svd7tqv5naazd67zcdkq6rh4wxxm","contentHash":"38e253e728e24623d20ef04672f48470","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":653,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"38e253e728e24623d20ef04672f48470","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- Subscan is a tool to see what happens on Kusama.\n- It will work for all of 2026.\n- The community pays a small amount each month.\n- If service is bad, the community can stop paying.\n- The price is lower than before."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":34387565,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":34833966,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":35280366,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":35712365,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36158765,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36590765,"after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a30e88a0d29f16ed2a72761","referendumIndex":653,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17979388,"blockHash":"0x0b566dec469b667b9d235e04371e147179d1e186e81c1dbf8d74c3aa62c1ed02","blockTime":1781590104000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x2800","section":"utility","method":"batch"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18576853,"blockHash":"0xe18d0a6af11bd455eddbad317ed15681231934e871f0edf717e7278bad5ca092","blockTime":1782991752000,"eventIndex":25},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x2218deffed6b088f3873efd9e77c23ebf530a6b50f8e2905bae5586bdbe0305c","len":687}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":33978446,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":33981376,"confirming":34190406},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad60048a70d500","nays":"0x000000000000000004048e63497bf022","support":"0x000000000000000018ace36bca53d200"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34190406,[34190406,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad60048a70d500","nays":"0x000000000000000004048e63497bf022","support":"0x000000000000000018ace36bca53d200","electorate":"17593954039437969700"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x2218deffed6b088f3873efd9e77c23ebf530a6b50f8e2905bae5586bdbe0305c","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4353450000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":null,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":34387565,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":34833966,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":35280366,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":35712365,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36158765,"after":null},{"isSpendLocal":false,"assetKind":{"chain":"assethub","type":"native","symbol":"KSM"},"amount":"4834600000000000","beneficiary":{"chain":"assethub","address":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","pubKey":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"},"beneficiaryLocation":{"name":"beneficiary","type":"ParachainsCommonPayVersionedLocatableAccount","value":{"v4":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"accountId":{"parents":0,"interior":{"x1":[{"accountId32":{"network":null,"id":"0xd6a3eadc4e60fe8f63d922f084878e3e358754829683261f166dd0e6cf7e9cd3"}}]}}}}},"validFrom":36590765,"after":null}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":34204806,"index":0},"approved":[34190406,{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":33333333333000}],"electorate":"17593954039437969700","treasurySpendIndex":26,"treasurySpendIndexes":[26,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":18463632,"blockHash":"0xc2bb7d6d9637a3fe399e8029c3e7975c9d425118f39edb74089f4ca17d1d6533","blockTime":1782725496000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a30e88a0d29f16ed2a72763","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":17979388,"blockHash":"0x0b566dec469b667b9d235e04371e147179d1e186e81c1dbf8d74c3aa62c1ed02","blockTime":1781590104000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeifmszrcj2owdncw3vusbws5d4svd7tqv5naazd67zcdkq6rh4wxxm","createdAt":"2026-06-16T06:08:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-16T06:23:44.735Z","referendumIndex":653,"contentHash":"38e253e728e24623d20ef04672f48470"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a30e88a0d29f16ed2a72763","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","publicKey":"976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","emailMd5":"fc29fe0533e27b4fe4341203b696c432","address":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a2fd4b9a04636a85d6a4b60","referendumIndex":652,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17948966,"blockHash":"0x56533c6a46a5b93d279e7e6fa3dba05adbe584e09f850e804a60bb99f3f4ff41","blockTime":1781519472000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","title":"[Invoice] Subscan Explorer - Kusama 2025 Q3-Q4 SaaS Infrastructure Settlement","content":"**View Proposal Detail:**\n\n[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1baZdRrWHzMVfgPjItV7TTaPmRYusg8oB1B5r9qvkUbs/edit?tab=t.plgygtrmtmif#heading=h.ne48v3qj5vsm](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1baZdRrWHzMVfgPjItV7TTaPmRYusg8oB1B5r9qvkUbs/edit?tab=t.plgygtrmtmif#heading=h.ne48v3qj5vsm)\n\n## Executive Summary\n\nSubscan is the leading high-precision Web3 explorer and essential data infrastructure for the Polkadot, Kusama, and Substrate-based ecosystems. It provides a comprehensive, user-friendly interface for ecosystem participants to track extrinsics, events, transfers, and governance activities. Beyond a visual block explorer, Subscan serves as a critical developer tool, offering the free API plan that powers numerous wallets, DApps, and analytics platforms across the network.\n\nWe understand that reviewing comprehensive treasury proposals can be time-consuming. To ensure complete transparency and provide a clear guide for OpenGov voters, we have summarized the entire proposal into the table below.\n\n## Settlement Summary Table\n\n| Settlement Item & Period                                |                                           Amount Requested | Scope & Delivered Value                                                                                                                       | Key Changes vs. Previous Ref #641                                                                            |\n| ------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |\n| 1. Q3 SaaS Infrastructure<br><br>(Jul 1 - Sep 30, 2025) |                                  $70,812<br>($23,604 / mo) | Network: Kusama + 4 System Parachains<br><br>Scope: Enterprise Cloud DBs, 24/7 DevOps, Bandwidth.<br><br>Result: >99.5% SLA uptime delivered. | Removed 2026 Fees: All forward-looking 2026 estimates were removed to focus strictly on H2 2025 settlements. |\n| 2. Q4 SaaS Infrastructure<br><br>(Oct 1 - Dec 31, 2025) |                                  $70,812<br>($23,604 / mo) | Network: Kusama + 4 System Parachains<br><br>Scope: Enterprise Cloud DBs, 24/7 DevOps, Bandwidth.<br><br>Result: >99.5% SLA uptime delivered. | Removed 2026 Fees: All forward-looking 2026 estimates were removed to focus strictly on H2 2025 settlements. |\n| TOTAL SETTLEMENT                                        | $141,624<br>EMA30 Price: 4.1836 USD<br>Total: 33852.18 KSM | (Treasury assumes zero risk; all services already flawlessly delivered.)                                                                      |                                                                                                              |\n\nNote: Total requested amount will be converted to KSM based on the 30-day EMA price at the time of on-chain submission.\n\n## Past Proposals\n\n#229 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine (from July to December 2022)\n\n#377 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Asset Hub (Kusama) Networks (from January 2023 to March 2024)\n\n#434 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine Networks (from April to June 2024)\n\n#482 Subscan Q2/Q3/Q4 2024 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n#581 Subscan 2025 Q1-Q2 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n#641 [Kusama] Subscan 2025 Q3-Q4 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)\n\n# Infrastructure Settlement (Q3 & Q4 2025)\n\n(Covering the Kusama Relay Chain + 4 System Parachains: AssetHub, BridgeHub, Coretime, People)\n\n## 1. Service Continuity, Zero-Downtime Commitment, & Billing Precedent\n\nWe would like to clarify to the community why this invoice is submitted after the service period has concluded:\n\n**No Service Termination Notice:** Prior to and during H2 2025, Subscan did not receive any notice or request from the Community, OpenGov, or the Parity team to suspend or terminate our explorer and indexing services on Kusama. Furthermore, we continuously received technical communications from Parity staff regarding architectural alignments and network updates.\n\n**Ecosystem Lifeline:** Halting our explorer services would have immediately paralyzed crucial ecosystem infrastructure. Major wallets, dApps, testing frameworks, and OpenGov dashboards rely heavily on Subscan's APIs. Shutting down would have caused severe disruptions for developers and end-users on the Canary network.\n\n**Fronting the Costs (The Post-Paid Model):** Based on a multi-year historical precedent of a \"post-paid\" (settlement after service) arrangement with the Kusama Treasury, Subscan acted as a responsible, enterprise-grade B2B provider and fronted all cloud infrastructure expenses out-of-pocket to ensure continuous service.\n\n**Identical Pricing:** The pricing model used for these invoices is 100% identical to the fee structure approved by the community over the past two years, with absolutely zero unexpected markups.\n\n## 2. Q3 Invoice Breakdown (July 1 - Sept 30, 2025)\n\nThis invoice strictly covers the hard costs of enterprise cloud databases, 24/7 DevOps maintenance, and high-throughput bandwidth. To ensure absolute clarity, the financial breakdown is calculated precisely by dividing the 6-month service cycle evenly in half.\n\n| Network          | Q3 Median Storage | Applicable Tier | Monthly Fee | Total Q3 (3 Months) |\n| ---------------- | ----------------: | --------------- | ----------: | ------------------: |\n| Kusama           |       4,236.90 GB | Professional    |     $19,063 |             $57,189 |\n| AssetHub         |         341.96 GB | Basic+          |      $1,546 |              $4,638 |\n| BridgeHub        |         313.12 GB | Basic+          |      $1,397 |              $4,191 |\n| Coretime         |          93.14 GB | Basic           |        $799 |              $2,397 |\n| People           |          88.89 GB | Basic           |        $799 |              $2,397 |\n| Total Settlement |                   |                 |             |             $70,812 |\n\n## 3. Q4 Invoice Breakdown (Oct 1 - Dec 31, 2025)\n\nQ4 was characterized by intense testing, high-frequency on-chain activities, and multiple runtime upgrades across Kusama system parachains. This invoice settles the SLA and maintenance costs that guarantee a robust data layer during this critical period.\n\n| Network          | Q4 Median Storage | Applicable Tier | Monthly Fee | Total Q4 (3 Months) |\n| ---------------- | ----------------: | --------------- | ----------: | ------------------: |\n| Kusama           |       4,236.90 GB | Professional    |     $19,063 |             $57,189 |\n| AssetHub         |         341.96 GB | Basic+          |      $1,546 |              $4,638 |\n| BridgeHub        |         313.12 GB | Basic+          |      $1,397 |              $4,191 |\n| Coretime         |          93.14 GB | Basic           |        $799 |              $2,397 |\n| People           |          88.89 GB | Basic           |        $799 |              $2,397 |\n| Total Settlement |                   |                 |             |             $70,812 |\n\n**Delivered Results:** By honoring these invoices, the Treasury is settling the infrastructure costs that kept the ecosystem running smoothly. We are proud to report that despite massive data indexing demands and frequent upgrades, Subscan's actual Service Level Agreement (SLA) uptime exceeded 99.5% throughout both Q3 and Q4.\n\n## Development & Maintenance Cost Concession\n\nSubscan deeply understands the current macroeconomic constraints of the OpenGov Treasury. We want to ensure community funds are strictly focused on sustaining core infrastructure.\n\nTherefore, for the Kusama H2 2025 period, Subscan has voluntarily absorbed 100% of the complex R&D and maintenance costs related to XCM engines, UI updates, and Runtime upgrades directly into our standard SaaS fees. We are charging the Kusama Treasury absolutely zero ($0) extra development costs, providing maximum value to the community.\n\n## Conclusion & Our Ecosystem Commitment\n\nBy approving this settlement, the Treasury will clear the total amount of $141,624 (to be converted to KSM via 30-day EMA) for H2 2025 (Q3 + Q4) core infrastructure services. This funding covers the hard operational costs that guarantee a robust, uninterrupted, and reliable data layer for the entire Kusama ecosystem.\n\n2026-06-15 10:00:00 (+UTC), Block #17948149\n\nKSM EMA30 Price ( USD ): 4.183600\n\nNumber of KSM: 33852.184721\n\nhttps://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/tools/price_converter?value=141624&type=block&from=USD&to=KSM&time=17948149\n\nOur voluntary absorption of all extra engineering costs is a direct testament to our core philosophy: in times of ecosystem challenges, Subscan chooses to stand firmly with the community. We are not just a service provider; we are deeply committed, long-term builders of Kusama. Thank you to the community for your continued trust in our enterprise-grade infrastructure.\n","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-06-15T10:31:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-15T10:34:10.570Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-07-02T11:29:36.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18576865,"blockHash":"0xaea6b8275c964ba421ce8d3954f70fa83c60cb6eab2a1028900947413898108d","blockTime":1782991776000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":652,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeihndgp74hx3rrij57y4yrys3umx2d4nya2wd5z76wus4ohqd6uhpq","contentHash":"98fcfe6881a80fc095a40e262b2d5b69","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"98fcfe6881a80fc095a40e262b2d5b69","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- Subscan is a tool that helps people see what happens on Kusama and Polkadot networks.  \n- It asks for money to pay for computer servers it already used for 6 months in 2025.  \n- The total request is $141,624, which will be turned into KSM coins.  \n- Subscan kept its services running really well, with almost no downtime.  \n- It paid for all extra work itself, so the Treasury only pays for basic costs.  \n- Past proposals show this is a normal way Subscan asks for payment."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"33852180000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a2fd4ac5e8be58be31334d9","referendumIndex":652,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17948966,"blockHash":"0x56533c6a46a5b93d279e7e6fa3dba05adbe584e09f850e804a60bb99f3f4ff41","blockTime":1781519472000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":18576865,"blockHash":"0xaea6b8275c964ba421ce8d3954f70fa83c60cb6eab2a1028900947413898108d","blockTime":1782991776000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xb7860543f67b7fce26c6cfd2d178471ae85e47119e1b0f44ad7f827d4ea14505","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":33967068,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":33968268,"confirming":34190413},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad6006de7cb900","nays":"0x000000000000000004048e63497bf022","support":"0x000000000000000018ace38312caba00"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[34190413,[34190413,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000018ad6006de7cb900","nays":"0x000000000000000004048e63497bf022","support":"0x000000000000000018ace38312caba00","electorate":"17593954039437969700"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xb7860543f67b7fce26c6cfd2d178471ae85e47119e1b0f44ad7f827d4ea14505","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"33852180000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae"}}]}],"amount":"33852180000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","beneficiaries":["HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"33852180000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"enactment":{"when":34204813,"index":0},"approved":[34190413,{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":33333333333000}],"electorate":"17593954039437969700","treasuryProposalIndex":459,"treasuryProposalIndexes":[459],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":18463653,"blockHash":"0x87045708e0941206f8d73c079edb74dd70b5f0c092fa892906e5c6d9c18be015","blockTime":1782725520000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a2fd4ac5e8be58be31334db","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":17948966,"blockHash":"0x56533c6a46a5b93d279e7e6fa3dba05adbe584e09f850e804a60bb99f3f4ff41","blockTime":1781519472000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeihndgp74hx3rrij57y4yrys3umx2d4nya2wd5z76wus4ohqd6uhpq","createdAt":"2026-06-15T10:31:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-15T10:34:10.570Z","referendumIndex":652,"contentHash":"98fcfe6881a80fc095a40e262b2d5b69"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a2fd4ac5e8be58be31334db","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","publicKey":"976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","emailMd5":"fc29fe0533e27b4fe4341203b696c432","address":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"6a26d355a04636a85d22ebbc","referendumIndex":651,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17694861,"blockHash":"0x87c1e2d30783468181f7bfc9ac5f911f16f3ec703ba11fb50c8f44f3cfd34560","blockTime":1780929324000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","title":"Runtime Upgrade 2.3","content":"Upgrade all system chains (excluding Bulletin) to [release 2.3.0](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/releases/tag/v2.3.0)  \n\nWhitelisted by Polkadot Fellowship ref through P<->K Bridge https://collectives.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/544","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-06-08T14:35:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-08T14:40:29.577Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-11T14:27:24.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":17806727,"blockHash":"0x29741a26467bc515d47f2fc9c41bde7a5bf25d79a4662510a741e3574fa23da4","blockTime":1781188044000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":0,"polkassemblyId":651,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeidawf4p4dlbmakvxh2w2rf5qzmzhpp5f54le3k7e3iz6egg4xjg54","contentHash":"6f2f1d8dc925c00c3024770d481e9078","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a26d3502ba9a03991800e21","referendumIndex":651,"indexer":{"blockHeight":17694861,"blockHash":"0x87c1e2d30783468181f7bfc9ac5f911f16f3ec703ba11fb50c8f44f3cfd34560","blockTime":1780929324000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":17806727,"blockHash":"0x29741a26467bc515d47f2fc9c41bde7a5bf25d79a4662510a741e3574fa23da4","blockTime":1781188044000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xd183ea00b7326c6121ce8569a3d9ca4eb3a2bc2ab4cf1e326ac02bec712ff692","len":291}},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":33871617,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":33872525,"confirming":33913325},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000027e1c8daf650c00","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018b055e633213800"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33913319,[33913319,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000027e1c8daf650c00","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000018b055e633213800","electorate":"17524257138155926510"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0x3ad2bf340fd1fe8c8434d8ac346d6afc77e7bb2d1c76340d47a0c2983225e64b"],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xd183ea00b7326c6121ce8569a3d9ca4eb3a2bc2ab4cf1e326ac02bec712ff692","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":33913426,"index":0},"approved":[33913326,{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":33333333333},{"who":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"17524257138155926510","lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":17806175,"blockHash":"0xc2298d312ae12bcca1bf9d32979c55f52db9d74932bb0837b60b73a94a40be3c","blockTime":1781186808000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a26d3502ba9a03991800e23","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":17694861,"blockHash":"0x87c1e2d30783468181f7bfc9ac5f911f16f3ec703ba11fb50c8f44f3cfd34560","blockTime":1780929324000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeidawf4p4dlbmakvxh2w2rf5qzmzhpp5f54le3k7e3iz6egg4xjg54","createdAt":"2026-06-08T14:35:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-08T14:40:29.577Z","referendumIndex":651,"contentHash":"6f2f1d8dc925c00c3024770d481e9078"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a26d3502ba9a03991800e23","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","publicKey":"6c9e3102dd2c24274667d416e07570ebce6f20ab80ee3fc9917bf4a7568b8fd2","address":"F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"6a0ca088a04636a85dbd8da1","referendumIndex":650,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16931632,"blockHash":"0xef46b90834a2106f4b7ea02864053c9fa2de3833ecce337881308f0dbc440788","blockTime":1779212352000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","title":"Funding for Public RPC Providers (Kusama)","content":"Dear community,\n\nThis proposal, submitted with the authorization of the curators of Bounty 31, seeks funding to continue Public RPC Provider services for one year.\n\nThe requested funding covers both the previous tender period and the upcoming one. Three months of the total are retroactive funding for Tender 4, while the remainder supports Tender 5. Tender 4’s funding was reduced by 25% following negotiations with Parity Technologies.\n\nThe Public RPC bounty funds RPC infrastructure through a blind tender process similar to traditional procurement. Curators define the required service scope using usage data from a monitoring system. This scope sets out the quality requirements, expected request volumes, and required number of providers for each supported chain.\n\nParticipants first submit a hash of their proposal by the deadline, then later reveal the full proposal document. Curators verify that the submitted proposal matches the original hash before scoring the tender.\n\nThis process has delivered significant benefits by keeping pricing close to market value while allowing RPC capacity to scale according to current ecosystem demand. Each tender round is based on fresh usage data and updated service requirements.\n\nThe bounty has also been guided to provide an alternative entry point for RPC service through a GeoDNS/load-balancer system. This system would connect users to the geographically nearest suitable provider and perform health checks to redirect traffic if a provider goes offline, becomes unhealthy, or reaches saturation. This would improve reliability, performance, and resilience for users accessing public RPC infrastructure.\n\nImportantly, the existing direct entry point for each individual provider would remain published. Users and applications would therefore remain free to connect directly to a preferred provider, or to avoid the GeoDNS/load-balanced service entirely, depending on their own preference and requirements.\n\nThis proposal requests $65,724 for 12 months of RPC service provision for the Kusama Relay Chain and all Kusama System Chains.\n\nA link to the proposal can be found here:\n[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wgVHy98MNowCkgRIBjWr7TdX0T1sHbJwiKPlkCq6RJo/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.opw8llbn4ibw](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wgVHy98MNowCkgRIBjWr7TdX0T1sHbJwiKPlkCq6RJo/edit?tab=t.0#heading=h.opw8llbn4ibw)\n\nMany thanks and we look forward to your support,\nDaniel from Simply Staking","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-05-19T17:39:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-19T23:37:33.659Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-04T20:02:00.000Z","edited":true,"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":17543719,"blockHash":"0x9d13e37333237e7d149ae9bbc93ca975f6869c1393a98a59b45e23b65b6b98f2","blockTime":1780603320000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":0,"polkassemblyId":650,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeihgaimgdgaoostlwvmiqsazez2o3xdjk6xf3to3xyot5sjn3wquj4","contentHash":"f7ba362bd8feb55e08d118c618fca6ef","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"f7ba362bd8feb55e08d118c618fca6ef","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"A proposal requests $65,724 to continue the Public RPC Provider service for Kusama for one year. It covers a previous tender period and the upcoming one. A GeoDNS system would connect users to the nearest available provider. Users can still connect directly to any provider."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"12664000000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNfgLCSosSjAznoSgGRWrn8p28ZB","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"6a0ca06d9b3d164af4dfa43b","referendumIndex":650,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16931632,"blockHash":"0xef46b90834a2106f4b7ea02864053c9fa2de3833ecce337881308f0dbc440788","blockTime":1779212352000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","authors":["DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":17543719,"blockHash":"0x9d13e37333237e7d149ae9bbc93ca975f6869c1393a98a59b45e23b65b6b98f2","blockTime":1780603320000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xdd1d8dadeb4565301d0ec4e459743dca54e6637b6445b438fead0a6ccff0bb59","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":33593179,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":33595579,"confirming":33804380},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000167ff9d8b3b67800","nays":"0x0000000000000000040c16df5e2c4fe2","support":"0x00000000000000000b365f54928a2000"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33804380,[33804380,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000167ff9d8b3b67800","nays":"0x0000000000000000040c16df5e2c4fe2","support":"0x00000000000000000b365f54928a2000","electorate":"17483270961009896894"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xdd1d8dadeb4565301d0ec4e459743dca54e6637b6445b438fead0a6ccff0bb59","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"12664000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNfgLCSosSjAznoSgGRWrn8p28ZB"}}]}],"amount":"12664000000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNfgLCSosSjAznoSgGRWrn8p28ZB","beneficiaries":["F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNfgLCSosSjAznoSgGRWrn8p28ZB"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"12664000000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNfgLCSosSjAznoSgGRWrn8p28ZB","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"enactment":{"when":33818780,"index":0},"approved":[33804380,{"who":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","amount":33333333333},{"who":"DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8","amount":13333333333200}],"electorate":"17483270961009896894","treasuryProposalIndex":458,"treasuryProposalIndexes":[458],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":17421256,"blockHash":"0x47256fd2b0e2bad1c096e1942a5d69bc7233505d793a8027d0bb80c421553e1e","blockTime":1780336428000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"6a0ca06d9b3d164af4dfa43d","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":16931632,"blockHash":"0xef46b90834a2106f4b7ea02864053c9fa2de3833ecce337881308f0dbc440788","blockTime":1779212352000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeihgaimgdgaoostlwvmiqsazez2o3xdjk6xf3to3xyot5sjn3wquj4","createdAt":"2026-05-19T17:39:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-19T23:37:33.659Z","referendumIndex":650,"contentHash":"f7ba362bd8feb55e08d118c618fca6ef"},"rootPost":{"postId":"6a0ca06d9b3d164af4dfa43d","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["DNDBcYD8zzqAoZEtgNzouVp2sVxsvqzD4UdB5WrAUwjqpL8"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"69ff799da04636a85d894006","referendumIndex":649,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556308,"blockHash":"0xcad4040c04105ffc6a9360fa3810543b1faa8df178457954b7c1f9c2eae7c1f5","blockTime":1778350428000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","title":"[Small Spender] Set up the Kusama Vision ZKProofs Multi-Asset Bounty","content":"1 DOT requested from Treasury in order to create and seed the Zero Knowledge Proofs Multi-Asset Bounty which is an integral part of the Kusama Vision (https://kusama.network/vision).","contentType":"markdown","track":32,"createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:13:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:20:05.981Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-23T14:49:48.041Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":2,"polkassemblyId":649,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974782,"blockHash":"0xdcd8d30ce440e02ce1063a46b0c9e9afbc3eeb418f1c06b211c864de4afc00d5","blockTime":1779311172000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeidzjc4nx3e4lxudeuh6wwgr6vtu34ilaoquykcbyt4sbd6eyoa36u","contentHash":"422f82f0cf51f2d07b44f88c8c452c93","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"69ff797eca441ca1654f8f53","referendumIndex":649,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556308,"blockHash":"0xcad4040c04105ffc6a9360fa3810543b1faa8df178457954b7c1f9c2eae7c1f5","blockTime":1778350428000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":32,"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974782,"blockHash":"0xdcd8d30ce440e02ce1063a46b0c9e9afbc3eeb418f1c06b211c864de4afc00d5","blockTime":1779311172000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":32,"origin":{"origins":"SmallSpender"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b5402002898034a8b04387038b26935b176c4f181badafcd0fbe66d214d4d30102742c051a653392041b47a2846d65880d4feaa2425b1b28b757d224b5716f8ce3f39d1"},"enactment":{"after":1},"submitted":33453156,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300},"deciding":{"since":33455556,"confirming":33594733},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e96c5d9632c1d00","nays":"0x0000000000000000040812c014057622","support":"0x00000000000000000e8ae90cea7cfa00"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33594733,[33594733,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e96c5d9632c1d00","nays":"0x0000000000000000040812c014057622","support":"0x00000000000000000e8ae90cea7cfa00","electorate":"17428361766831922603"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b5402002898034a8b04387038b26935b176c4f181badafcd0fbe66d214d4d30102742c051a653392041b47a2846d65880d4feaa2425b1b28b757d224b5716f8ce3f39d1","hash":"0x05e08ed6e7b7a37f5e1805874b81f475b4709a616303997c478cba51b08bd593","call":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty","args":[{"name":"assetKind","type":"PolkadotRuntimeCommonImplsVersionedLocatableAsset","value":{"v5":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"assetId":{"parents":2,"interior":{"x1":[{"globalConsensus":{"polkadot":null}}]}}}}},{"name":"value","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"10000000000"},{"name":"curator","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"DVYbCSWbNfNxA2DXK1TUJSUaBYZVyeVq6AEvmp98S2nn3LH"}},{"name":"metadata","type":"H256","value":"0x51a653392041b47a2846d65880d4feaa2425b1b28b757d224b5716f8ce3f39d1"}]}},"proposalHash":"0x05e08ed6e7b7a37f5e1805874b81f475b4709a616303997c478cba51b08bd593","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":33609133,"index":0},"approved":[33594733,{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300}],"electorate":"17428361766831922603","allFundBounties":[{"assetKind":{"chain":"polkadot","type":"crosschainNative","symbol":"DOT","decimals":10},"amount":"10000000000","curator":"DVYbCSWbNfNxA2DXK1TUJSUaBYZVyeVq6AEvmp98S2nn3LH"}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"multiAssetBountyIndex":2,"multiAssetBountyIndexes":[2],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":16916397,"blockHash":"0xf53fb89d33f23fad4ec0adbff4ce157e407ee6ca5c6b3dec20ca4198d4434965","blockTime":1779177480000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69ff797eca441ca1654f8f55","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":16556308,"blockHash":"0xcad4040c04105ffc6a9360fa3810543b1faa8df178457954b7c1f9c2eae7c1f5","blockTime":1778350428000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeidzjc4nx3e4lxudeuh6wwgr6vtu34ilaoquykcbyt4sbd6eyoa36u","createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:13:48.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:20:05.981Z","referendumIndex":649,"contentHash":"422f82f0cf51f2d07b44f88c8c452c93"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69ff797eca441ca1654f8f55","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"]},"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","publicKey":"2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","address":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"69ff797da04636a85d892fdc","referendumIndex":648,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556301,"blockHash":"0x03423e04a89f6f592f34195b4cc1dbfd703889ea433da2fbf81a431b29ae18d7","blockTime":1778350392000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","title":"[Small Spender] Set up the Kusama Vision Art and Social Experiments Multi-Asset Bounty","content":"1 DOT requested from Treasury in order to create and seed the Art and Social Experiments Multi-Asset Bounty which is an integral part of the Kusama Vision (https://kusama.network/vision).","contentType":"markdown","track":32,"createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:13:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:18:45.442Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-23T14:50:41.990Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":2,"polkassemblyId":648,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974764,"blockHash":"0x32682bf62433a38eb08e7082c7b8ce3e37092550587f404d4703322c8cbbcd53","blockTime":1779311124000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeifdl4hc4nb6omv3mpmb76dx5rbpjaymgkt6vjrsncuubutwzhowyu","contentHash":"f5420af7f7042e754f6aef2ca9d89378","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"69ff7974ca441ca1654f8f50","referendumIndex":648,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556301,"blockHash":"0x03423e04a89f6f592f34195b4cc1dbfd703889ea433da2fbf81a431b29ae18d7","blockTime":1778350392000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":32,"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974764,"blockHash":"0x32682bf62433a38eb08e7082c7b8ce3e37092550587f404d4703322c8cbbcd53","blockTime":1779311124000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":32,"origin":{"origins":"SmallSpender"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b540200eefa063379e31afb376023d1ce0592627f7176fab5dd05f3539a300596f4981492c3f9a6f07a447646735c4453263671ff2f77eb3eb3153f1967d15a882da4ea"},"enactment":{"after":1},"submitted":33453151,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300},"deciding":{"since":33455553,"confirming":33594727},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e96c5d9632c1d00","nays":10000000000,"support":"0x00000000000000000e8c5df17ad89a00"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33594727,[33594727,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e96c5d9632c1d00","nays":10000000000,"support":"0x00000000000000000e8c5df17ad89a00","electorate":"17428357586795896684"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b540200eefa063379e31afb376023d1ce0592627f7176fab5dd05f3539a300596f4981492c3f9a6f07a447646735c4453263671ff2f77eb3eb3153f1967d15a882da4ea","hash":"0xbc190cc930cb75e3f82d2b9d8e082bd1589aafdabfe30032bcf4bc6eda9b7311","call":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty","args":[{"name":"assetKind","type":"PolkadotRuntimeCommonImplsVersionedLocatableAsset","value":{"v5":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"assetId":{"parents":2,"interior":{"x1":[{"globalConsensus":{"polkadot":null}}]}}}}},{"name":"value","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"10000000000"},{"name":"curator","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"HyfBoVzPkikGdDv5P9pNoMkHrQJ5LvktdXwiv9RntbrTHi4"}},{"name":"metadata","type":"H256","value":"0x92c3f9a6f07a447646735c4453263671ff2f77eb3eb3153f1967d15a882da4ea"}]}},"proposalHash":"0xbc190cc930cb75e3f82d2b9d8e082bd1589aafdabfe30032bcf4bc6eda9b7311","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":33609127,"index":0},"approved":[33594727,{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300}],"electorate":"17428357586795896684","allFundBounties":[{"assetKind":{"chain":"polkadot","type":"crosschainNative","symbol":"DOT","decimals":10},"amount":"10000000000","curator":"HyfBoVzPkikGdDv5P9pNoMkHrQJ5LvktdXwiv9RntbrTHi4"}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"multiAssetBountyIndex":1,"multiAssetBountyIndexes":[1],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":16916385,"blockHash":"0xfc1dfc0de06059c2818def4cec823e24ee249c3eba6bf132f8cb011283bbed51","blockTime":1779177432000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69ff7974ca441ca1654f8f52","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":16556301,"blockHash":"0x03423e04a89f6f592f34195b4cc1dbfd703889ea433da2fbf81a431b29ae18d7","blockTime":1778350392000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"bafybeifdl4hc4nb6omv3mpmb76dx5rbpjaymgkt6vjrsncuubutwzhowyu","createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:13:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:18:45.442Z","referendumIndex":648,"contentHash":"f5420af7f7042e754f6aef2ca9d89378"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69ff7974ca441ca1654f8f52","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"]},"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","publicKey":"2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","address":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"69ff7779a04636a85d85d56f","referendumIndex":647,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556080,"blockHash":"0x5cc2b7f8b48b42fa5c41b1af8d2cf2ce477ea404c4dc85732a83adb378da7414","blockTime":1778349900000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","title":"[Small Spender] Set up the Kusama Vision POP Multi-Asset Bounty","content":"1 DOT requested from Treasury in order to create and seed the POP Multi-Asset Bounty which is an integral part of the Kusama Vision (https://kusama.network/vision).","contentType":"markdown","track":32,"createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:05:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:18:07.653Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-06-23T14:51:33.341Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":2,"polkassemblyId":647,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974746,"blockHash":"0x1abe8c2c12d86f151402c31352cce4ecfe8f6aa0c6bb36860d51ab353d3e49fe","blockTime":1779311088000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeiaecp4raa4gm7dz3dfev6vqqlnhwkn2lyzb4uzwjswqq55x3veolm","contentHash":"8a27118144e32d6f194ac376cd3b7ac0","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"69ff7776ca441ca1654f47f4","referendumIndex":647,"indexer":{"blockHeight":16556080,"blockHash":"0x5cc2b7f8b48b42fa5c41b1af8d2cf2ce477ea404c4dc85732a83adb378da7414","blockTime":1778349900000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":32,"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"proposer":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":16974746,"blockHash":"0x1abe8c2c12d86f151402c31352cce4ecfe8f6aa0c6bb36860d51ab353d3e49fe","blockTime":1779311088000,"eventIndex":5},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":32,"origin":{"origins":"SmallSpender"},"proposal":{"inline":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b540200e104b438e7893a9f9cbc59e7d057d61a85ed1b88e3a0ebc59733cb89637a5e7c72abf9bbdec79db960c6b2773b85427abf8cef903ff01f301707edaf8ae8102d"},"enactment":{"after":1},"submitted":33453070,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300},"deciding":{"since":33455470,"confirming":33594721},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e966ae652b1dd00","nays":"0x000000000000000004086db3247fb622","support":"0x00000000000000000e8abb93623fda00"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33594721,[33594721,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000e966ae652b1dd00","nays":"0x000000000000000004086db3247fb622","support":"0x00000000000000000e8abb93623fda00","electorate":"17428352066222674021"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"inlineCall":{"hex":"0x6200050000020109020700e40b540200e104b438e7893a9f9cbc59e7d057d61a85ed1b88e3a0ebc59733cb89637a5e7c72abf9bbdec79db960c6b2773b85427abf8cef903ff01f301707edaf8ae8102d","hash":"0x10e344ffabd3184abff452096b2489208a3b22f18c9b5eaedd7e179ce1eaad02","call":{"callIndex":"0x6200","section":"multiAssetBounties","method":"fundBounty","args":[{"name":"assetKind","type":"PolkadotRuntimeCommonImplsVersionedLocatableAsset","value":{"v5":{"location":{"parents":0,"interior":{"here":null}},"assetId":{"parents":2,"interior":{"x1":[{"globalConsensus":{"polkadot":null}}]}}}}},{"name":"value","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"10000000000"},{"name":"curator","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"HfMgvo7Lfuymg9sxii2H747rXdts5be6UfLPp6kXS4cNE9u"}},{"name":"metadata","type":"H256","value":"0x72abf9bbdec79db960c6b2773b85427abf8cef903ff01f301707edaf8ae8102d"}]}},"proposalHash":"0x10e344ffabd3184abff452096b2489208a3b22f18c9b5eaedd7e179ce1eaad02","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"enactment":{"when":33609121,"index":0},"approved":[33594721,{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":33333333333},{"who":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK","amount":3333333333300}],"electorate":"17428352066222674021","allFundBounties":[{"assetKind":{"chain":"polkadot","type":"crosschainNative","symbol":"DOT","decimals":10},"amount":"10000000000","curator":"HfMgvo7Lfuymg9sxii2H747rXdts5be6UfLPp6kXS4cNE9u"}],"isTreasuryProposal":true,"multiAssetBountyIndex":0,"multiAssetBountyIndexes":[0],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":16916367,"blockHash":"0xe15ec3a3a1d02d76e7d4c0365387d917fa02adc76c93d05b4e434f820a6f3191","blockTime":1779177396000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69ff7776ca441ca1654f47f6","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":16556080,"blockHash":"0x5cc2b7f8b48b42fa5c41b1af8d2cf2ce477ea404c4dc85732a83adb378da7414","blockTime":1778349900000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"bafybeiaecp4raa4gm7dz3dfev6vqqlnhwkn2lyzb4uzwjswqq55x3veolm","createdAt":"2026-05-09T18:05:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-05-09T18:18:07.653Z","referendumIndex":647,"contentHash":"8a27118144e32d6f194ac376cd3b7ac0"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69ff7776ca441ca1654f47f6","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"]},"trackInfo":{"id":32,"name":"small_spender","originalName":"small_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"3333333333300","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":7200,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":607142857,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":7892829,"xOffset":15544040,"yOffset":-7772020}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","publicKey":"2cb783d5c0ddcccd2608c83d43ee6fc19320408c24764c2f8ac164b27beaee37","address":"Dax95Nps5EEVfw7eQ2mvB3bX8p2hX2ZCtYSLiA357ZRq3aK"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"69df7969a04636a85d340175","referendumIndex":646,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15634264,"blockHash":"0xd315741a7cdb543f8b9b845e10fa055681cb4823ac56687f808caba8029e96ba","blockTime":1776253224000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","title":"DeServe.network Global Kusama Archive RPC Deployment - Proposal #1","content":"ℹ️ Please view the counterpart proposals:\n- Polkadot proposal live at referendum [#1879](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1879)\n- Paseo proposal live at referendum [#1880](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1880)\n\n## Summary\n\nThis proposal is for the global deployment of a **progressively decentralized** archive RPC network for Kusama and its system parachains. Please view the detailed [forum post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/launched-a-global-rpc-network-starting-with-polkadot-asset-hub-first-step-of-a-depin-14-locations-lowest-latency-cost-benchmarks-free-endpoints) for the complete background of the initial Polkadot deployment.\n\n**DeServe** is:\n\n- **Global RPC infrastructure** - **8 locations across 5 continents,** optimized for Kusama coverage\n- **Geo-steered load balancing**\n- **Lowest latency** among all major Polkadot RPC providers\n- By a **Polkadot-native infrastructure & software builder,** ex-IBP Rank-6 member\n- **Path to on-chain, general-purpose infrastructure** (DePIN)\n- Launched on March 31st, 2026 as a single-chain deployment, **>53M req/24h** by day 10\n- Testnet live on Paseo, para id 5150 ([telemetry](https://telemetry.polkadot.io/#list/0x1260a2a27387e782a0f11f9fb4e42eb80d7ccff994a30ff8fb2c409315f38f49)), proof of on-chain commitment, currently running a shell runtime with business logic upgrade planned\n- **87% cheaper** than IBP\n- Webpage live at [deserve.network](https://deserve.network)\n- Developer documentation: [docs.deserve.network](https://docs.deserve.network)\n\nThis proposal requests **3,003.00 KSM** (**$12,614.00** at 7-day EMA) as the first payment, first month upfront to bootstrap the global rollout of all Kusama services. Subsequent payments will be requested via **3-monthly retroactive proposals,** alongside full transparency reports covering expenses, performance, and request analytics.\n\n## Initial Traction & Updates\n\nThe following X posts document DeServe's first days of deployment:\n\n- Launch announcement for Polkadot Asset Hub ([post](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2038985203134148715))\n- **\\>1.7M requests** on day 1, Ethereum-compatible RPC deployment ([post](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2039355526690099210))\n- **\\>45M requests/24h,** [deserve.network](https://deserve.network) launch ([post](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2041130311560400912))\n- **\\>50M requests/24h,** [docs.deserve.network](https://docs.deserve.network) launch ([post](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2041565462027210917))\n- **\\>53M requests/24h,** Polkadot Coretime rollout and public dashboard launch ([post](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2042238422329217300))\n\nOver the first two weeks of deployment, DeServe has served over **500 million requests,** and is currently serving **>36M requests/day.**\n\nLive request analytics are available at the [public dashboard](https://monitoring.deserve.network/public-dashboards/bc12221c75c044d391ac76e516a8af3b?orgId=1&refresh=1m).\n\n![Screenshot 2026-04-15 at 08.27.05.png](https://subsquare.infura-ipfs.io/ipfs/QmWERUo6Un8sWK62muTsgzSZsT5ZjMyK1oJyUbAkURrYeU)\n\n## Deployment & Coverage\n\n![Screenshot 2026-04-15 at 07.52.39.png](https://subsquare.infura-ipfs.io/ipfs/QmW1oSP7X6pqqjEiUwMteciMcBQLtscjGu5BajS4KhbHiN)\n\n### Current deployment\n\n* Polkadot Asset Hub Archive RPC & Ethereum-compatible RPC ([endpoints](https://docs.deserve.network/polkadot-and-parachains/polkadot-asset-hub))\n* Polkadot Coretime Archive RPC ([endpoints](https://docs.deserve.network/polkadot-and-parachains/polkadot-coretime))\n\n### Complete Kusama rollout under this proposal\n\nKusama RPC services will be rolled out at **8 locations across 5 continents,** optimized for coverage and budget efficiency for Kusama.\n\n* Kusama Relay Chain\n* Asset Hub\n* Bridge Hub\n* Coretime\n* Encointer\n* People\n\n| Chain | Archive RPC | ETH RPC | Status |\n| -------- | :--------: | :--------: | -------- |\n| Kusama Relay Chain | ✅ | - | To be deployed |\n| Asset Hub | ✅ | ✅ | To be deployed |\n| Coretime | ✅ | - | To be deployed |\n| Bridge Hub | ✅ | - | To be deployed |\n| Encointer | ✅ | - | To be deployed |\n| People | ✅ | - | To be deployed |\n\n### Infrastructure\n\n- **8 locations** across **5 continents,** **5 providers** including Helikon\n    - İstanbul, TR\n    - Johannesburg, ZA\n    - Limburg, DE\n    - London, UK\n    - Mumbai, IN\n    - Seattle, WA, US\n    - Sao Paulo, BR\n    - Singapore, SG\n- **1G–10G** uplink bandwidth\n- Unmetered traffic on most nodes\n- **950GB–14.72TB** NVMe storage per node\n- ECC RAM\n\n### Monitoring and High Availability\n\n- **Geo-steered load balancing:** requests routed to the nearest node\n- **15-second health checks:** unreachable nodes removed from the pool\n- **Quick recovery from low-cost backup storage** preferred over 2N redundancy for cost-efficiency\n- **Prometheus & Grafana** monitoring and alerting across all nodes 24/7\n- **Monitoring network** *(in development)*: latency checks across the globe\n- **99.9%+** effective availability through rapid failover\n- Open-source DNS transition planned *(see Roadmap)*\n\n### RPC configuration\n\n- **100 req/s** without API key\n- **2MB** max request size / **7MB** max response size\n- **256** RPC subscriptions per connection\n\n## Performance\n\nDeServe delivers the **lowest latency** among all major Polkadot RPC providers for Polkadot Asset Hub, verified via [Compare Nodes](https://comparenodes.com), a global RPC performance inspector.\n\n| Comparison | Continents | Regions |\n| -------- | :--------: | :--------: |\n| DeServe vs IBP | 5/6 | 18-20/26 |\n| DeServe vs OnFinality | 6/6 | 25/26 |\n| DeServe vs Dwellir | 6/6 | 24/26 |\n| DeServe vs LuckyFriday | 6/6 | 24/26 |\n\nFull benchmark runs:\n\n- DeServe vs IBP: [Run 1](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/3a6c4cf0-f065-4bcb-9791-55f64dc7876f/), [Run 2](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/bf91bbee-1fa0-4ff8-8130-2cbe9941dfbc/), [Run 3](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/16cad275-c3ed-4c61-b6c7-e177b9484de3/)\n- DeServe vs OnFinality: [Run 1](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/b297f27c-4c7d-498b-bf81-d3882bb48b66/)\n- DeServe vs LuckyFriday: [Run 1](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/ccd9b336-4ecf-410b-b4b1-08cb4a7fd68f/)\n- DeServe vs Dwellir: [Run 1](https://www.comparenodes.com/global-node-comparison/a918f03e-4e10-4cba-9d89-b7c469075927/)\n\n![Screenshot 2026-03-31 at 17.05.21.png](https://subsquare.infura-ipfs.io/ipfs/QmaEXDFx5y8SmVBuwUzgjtotE4tncoWghQQmdYGWoogU5v)\n\n## Cost Comparison\n\nIBP is currently the only other provider offering a global geo-steered RPC service, making it the most appropriate reference for cost comparison.\n\nNote that IBP operates on a **2N redundancy model,** while DeServe operates on a **single-instance model with rapid failover** through backups, as detailed in the Monitoring & High Availability section.\n\nGiven the current cost constraints of the Polkadot ecosystem, we find that single instance per location with backup mechanisms in place should be sufficient under a highly responsive load-balancing system. DeServe’s current setup monitors endpoints every 15 seconds, immediately removing any unreachable endpoint from the pool.\n\nThe compared numbers below are taken from IBP dashboard [billing view](https://ibdash.dotters.network/).\n\n| | IBP | DeServe |\n| --- | ---: | ---: |\n| Kusama Relay Chain | $66,226.50 | $8,345.00 |\n| Asset Hub | $9,644.74 | $1,214.00 |\n| Ethereum RPC | $538.30 | $69.00 |\n| Bridge Hub | $6,926.66 | $873.00 |\n| Coretime | $5,595.14 | $706.00 |\n| Encointer | $5,595.14 | $706.00 |\n| People | $5,567.62 | $701.00 |\n| **TOTAL** | **$100,094.10** | **$12,614.00** |\n| **vs. IBP** | - | **87% cheaper** |\n\nOur cost model is illustrated in detail in the initial [forum post](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/launched-a-global-rpc-network-starting-with-polkadot-asset-hub-first-step-of-a-depin-14-locations-lowest-latency-cost-benchmarks-free-endpoints). DeServe also provides **GeoDNS services for free** as part of the package, whereas IBP charges **$1,200.00/month** for this service. DeServe also comes without curator payments, which add further overhead to bounty-based programs. IBP curator payments add approximately **$3,400.00/month** in additional overhead ([reference](https://github.com/ibp-network/ChildBounties/blob/main/Polkadot%20Bounty%2050/2025.11%20-%20IBP%20Polkadot.pdf)).\n\n## Operation & Payment Details\n\n### Payment model\n\n- **First payment: 3,003.00 KSM** ($12,614.00 at 7-day EMA): first month upfront to bootstrap the Kusama rollout\n- **Second payment $25,228.00 in KSM at 7-day EMA:** months 2-3, requested at end of month 3 alongside the first transparency report\n- **Subsequent payments $37,842.00/quarter in KSM at 7-day EMA:** 3-monthly retroactive proposals alongside full transparency reports\n\n### Payment terms\n\n- **KSM:** due to stable coins not being held by the Kusama treasury\n- **No lock-in:** the treasury can cancel anytime\n- **Via regular spends:** no long-term bounty top-ups or commitment\n- **Monthly transparency reports:** expenses, performance, and request analytics\n- **Public monitors:** service health and performance, live at [public dashboard](https://monitoring.deserve.network/public-dashboards/bc12221c75c044d391ac76e516a8af3b?orgId=1&refresh=1m)\n- **99.9%+ uptime SLA:** basis for payment validation\n\n### Labour costs\n\nLabour costs for the current alpha phase are excluded from this proposal and **covered by Helikon.** As DeServe matures, operator labour costs will be **standardized through protocol governance.**\n\n## Roadmap\n\n### First 3 Months\n\n- **All Kusama services live within week 2 of proposal approval:** Kusama Relay Chain, Asset Hub, Ethereum-compatible RPC, Bridge Hub, Coretime, Encointer, People\n- **Monitoring network:** real-time latency and health checks across all regions\n- **DeServe website:** live node map, performance data, endpoints, and developer documentation (live at [deserve.network](https://deserve.network))\n- **Open-source DNS:** replacing Cloudflare for geo-steered load balancing, integrated with the monitoring network\n- **Polkadot-native provider onboarding:** begin replacing cloud providers with native Polkadot infrastructure providers, onboarding criteria to be published\n- **Governance alpha phase:** managed and governed by Helikon\n- **DeServe Unpaper:** protocol design and vision document\n\n### First 6 Months\n\n- **Complete Polkadot-native operator onboarding**\n- **Governance beta phase:** network committee of \\>3 native operators\n- **On-chain service provision:** on-chain payments, proofs, and governance, built on Polkadot\n\n## Submerge Commitment\n\n[Submerge](https://github.com/helikon-labs/submerge) is a data and compliance platform for Polkadot SDK chains, currently in development by Helikon. Submerge has [received](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/1149) treasury funding and is behind schedule. Its two main components, Crystal (a chain indexer), Mycelium (a cross-chain indexer), along with their APIs for all supported chains will be delivered before any further on-chain submission for DeServe.\n\n## About Helikon\n\nHelikon is a **Polkadot-native infrastructure and software development collective** based in İstanbul. A **regular contributor** to the Polkadot ecosystem at both the development and governance levels since late 2020:\n\n- **5 active Kusama & Polkadot validators,** former 1KV & Decentralized Nodes member\n- **Rank-6 ex-IBP member:** infrastructure services for 26 blockchains\n- **Two-time Decentralized Voices delegate,** once as founder of [Permanence DAO](https://permanence.io)\n- Recently **saved and revived Multix** ([post 1](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2013581524981956874), [post 2](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2014003096997749247), [post 3](https://x.com/kukabi_/status/2019777074131513426)), **a >$500K investment** funded through Polkadot treasury proposal [#236](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/treasury/proposals/236) and referendum [#120](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/120), and child bounties [36_10](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/treasury/child-bounties/36_10) and [36_3054](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/treasury/child-bounties/36_3054).\n- Maintaining SubVT ([iOS](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/subvt/id1602653455) & Telegram [Kusama](https://t.me/subvt_kusama_bot)/[Polkadot](https://t.me/subvt_polkadot_bot)), [Chain Console](https://forum.polkadot.network/t/chainconsole-com-polkadot-js-apps-fork-with-bug-fixes-and-improvements/17313), [Chainviz](https://chainviz.app/)/[alpha](https://alpha.chainviz.app/), [followthedot](https://followthedot.live/)\n- Built [dv.report](https://dv.report) - analysis dashboard for the Decentralized Voices program cohorts 4 and 5\n- Developing [Submerge](https://submerge.io) - data & compliance platform for Polkadot SDK chains\n\n### Contact\n\n- info@helikon.io\n- [@helikonlabs](https://x.com/helikonlabs)\n- [@kukabi_](https://x.com/kukabi_)\n- [Helikon GitHub](http://github.com/helikon-labs)\n- [kukabi GitHub](https://github.com/kukabi)\n- [Forum](https://forum.polkadot.network/u/kukabi/summary)","contentType":"markdown","track":33,"createdAt":"2026-04-15T11:40:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-15T11:46:27.935Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-29T21:56:36.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":16185816,"blockHash":"0x5c875599aec7e28b67ea081f0f07e00f15446c248f81bc7b921eee499b1eaeb4","blockTime":1777499796000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000017672bef563efa","nays":"0x0000000000000000045d0ee1551ee022","support":1952566180503293}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":3,"polkassemblyId":646,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeicxksm7ccuppxvzf37fkemurq56dz2p4o4mgpqxrxtvlipc5mf6p4","contentHash":"26f5a59abd56883f67c5a019b9ec49bb","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"26f5a59abd56883f67c5a019b9ec49bb","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- DeServe is a new global RPC service for Kusama.\n- It has 8 locations across 5 continents for fast access.\n- It is 87% cheaper than the current main provider.\n- It already serves over 36 million requests daily on Polkadot.\n- The proposal asks for 3,003 KSM to start the Kusama service.\n- Services will include Kusama, Asset Hub, and others.\n- Performance and costs will be shared publicly every month.\n- It is built by Helikon, a trusted Polkadot team."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"3003000000000000","beneficiary":"FT9jKxrKHLzSJGFPXHPipEpyRjbmcTuHJivyPN2AXSwDCQ1","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"69df79601665d2e7b758f28a","referendumIndex":646,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15634264,"blockHash":"0xd315741a7cdb543f8b9b845e10fa055681cb4823ac56687f808caba8029e96ba","blockTime":1776253224000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":33,"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"proposer":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","authors":["Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":16185816,"blockHash":"0x5c875599aec7e28b67ea081f0f07e00f15446c248f81bc7b921eee499b1eaeb4","blockTime":1777499796000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000017672bef563efa","nays":"0x0000000000000000045d0ee1551ee022","support":1952566180503293}}},"info":{"track":33,"origin":{"origins":"MediumSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xa4cbd61ecdc4a2db08bc739790671b47bcca9ac4f660abe45a2de94490579f88","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":33110138,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","amount":6666666666600},"deciding":{"since":33112538,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000017672bef563efa","nays":"0x0000000000000000045d0ee1551ee022","support":1952566180503293},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33314138,[33314138,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000017672bef563efa","nays":"0x0000000000000000045d0ee1551ee022","support":1952566180503293,"electorate":"17357251647571011897"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xa4cbd61ecdc4a2db08bc739790671b47bcca9ac4f660abe45a2de94490579f88","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"3003000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"FT9jKxrKHLzSJGFPXHPipEpyRjbmcTuHJivyPN2AXSwDCQ1"}}]}],"amount":"3003000000000000","beneficiary":"FT9jKxrKHLzSJGFPXHPipEpyRjbmcTuHJivyPN2AXSwDCQ1","beneficiaries":["FT9jKxrKHLzSJGFPXHPipEpyRjbmcTuHJivyPN2AXSwDCQ1"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"3003000000000000","beneficiary":"FT9jKxrKHLzSJGFPXHPipEpyRjbmcTuHJivyPN2AXSwDCQ1","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"electorate":"17357251647571011897","rejected":[33314138,{"who":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","amount":33333333333},{"who":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY","amount":6666666666600}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"refToPost":{"postId":"69df79601665d2e7b758f28c","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":15634264,"blockHash":"0xd315741a7cdb543f8b9b845e10fa055681cb4823ac56687f808caba8029e96ba","blockTime":1776253224000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeicxksm7ccuppxvzf37fkemurq56dz2p4o4mgpqxrxtvlipc5mf6p4","createdAt":"2026-04-15T11:40:24.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-15T11:46:27.935Z","referendumIndex":646,"contentHash":"26f5a59abd56883f67c5a019b9ec49bb"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69df79601665d2e7b758f28c","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY"]},"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x008d8404893c7b4b80f397605cc96e61fec3c89676c8c2794a2a7d281d678b1a","publicKey":"008d8404893c7b4b80f397605cc96e61fec3c89676c8c2794a2a7d281d678b1a","address":"Cb3ZF5tmeTEDR44MRLAPH3agiv5ntLG6VMZ2U5x8QM3XkGY"},"commentsCount":8},{"_id":"69dddee3a04636a85dc2c9c1","referendumIndex":645,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15585924,"blockHash":"0xe78e9584ddc8e8d72a3b3411394797503fbde144b0fc760aa8ca2f3a447b9cb3","blockTime":1776148152000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","title":"[Medium Spender] Encointer System Chain – Infrastructure Operations (Apr–Dec 2026)","content":"**Track:** MediumSpender\n**Requested:** 3,200 KSM ($13,500 USD at current 7-day EMA)\n**Period:** April – December 2026 (9 months)\n**Cost:** \\~$1,500/month\n\n***\n\n## 1. Summary\n\nEncointer is **Kusama's second system chain**, registered via Referendum 158. It provides Proof of Personhood, Sybil resistance, community currencies, and democratic governance tooling. It is the **only system chain unique to Kusama** – it does not exist on Polkadot.\n\nThis MediumSpender proposal requests funding for **basic infrastructure operations** of the Encointer system chain for 9 months (April–December 2026). The scope is strictly limited to keeping the chain running reliably: collators, RPC nodes, indexing, explorer, and accounting frontend. **This is not a development or community growth proposal.**\n\n### Why this is justified\n\nEncointer had **comparable monthly active accounts to Kusama Asset Hub before the AHM migration**. The data below shows that for recent months, both chains served a similar-sized user base – yet Encointer's operational costs are a fraction of what other system chains receive:\n\n| Month   | Encointer | KSM Asset Hub | Note               |\n| ------- | --------- | ------------- | ------------------ |\n| 2025-04 | 141       | 138           | **Encointer > AH** |\n| 2025-05 | 173       | 138           | **Encointer > AH** |\n| 2025-06 | 158       | 165           | Comparable         |\n| 2025-07 | 181       | 251           | Comparable         |\n| 2025-08 | 198       | 165           | **Encointer > AH** |\n| 2025-09 | 203       | 185           | **Encointer > AH** |\n| 2025-10 | 178       | 3,459         | AHM migration      |\n| 2025-11 | 182       | 4,962         | Post-AHM           |\n| 2025-12 | 155       | 3,848         | Post-AHM           |\n| 2026-01 | 155       | 3,703         | Post-AHM           |\n| 2026-02 | 149       | 3,370         | Post-AHM           |\n\n*Source: Encointer [litescan](https://github.com/brenzi/litescan/tree/encointer) indexer. Subscan has refused to index Encointer as a system chain.*\n\nBefore the Asset Hub Migration (Oct 2025), Encointer consistently matched or exceeded KAH in monthly active accounts. Encointer is one of the most actively used and still a very cost-efficient system chain in the Kusama ecosystem.\n\n### What does Encointer do for Kusama?\n\nKusama benefits directly from Encointer and should continue to fund it as a common good system chain. Its proof-of-personhood protocol and community currencies are not just theoretical — they are live experiments with active communities of meaningful size in the hundreds, enabling real experimentation with one-person-one-vote democracy that could complement Kusama's existing stake-weighted governance. Encointer also delivers tangible real-world impact: its Nyota pilot in Tanzania [multiplied the economic impact of cash transfer subsidies by 240%](https://www.ngostartupstoday.com/article/863655428-blockchain-based-community-currency-doubles-local-economic-impact), while the community in Nigeria are running [solar-powered collator nodes](https://encointer.org/independence-powered-by-the-sun-a-nigerian-communitys-journey-into-blockchain-and-self-reliance/) that improve Kusama's own geographic decentralization. Encointer makes Kusama more democratic and more relevant.\n\n## 2. Infrastructure Scope\n\nThis proposal covers five infrastructure components required to operate the Encointer system chain:\n\n| Component                    | Description                                                                                                                                                    | Monthly Cost (USD) |\n| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------ |\n| **2 Invulnerable Collators** | Team-operated invulnerable collators/bootnodes for block production. Excluded from system chain collator bounty (Ref #643 funds only community invulnerables). | $500               |\n| **Load-Balanced RPC Nodes**  | Public RPC endpoints for wallets, dApps, and community access. Load-balanced for availability.                                                                 | $350               |\n| **Litescan Indexer**         | [Simple FOSS indexer](https://github.com/pifragile/litescan) providing chain data for explorer and accounting tools. Runs continuously.                        | $250               |\n| **Accounting Frontend**      | [accounting.encointer.org](https://accounting.encointer.org/) – Transparency tool showing community treasury flows and token economics.                        | $200               |\n| **Explorer**                 | [explorer.encointer.org](https://explorer.encointer.org/) – Community status explorer for the Encointer chain. Public good for users and developers.           | $50                |\n| **Monitoring & Ops**         | Alerting, uptime monitoring, trivial incident response, SSL/DNS management for all above services.                                                             | $150               |\n| **TOTAL (monthly)**          |                                                                                                                                                                | **$1,500**         |\n| **TOTAL (9 months)**         | April – December 2026                                                                                                                                          | **$13,500**        |\n\n### What is NOT included\n\n* Runtime development and new features (funded separately or by Encointer Association)\n* Community growth operations (Nyota, PayNuq, new community bootstrapping)\n* Mobile app / wallet development\n* Marketing or outreach\n* Team salaries beyond basic infrastructure operations. \n \nFundraising efforts from external sources are ongoing and we see progress.  Nevertheless, we may need to approach the Kusama Treasury for additional well-scoped packages on top of this one if we want to do more than mere basic maintenance.\n\nThe team commits to keeping the system running and performing minimal maintenance for the stated period even in case no further funding can be secured.\n\n### Why these costs are excluded from other bounties\n\nThe system chain collator bounty ([Ref #643](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/643)) funds **community invulnerable collators only**. It explicitly allocates 2 slots for Encointer at $250/month each, paid to external community operators. The Encointer team's own 2 invulnerable collators are **not eligible** for this bounty. The RPC nodes, indexer, explorer, and accounting frontend are entirely unfunded by any other mechanism.\n\nThe Polkadot fellowship [does not cover any work or infrastructure which is specific to Encointer](https://collectives.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/215) although Encointer's runtime is maintained within the fellowship repositories.\n\nOther system chain maintenance budgets are not transparently reported for public scrutiny.\n\n## 3. Key Achievements\n\nDespite operating on one of the leanest budgets in the ecosystem, Encointer has delivered real-world impact:\n\n* **Nyota (Tanzania):** 100+ active participants, 15 new businesses created via Kusama Mchezo lending circles, 240% economic multiplier effect on development aid. [Published in NextBillion / Association of African Entrepreneurs](https://nextbillion.net/creating-local-means-of-exchange-for-african-entrepreneurs-how-blockchain-based-community-currency-gained-traction-tanzania/).\n* **PayNuq (Nigeria):** New and growing community bootstrapped in Zaria, operating a [solar-powered collator](https://encointer.org/independence-powered-by-the-sun-a-nigerian-communitys-journey-into-blockchain-and-self-reliance/) for the Encointer network.\n* **LEU (Zurich):** First personhood-based democratic decision about community matters.\n* **Democratic community treasuries:** All communities now vote on treasury spending decisions on-chain with approx. one-person-one-vote.\n* **Blockchain Switzerland InnoBooster Award** – third-party recognition of innovation.\n* **Runtime 2.1.0 upgrade** ([Ref #637](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/637)), demonstrating active chain development as part of fellowship repository.\n\n### Previous treasury proposals\n\n| Proposal                                                      | Period       | Amount                  | Status     |\n| ------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ----------------------- | ---------- |\n| [Ref 636](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/636)          | Jul–Dec 2025 | 73,811 CHF / 19,339 KSM | ❌ Rejected |\n| [Ref 564](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/proposals/445) | Jan–Jun 2025 | 61,592 CHF / 5,047 KSM  | ✅ Awarded  |\n| [Ref 489](https://kusama.subsquare.io/treasury/proposals/433) | Jul–Dec 2024 | 64,300 CHF / 2,413 KSM  | ✅ Awarded  |\n\nolder proposals linked in all proposal documents","contentType":"markdown","track":33,"createdAt":"2026-04-14T06:29:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-14T07:08:04.720Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-28T16:49:36.000Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":3,"polkassemblyId":645,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":16141365,"blockHash":"0xecbac1c8817063b37313ea426cc8a5781ae76c54140ffb8a9135fd9e6fbddeff","blockTime":1777394976000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000004ccad8e8d792d00","nays":"0x000000000000000004cfe6349b054822","support":"0x000000000000000000f015513c32df00"}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeihgcsdcjrtpf5mbqjhcodrtb47ig23ldnmeu4rpj3u7ieescfqc7y","contentHash":"6e4d71941364e463e667f2303fe97f5d","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"6e4d71941364e463e667f2303fe97f5d","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- Encointer is a special part of Kusama that helps prove people are real online and lets communities create their own money.\n- This request is for money to keep Encointer running for 9 months, like paying for computers and websites.\n- Before October 2025, just as many people used Encointer as another important part of Kusama called Asset Hub.\n- Encointer helps real people in places like Tanzania and Nigeria by making local money and using solar power for computers.\n- The money will pay for important things like computers that make blocks, public websites, and tools to see how the system works.\n- This does not pay for making new features or growing the community, just keeping it running.\n- Encointer has won awards and helped start new businesses in Africa.\n- The team has gotten money from Kusama before to keep things going."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"3200000000000000","beneficiary":"DggTJdwWEbPS4gERc3SRQL4heQufMeayrZGDpjHNC1iEiui","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"69dddee1624caf226ae3fe06","referendumIndex":645,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15585924,"blockHash":"0xe78e9584ddc8e8d72a3b3411394797503fbde144b0fc760aa8ca2f3a447b9cb3","blockTime":1776148152000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":33,"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"proposer":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","authors":["EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":16141365,"blockHash":"0xecbac1c8817063b37313ea426cc8a5781ae76c54140ffb8a9135fd9e6fbddeff","blockTime":1777394976000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000004ccad8e8d792d00","nays":"0x000000000000000004cfe6349b054822","support":"0x000000000000000000f015513c32df00"}}},"info":{"track":33,"origin":{"origins":"MediumSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xfe94561b3dc461c4b601de748702a2c21ef3af9376ef7807779cf4b3e4d5a02f","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":33092935,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","amount":6666666666600},"deciding":{"since":33095335,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000004ccad8e8d792d00","nays":"0x000000000000000004cfe6349b054822","support":"0x000000000000000000f015513c32df00"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33296920,[33296920,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x000000000000000004ccad8e8d792d00","nays":"0x000000000000000004cfe6349b054822","support":"0x000000000000000000f015513c32df00","electorate":"17352515457820528152"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xfe94561b3dc461c4b601de748702a2c21ef3af9376ef7807779cf4b3e4d5a02f","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"3200000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"DggTJdwWEbPS4gERc3SRQL4heQufMeayrZGDpjHNC1iEiui"}}]}],"amount":"3200000000000000","beneficiary":"DggTJdwWEbPS4gERc3SRQL4heQufMeayrZGDpjHNC1iEiui","beneficiaries":["DggTJdwWEbPS4gERc3SRQL4heQufMeayrZGDpjHNC1iEiui"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"3200000000000000","beneficiary":"DggTJdwWEbPS4gERc3SRQL4heQufMeayrZGDpjHNC1iEiui","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"electorate":"17352515457820528152","rejected":[33296937,{"who":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","amount":33333333333},{"who":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm","amount":6666666666600}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":16136796,"blockHash":"0x97e33a5f9f60189579175c33f213dd58db083dd187aa93143e03f2db5539f13c","blockTime":1777383660000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69dddee1624caf226ae3fe08","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":15585924,"blockHash":"0xe78e9584ddc8e8d72a3b3411394797503fbde144b0fc760aa8ca2f3a447b9cb3","blockTime":1776148152000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeihgcsdcjrtpf5mbqjhcodrtb47ig23ldnmeu4rpj3u7ieescfqc7y","createdAt":"2026-04-14T06:29:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-14T07:08:04.720Z","referendumIndex":645,"contentHash":"6e4d71941364e463e667f2303fe97f5d"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69dddee1624caf226ae3fe08","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm"]},"trackInfo":{"id":33,"name":"medium_spender","originalName":"medium_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"6666666666600","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":821428571,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":14377233,"xOffset":27972031,"yOffset":-13986016}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x6a2bd95c44c00bcad3fef2f7226ad90b8b93c3c1b9679236d5abfdb39c895844","publicKey":"6a2bd95c44c00bcad3fef2f7226ad90b8b93c3c1b9679236d5abfdb39c895844","address":"EyXct79ZDWdQfcSgJTG5texKM9wJj3quyh1ugPDVSkSt3Xm"},"commentsCount":3},{"_id":"69dd0ee7a04636a85d804548","referendumIndex":644,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15560728,"blockHash":"0x7fe1d9553b4da104c7bbeb035bf46e716b6ccffdea3b8bc1a4cc4ed6e3d02b9e","blockTime":1776094896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"proposer":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","title":"Runtime Upgrade v2.2 For All System Chains","content":"Upgrade to [Release v2.2.0](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/releases/tag/v2.2.0)  \nWhitelisted by https://kusama.subsquare.io/fellowship/referenda/131","contentType":"markdown","track":1,"createdAt":"2026-04-13T15:41:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-13T15:44:47.789Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-21T11:49:48.000Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":0,"polkassemblyId":644,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":15870557,"blockHash":"0x7177e90a0d11779e63c88bc23f9012b3ff745131e313ea60dc2177958238f9be","blockTime":1776772188000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeiclvdwh4eihtpcybxqocsuflpc5git2ndhuopz7fndsuzo6kvjx74","contentHash":"797f46bac02691bc11102f535a580e97","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":null,"onchainData":{"_id":"69dd0eda624caf226acbfc68","referendumIndex":644,"indexer":{"blockHeight":15560728,"blockHash":"0x7fe1d9553b4da104c7bbeb035bf46e716b6ccffdea3b8bc1a4cc4ed6e3d02b9e","blockTime":1776094896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"track":1,"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"proposer":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5e03","section":"whitelist","method":"dispatchWhitelistedCallWithPreimage"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":15870557,"blockHash":"0x7177e90a0d11779e63c88bc23f9012b3ff745131e313ea60dc2177958238f9be","blockTime":1776772188000,"eventIndex":19},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":1,"origin":{"origins":"WhitelistedCaller"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x5f727abfbcab771f85cfcfc507278ebab18b993c47198c1791449d93041d5e51","len":291}},"enactment":{"after":10},"submitted":33084201,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000},"deciding":{"since":33096183,"confirming":33194978},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001bafda0015404c94","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000017a90684a0d3886e"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33194978,[33194978,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000001bafda0015404c94","nays":0,"support":"0x000000000000000017a90684a0d3886e","electorate":"17324338412669307984"},"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x5f727abfbcab771f85cfcfc507278ebab18b993c47198c1791449d93041d5e51","fellowshipReferenda":[131],"enactment":{"when":33195078,"index":0},"approved":[33194978,{"who":"Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR","amount":33333333333},{"who":"D9qBj8WnniECUWJxtbsu6ncUN24gKSi3KKp5ZPJjfG2GmaM","amount":333333333330000}],"electorate":"17324338412669307984","whitelistDispatchedHashes":["0x0e52524bbcc33a91a5abb6511f396ded6bdf1db18f77a1d358743586167edd77"],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":15870019,"blockHash":"0x8d3b0c4f68a3201f97b3919506141bc28afeec5e9ebade710b7d2b7ff9d0db99","blockTime":1776770976000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69dd0eda624caf226acbfc6a","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":15560728,"blockHash":"0x7fe1d9553b4da104c7bbeb035bf46e716b6ccffdea3b8bc1a4cc4ed6e3d02b9e","blockTime":1776094896000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":7},"cid":"bafybeiclvdwh4eihtpcybxqocsuflpc5git2ndhuopz7fndsuzo6kvjx74","createdAt":"2026-04-13T15:41:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-04-13T15:44:47.789Z","referendumIndex":644,"contentHash":"797f46bac02691bc11102f535a580e97"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69dd0eda624caf226acbfc6a","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["F2jgWXy7X8GQ2ykf1UGrsCXRERZvjEcd2aDf39fMf3BWVy6","Ea6jhP5gF4r7NqhkEoAXJDgSgYpNQNaTYU6gPsrEGfctaKR"]},"trackInfo":{"id":1,"name":"whitelisted_caller","originalName":"whitelisted_caller\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":100,"decisionDeposit":"333333333330000","preparePeriod":300,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":100,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":270899180,"xOffset":389830523,"yOffset":305084738}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":8650766,"xOffset":18867926,"yOffset":41509433}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"69c47044a04636a85d433061","referendumIndex":643,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14821725,"blockHash":"0xe2f9a1618f6d01527e1a5af27cd4f985bf2ac01cd7bff9be006cab928ac8ad60","blockTime":1774481412000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","title":"System Parachain Collator - Top up 2026 - Revised.","content":"Dear community,\n\nOn behalf of the system parachain collators, I am resubmitting this funding proposal with a materially revised scope and budget. Since the last version, we have made several changes following earlier steering from W3F and, more recently, feedback discussed with Parity. The updated proposal shifts away from the earlier broad 6-month model and toward a more constrained structure focused on work already rendered, lower recurring costs, and a tighter funded collator set.\n\n- **Old proposal:** [System Parachain Collator Bounty - Topup Request January 2026](https://gist.github.com/paradox-tt/a30a2661935a8343c39b47ae127cc5aa)\n- **New proposal:** [Kusama 2026 Topup 1 - Revised](https://gist.github.com/paradox-tt/1992978aa3ef7ea5f782be8e446f22ce)\n\nThe main revisions are as follows:\n\n- **The budget structure has been redesigned.**  \n  The previous proposal was a flat **6-month** request. The revised proposal is now split into three parts:  \n  **A)** the outstanding December remainder,  \n  **B)** reduced-rate payments for **January + February** for work already rendered, and  \n  **C)** a revised funding model running **from March through December**.\n\n- **The exchange rate assumption has changed.**  \n  The older version used **$7.3985 per 1 KSM**, while the revised proposal uses **$4.49 per 1 KSM**.\n\n- **Staking rewards have been removed entirely.**  \n  The old proposal included a staking-reward component for **62 collators**, estimated at roughly **39.24 KSM/month**. The revised proposal explicitly states **no staking rewards**.\n\n- **The tool-development budget has been removed.**  \n  The previous version included a **one-time $4,250** Kusama allocation for completing the updated scraping/payout tool. The revised proposal explicitly removes that budget line.\n\n- **Funding is no longer proposed for permissionless collators.**  \n  In the older version, the funded set included both **invulnerable and permissionless collators**, for a total of **62 eligible collators**. In the revised version, funding is limited to **invulnerable community collators only**.\n\n- **The funded collator set has been reduced.**  \n  The old proposal funded **62 collators** at **$300/month**. The revised model funds **30 collators total** from March onward at **$250/month**, based on a tiered categorization of system chains.\n\n- **A tiered model has replaced the previous broad funding model.**  \n  From March onward, the revised proposal uses the following funded set:  \n  - **AssetHub:** 8  \n  - **BridgeHub:** 8  \n  - **People:** 8  \n  - **Coretime:** 4  \n  - **Encointer:** 2  \n  This results in **30 funded community invulnerables** in total.\n\n- **Administrative compensation has been simplified and reduced within the Kusama ask.**  \n  Previously, curators were compensated via a **7.5% fee** on the monthly subtotal. The revised proposal replaces this with fixed curator compensation of **$250 per curator per month** (**$750/month total**).  \n  In addition, **coordinator costs are no longer included in Kusama budget items B and C**, as those are covered under the **Polkadot proposal**.\n\n- **Hosting remains included at a fixed monthly cost.**  \n  The revised proposal keeps hosting fixed at **$425/month**.\n\n- **The recurring collator compensation has been reduced from the earlier draft.**  \n  In the previous version, the March-onward funding model assumed **$300 per funded collator per month**. The revised proposal lowers this to **$250 per funded collator per month**, further reducing the recurring cost of the proposal.\n\n- **The total scope and headline ask have changed significantly.**  \n  The previous draft described a 6-month total of about **17,456.59 KSM**. The revised proposal now totals **$120,316.14**, or **26,796.47 KSM**, across parts **A + B + C**.\n\n- **The updated period totals are now as follows:**  \n  - **A) December outstanding:** **$6,416.14** | **1,428.98 KSM**  \n  - **B) January + February:** **$27,150.00** | **6,046.77 KSM**  \n  - **C) March through December:** **$86,750.00** | **19,320.71 KSM**\n\nOverall, the revised proposal is intended to reflect current treasury constraints while preserving support for the most critical system-chain collator infrastructure.\n\nRegards,\nWill | Paradox | ParaNodes.io","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-03-25T23:30:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-25T23:34:19.830Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-03T15:50:00.000Z","state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":15162130,"blockHash":"0xe9587315c9564a0931acd200e79f4bf8736c6ee81f60b54110aab9846f1f3248","blockTime":1775231400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":643,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeic5vwkcfsh3yxosidkje4l2shrqzwpa3t6cekb6nvhoimyd2hummu","contentHash":"bf249ba98a8e9788226f5ae1869dd35d","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"bf249ba98a8e9788226f5ae1869dd35d","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- This is an updated plan to pay people who help run the Kusama network.\n- The new plan is simpler and costs less money than the old one.\n- It only pays a smaller group of 30 important helpers, not 62.\n- Each helper will get $250 a month, which is less than before.\n- The plan asks for a total of about 26,796 KSM to cover different months of work."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"26796470000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"69c4703a62cc2d8cf23a67cc","referendumIndex":643,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14821725,"blockHash":"0xe2f9a1618f6d01527e1a5af27cd4f985bf2ac01cd7bff9be006cab928ac8ad60","blockTime":1774481412000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Executed","indexer":{"blockHeight":15162130,"blockHash":"0xe9587315c9564a0931acd200e79f4bf8736c6ee81f60b54110aab9846f1f3248","blockTime":1775231400000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"result":{"ok":null}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xf765b157957103c4dfdb70be3332abe4aba47a884ffd0bd4ec2823d15c3aa547","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":32820319,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":32822719,"confirming":32928410},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000169de94922940d00","nays":"0x000000000000000003df08352bca0854","support":"0x00000000000000000b45e630c816d200"},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[32928410,[32928410,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000169de94922940d00","nays":"0x000000000000000003df08352bca0854","support":"0x00000000000000000b45e630c816d200","electorate":"17230392000623820516"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xf765b157957103c4dfdb70be3332abe4aba47a884ffd0bd4ec2823d15c3aa547","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"26796470000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"}}]}],"amount":"26796470000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","beneficiaries":["F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"26796470000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"enactment":{"when":32942810,"index":0},"approved":[32928410,{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":13333333333200}],"electorate":"17230392000623820516","treasuryProposalIndex":457,"treasuryProposalIndexes":[457],"lastConfirmStartedAt":{"blockHeight":15041391,"blockHash":"0xf3dd87f2f9ef85c92006b66638906de228bce37e4c58fbb4903264de29bb30d1","blockTime":1774967196000,"eventIndex":0}},"refToPost":{"postId":"69c4703a62cc2d8cf23a67ce","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":14821725,"blockHash":"0xe2f9a1618f6d01527e1a5af27cd4f985bf2ac01cd7bff9be006cab928ac8ad60","blockTime":1774481412000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":5},"cid":"bafybeic5vwkcfsh3yxosidkje4l2shrqzwpa3t6cekb6nvhoimyd2hummu","createdAt":"2026-03-25T23:30:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-25T23:34:19.830Z","referendumIndex":643,"contentHash":"bf249ba98a8e9788226f5ae1869dd35d"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69c4703a62cc2d8cf23a67ce","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xe8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","publicKey":"e8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","address":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"},"commentsCount":1},{"_id":"69c2fb36a04636a85df59631","referendumIndex":642,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14778709,"blockHash":"0xbecbe7b1aca8bdd08c54b231523ec5604d2400105af7254954b7fd94783a4eec","blockTime":1774385916000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","title":"System Parachain Collator Bounty - Top up (2026) - Please vote NAY","content":"Will be revised.","contentType":"markdown","track":11,"createdAt":"2026-03-24T20:58:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-25T10:47:26.169Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-08T05:38:36.000Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":642,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15342093,"blockHash":"0x6c32002c3593291ce236b08cc48859629ce29af56e7227fc47bb0289edf14e30","blockTime":1775626716000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":41812323210904,"nays":"0x0000000000000000043ce70977a5cc44","support":14604107736968}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeifouhwpz6p52cwvzdur5i5cza65ky2qnfpgbllbnr3q5z7xmp5p2m","contentHash":"674de3277c6c537ed7118eb80a135d59","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":null,"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"38809820000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"69c2fb3114bcc8848bbd503f","referendumIndex":642,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14778709,"blockHash":"0xbecbe7b1aca8bdd08c54b231523ec5604d2400105af7254954b7fd94783a4eec","blockTime":1774385916000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":11,"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15342093,"blockHash":"0x6c32002c3593291ce236b08cc48859629ce29af56e7227fc47bb0289edf14e30","blockTime":1775626716000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":41812323210904,"nays":"0x0000000000000000043ce70977a5cc44","support":14604107736968}}},"info":{"track":11,"origin":{"origins":"Treasurer"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x5893858ca4d5c88ec395f55a12e8420b97a065590488b5c37228b18379bd6628","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":32804716,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333000},"deciding":{"since":32805916,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":41812323210904,"nays":"0x0000000000000000043ce70977a5cc44","support":14604107736968},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[33007516,[33007516,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":41812323210904,"nays":"0x0000000000000000043ce70977a5cc44","support":14604107736968,"electorate":"17277999862501339973"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x5893858ca4d5c88ec395f55a12e8420b97a065590488b5c37228b18379bd6628","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"38809820000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"}}]}],"amount":"38809820000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","beneficiaries":["F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"38809820000000000","beneficiary":"F3opxRbN5ZbjJNU513biNemEwi2QDYNACcNqzU68jHWZos2","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"electorate":"17277999862501339973","rejected":[33007517,{"who":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn","amount":33333333333},{"who":"J11Rp4mjz3vRb2DL51HqRGRjhuEQRyXgtuFskebXb8zMZ9s","amount":33333333333000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"refToPost":{"postId":"69c2fb3114bcc8848bbd5041","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":14778709,"blockHash":"0xbecbe7b1aca8bdd08c54b231523ec5604d2400105af7254954b7fd94783a4eec","blockTime":1774385916000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeifouhwpz6p52cwvzdur5i5cza65ky2qnfpgbllbnr3q5z7xmp5p2m","createdAt":"2026-03-24T20:58:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-25T10:47:26.169Z","referendumIndex":642,"contentHash":"674de3277c6c537ed7118eb80a135d59"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69c2fb3114bcc8848bbd5041","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"]},"trackInfo":{"id":11,"name":"treasurer","originalName":"treasurer\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"33333333333000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0xe8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","publicKey":"e8b2603f6baee5bc32a9b9e4eee9168499fa553d35edb56aef0035ff7e1f165e","address":"HqRcfhH8VXMhuCk5JXe28WMgDDuW9MVDVNofe1nnTcefVZn"},"commentsCount":0},{"_id":"69c0ecffa04636a85dab9fbd","referendumIndex":641,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14716170,"blockHash":"0xecb62f76c0465d813be2e258dca1785f8a991b1ba5c2dc7330b5b1af35d61993","blockTime":1774251216000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","title":"[Kusama] Subscan 2025 Q3-Q4 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)","content":">Due to potential display issues with some charts in format across various devices and platforms, please refer to the detailed information in this Google Document:\n\n>https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NXVGFI6i-5zoEXoMpm30j2u7FA5h9f1n2ccWvxR9RWE/edit?usp=sharing\n\n### Past discussion\n\nhttps://kusama.polkassembly.io/post/2686\n\n### Past proposals\n\n  - [\\#229 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine (from July to December 2022)](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/229)\n  - [\\#377 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Asset Hub (Kusama) Networks (from January 2023 to March 2024)](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/377)\n  - [\\#434 Subscan | Infrastructure Costs of Subscan for Kusama & Statemine Networks (from April to June 2024)](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/434)\n  - [\\#482 Subscan Q2/Q3/Q4 2024 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/482)\n  - [\\#581 Subscan 2025 Q1-Q2 Funding Proposal: Basic service fee for the Kusama Relaychain and Kusama public parachain (AssetHub, Coretime, BridgeHub, People)](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/581)\n\n### Overview\n\nSubscan requests funding from the Kusama Treasury to support 2025 Q3–Q4 operational maintenance for the following five networks:\n\n  - Kusama Relay Chain\n  - AssetHub-Kusama\n  - Coretime-Kusama\n  - BridgeHub-Kusama\n  - People-Kusama\n\nSubscan is one of the most essential public data infrastructure services in the Kusama ecosystem, providing stable, accurate, and low-latency indexing for developers, validators, governance systems, wallets, and other crucial tools.\n\nThis proposal covers only maintenance and necessary compatibility work, not new feature development.  \n\nTotal requested amount: USD 141,624 (to be converted to KSM using the 30-day average price at submission)\n\n### Recent Contributions and Ongoing Maintenance Work\n\nOver the past several months, Subscan has continued to deliver crucial updates and maintenance work for the Kusama ecosystem. Beyond providing stable explorer and indexing services, our team has:\n\n  - Completed multiple runtime upgrade adaptations across the Kusama Relay Chain and all supported public parachains, ensuring uninterrupted indexing and API availability.\n  - Enhanced compatibility with new chain features introduced through recent upgrades, including adjustments to governance, asset management, and cross-chain messaging logic.\n  - Supported the October AssetHub migration on Kusama, making all necessary backend modifications and data-structure updates to ensure seamless continuity for users and downstream tooling.\n  - Performed continuous bug fixes, data consistency checks, and indexing optimizations, keeping data quality and performance at high standards despite growing chain complexity.\n\n### Why Subscan Matters\n\nAs the default block explorer and indexing layer for Kusama, Subscan provides the foundational data required by nearly all ecosystem participants.\n\n### Developers & Applications\n\n  - Reliable APIs: blocks, extrinsics, events, XCM, assets, NFTs\n  - Faster debugging and monitoring\n  - Data infrastructure for indexers, dashboards, bots, dApps\n\n### Parachain Teams & Validators\n\n  - Real-time block production, sync status, and finality\n  - XCM tracking across chains\n  - Early detection of node anomalies\n\n### Governance Platforms & Participants\n\n  - Referendum status, account history, delegation data\n  - Governance dashboards dependent on Subscan APIs\n  - Long-term auditability of past governance decisions\n\n### End Users, Wallets, and Ecosystem Tools\n\n  - Transfers, staking, NFT queries, asset visibility\n  - Multi-chain UI consistency and reliability\n\nWithout Subscan, many essential tools would face significant data degradation, and the accessibility of historical and governance data would be severely impacted.\n\n### Scope of This Proposal\n\nThis proposal includes the following mandatory maintenance activities:\n\n### Core Operational Maintenance\n\n  - Continuous indexing, data storage, and DB maintenance\n  - Multi-node redundancy and sync monitoring\n  - Data consistency and latency optimization\n\n### Runtime Upgrade Compatibility\n\n  - Support for upgrades on the Kusama Relay Chain and all four public parachains\n  - Adaptation to evolving XCM, Assets, Governance, and system modules\n  - Ensuring zero-downtime during upgrade cycles\n\n### Essential Bug Fixing & Performance Tuning\n\n  - Schema updates and historical data alignment\n  - Compatibility fixes for nodes and indexers\n  - Performance improvements for high-load scenarios\n\n### Support for Major Ecosystem Changes\n\n  - Previously ensured smooth migration for AssetHub and recent system updates\n  - Future major migrations or critical runtime changes will be fully supported\n\n### Service Fee Model & Pricing Methodology\n\nThroughout 2025, Subscan has focused on deep infrastructure optimization. By refining our technical stack, we have successfully reduced internal overhead and operational costs without compromising the high service standards the ecosystem expects. Our goal is to pass these efficiencies directly to the networks we support through a more competitive pricing structure.\n\n### Phased Implementation Strategy\n\nTo ensure a stable transition, we are rolling out these optimizations and subsequent price reductions in stages:\n\n  - Pilot Phase (Westend): The new infrastructure and discounted pricing are already being piloted on the Westend testnet.\n  - Expansion Phase: Following the Westend pilot, these optimizations will be progressively integrated into canary networks (Kusama) and eventually the Polkadot mainnet.\n  - Current Proposal Scope (2025 Q3–Q4): This proposal maintains the existing fee structure to ensure continuity and stability during the final stages of the optimization rollout.\n  - 2026 Outlook: Starting in Q1 2026, a fully optimized pricing model and additional discounts will be applied across all supported networks.\n\nNote: For a detailed breakdown of how these infrastructure improvements will impact future budgets, please refer to the \"2026 Cost Outlook (Infrastructure Optimization Based)\" section.\n\n### Pricing Methodology\n\nFor the period of 2025 Q3–Q4, Subscan’s fee structure remains consistent with the model successfully utilized over the past two years.\n\nOur maintenance packages are designed to support a wide range of data and operational needs, ensuring stable and efficient system performance. Because our overall cost structure is composed of multiple infrastructure and operational expenses—such as cloud services, network acceleration, monitoring systems, node providers, and the Subscan team’s ongoing operations—we use storage consumption as the primary metric for determining service fees.\n\nPricing Tiers:  \na. Basic Plan\n\n  - Up to 200 GB: $799/month\n  - Beyond 200 GB: $5.3/GB\n  - Automatically upgrades to the next tier after 350 GB\n\nb. Advanced Plan\n\n  - Up to 500 GB: $1,699/month\n  - Beyond 500 GB: $5.2/GB\n  - Automatically upgrades to the next tier after 750 GB\n\nc. Professional Plan\n\n  - Up to 1 TB: $2,999/month\n  - Beyond 1 TB: $5/GB\n\n### Monthly Service Fee Breakdown\n\n1.  Database Storage & Indexing\n\n  - What It Covers: Continuous indexing of on-chain data—from blocks and transactions to event logs, governance info, and NFTs—so users can reliably access both real-time and historical records.\n  - Why It Matters: As chain activity increases, so does data volume. By tying fees to storage needs, we accurately account for the costs of scaling infrastructure (e.g., additional database capacity).\n\n2.  Network Egress Bandwidth\n\n  - What It Covers: The outgoing traffic required to serve user requests quickly and consistently, including API calls, UI data retrieval, and integrations with third-party tools.\n  - Why It Matters: A stable, high-bandwidth connection ensures that explorers, wallets, and dApps receive timely data responses, even during peak activity.\n\n3.  Monitoring & DevOps\n\n  - What It Covers: Round-the-clock health checks, internal alert pipelines, CI/CD automation, and system auditing. This includes running multiple nodes, maintaining synchronization, and ensuring high availability.\n  - Why It Matters: These processes help detect issues early (e.g., node crashes, indexer slowdowns) and streamline updates or deployments, minimizing service disruption for the community.\n\n4.  Node Status Monitoring & Notifications\n\n  - What It Covers: Dedicated tools and alert mechanisms to track the real-time status of network nodes—particularly those relating to the Kusama Relay Chain and the associated parachains (Assethub, Coretime, Bridgehub, People).\n  - Why It Matters: Quick notifications enable parachain teams, validators, and the wider ecosystem to react rapidly to performance changes, forks, or potential security incidents.\n\n5.  Technical Support & Troubleshooting\n\n  - What It Covers: Responsive assistance for users, developers, and validators, including issue resolution, feature guidance, and integration help.\n  - Why It Matters: Timely support keeps the ecosystem running smoothly and fosters a positive development environment—especially crucial for teams building dApps, explorers, and automation tools.\n\n## Why We Use Storage as a Pricing Metric\n\nCorrelation to Real Costs:  \n Storage growth scales directly with block production and transaction activity, making it a more stable and predictable metric than raw API traffic. As chain activity evolves, storage becomes the clearest and most consistent indicator of the underlying infrastructure load required to maintain long-term historical data.\n\nSubscan Baseline:  \n Subscan determines the appropriate fee tier based on the median storage consumption measured during the billing period. For example, for the Q3–Q4 2025 billing cycle, the baseline storage usage is derived from data recorded on September 30th.\n\nPredictable Billing:  \n Basing fees on storage reduces the volatility caused by sudden traffic spikes and ensures a more transparent, usage-based cost model for both the community and the treasury.\n\n## Beyond Storage: The Full Cost Landscape\n\nOur pricing also incorporates the broader operational overhead required to run a production-grade, high-availability data service—such as cloud infrastructure, network acceleration, monitoring systems, node providers, and Subscan’s ongoing engineering and support efforts.\n\nBecause these components fluctuate dynamically based on cloud regions, traffic patterns, redundancy requirements, and security considerations, they cannot be broken down into a stable or meaningful line-item list. In addition, some of these details involve sensitive architectural and security-related information that should not be fully disclosed publicly in order to preserve system robustness and reduce attack surface.\n\nFor these reasons, Subscan adopts a service-fee-based pricing model, which is consistent with industry practices used by major explorer and indexing providers. Pegging the service fee to storage usage strikes the right balance between:\n\n  - transparent and verifiable metrics (storage is measurable on-chain and externally),\n  - predictable treasury budgeting, and\n  - preserving the flexibility and sustainability necessary to maintain and upgrade a mission-critical public data infrastructure.\n\nThis model also enables Subscan to invest continuously in optimization and long-term cost reduction—ensuring that infrastructure improvements directly translate into better performance and lower overall fees for the ecosystem over time.\n\n### Fee Details\n\n#### 2025 Q3 & Q4 Maintenance Fee\n\n| Network | Actual Usage/GB | Date | Package | Fees/Month | Billing Period | Fees |\n| :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: |\n| Kusama | 4236.9 | 30/09/2025 | Professional | 19063 | Q3 & Q4: 01/07/2025-31/12/2025 | 114378 |\n| AssetHub-Kusama | 341.96 | 30/09/2025 | Basic+ | 1546 | Q3 & Q4: 01/07/2025-31/12/2025 | 9276 |\n| Coretime-Kusama | 93.14 | 30/09/2025 | Basic | 799 | Q3 & Q4: 01/07/2025-31/12/2025 | 4794 |\n| BridgeHub-Kusama | 313.12 | 30/09/2025 | Basic | 1397 | Q3 & Q4: 01/07/2025-31/12/2025 | 8382 |\n| People-Kusama | 88.89 | 30/09/2025 | Basic | 799 | Q3 & Q4: 01/07/2025-31/12/2025 | 4794 |\n\n  - Total Maintenance Fees for 2025 Q3 & Q4 (5 networks): USD 141,624\n\n### Why Kusama’s Fee Is Higher Than Other Chains\n\nKusama Relay Chain currently exceeds 4 TB of indexed data. This is primarily the result of long-term historical accumulation and the high density of chain activity. The key technical factors driving the large storage footprint include:\n\n1\\. Long network lifespan and full historical retention\n\nKusama is one of the earliest and longest-running networks in the Polkadot ecosystem.  \n Its extended operational history results in a significantly larger volume of blocks, extrinsics, events, and state transitions.  \n Subscan preserves complete historical data without pruning, ensuring full auditability and long-term access for developers, explorers, governance tools, and research.\n\n2\\. Increasing data complexity over time\n\nAs runtime modules, governance logic, asset operations, and state transition models have evolved, the structure and richness of on-chain events have grown substantially.  \n This results in more complex data schemas and heavier indexing requirements for historical blocks.\n\n3\\. High density of XCM-related activity\n\nKusama carries some of the most experimental and active XCM traffic in the entire ecosystem.  \n The large number of cross-chain messages and event records generates:\n\n  - substantially more event data,\n  - more complex event-linking requirements, and\n  - larger historical datasets that must be preserved to maintain auditability.\n\nThis XCM-heavy traffic is a major contributor to the relay chain’s significantly larger storage footprint compared to individual parachains.\n\n### Optimization & Cost Reduction Roadmap\n\n(Already operational on [Westend testnet](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1iAToZZz9U2j56bC6VZ_JtFuBV2FIbegvVUi4tz35C_c/edit?tab=t.0) and gradually rolling out across the Kusama and Polkadot ecosystems, with quantifiable cost-reduction results to be reflected in billing beginning Q1 2026.)\n\nTo mitigate long-term storage growth and reduce operational costs—particularly for the Kusama relay chain—we are executing several structural optimization initiatives. These include efforts to reduce reliance on GCP and lower total cost of ownership.\n\n### 1\\. Hot/Cold storage separation\n\nWe are segmenting frequently accessed data into high-performance storage tiers while moving older blocks and events into cost-efficient archival layers.  \n This significantly reduces the cost of maintaining multi-terabyte historical datasets.\n\n### 2\\. XCM-focused indexing optimizations\n\nGiven that XCM events represent a major portion of Kusama’s data weight, we are optimizing:\n\n  - event-linking logic,\n  - redundant index structures, and\n  - cross-chain reference mappings.\n\nThese adjustments reduce long-term index growth without affecting query accuracy.\n\n### 3\\. Reduced reliance on GCP (major cost-efficiency initiative)\n\nTo optimize long-term infrastructure costs, we are:\n\n  - migrating certain storage layers to lower-cost object-storage providers,\n  - reducing GCP I/O operations via caching and pre-aggregation strategies,\n  - gradually shifting parts of the system toward self-hosted or hybrid infrastructure.\n\nThese changes directly address one of the largest cost drivers in the current operational model.\n\n### Long-Term Sustainability & Vision Our long-term goal is to reduce reliance on treasury funding through multiple channels:\n\n  - Continuous optimization to limit infrastructure costs as chain data grows.\n  - Exploring responsible revenue streams (e.g., optional premium features or partnerships).\n  - Actively incorporating community suggestions to ensure value delivery aligns with user needs, increasing platform utility and potential monetization avenues without compromising openness or neutrality.\n\n### 🔥 2026 Cost Outlook (Infrastructure Optimization Based)\n\nSubscan’s goal is to deliver high-quality infrastructure services with stable performance, predictable budgeting, and cost-efficient pricing, while also offering additional discounts for prepaid commitments.\n\nAs our ongoing optimization continues, Subscan expects to introduce more favorable and more predictable pricing in Q1 2026, including:\n\n  - A more standardized pricing structure across networks and services\n  - Improved cost efficiency at higher usage levels\n  - Additional incentives for annual/prepaid subscriptions\n\nBASIC PLAN\n\n  - $799 / Month\n  - Includes 500 GB / Month\n  - Up to ~52% lower total cost vs previous pricing at high usage\n\nADVANCED PLAN\n\n  - $1,699 / Month\n  - Includes 1 TB / Month\n  - Up to ~43% lower total cost vs previous pricing at high usage\n\nCUSTOM PLAN\n\n  - Tailored pricing based on usage\n  - ~33% lower total cost vs previous pricing at high usage\n\n### Annual Payment Network Discounts (Stackable)\n\n  - Mainnet: 10% off\n  - Canary: 25% off\n  - Testnet: 40% off\n\n2026 Estimated Annual Cost (Updated Pricing + Testnet Annual Discount)\n\n| Network / Service | Plan | Monthly Fee (USD) | Annual Billing Discount | Annual Fee (USD) |\n| :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: | :-: |\n| Kusama | Custom | 10,000 | 25% | 90000 |\n| Kusama Trace Service (Optional) | Custom | 4,000 | 25% | 36000 |\n| AssetHub (Kusama) | Advanced (Up to 1 TB/month) | 1,699 | 25% | 15291 |\n| AssetHub (Kusama) Trace Service (Optional)（This is a new feature and has not yet been officially implemented.） | Custom | 2,000 | 25% | 18000 |\n| Coretime (Kusama) | Basic (Up to 500 GB/month) | 799 | 25% | 7191 |\n| BridgeHub (Kusama) | Basic (Up to 500 GB/month) | 799 | 25% | 7191 |\n| People (Kusama) | Basic (Up to 500 GB/month) | 799 | 25% | 7191 |\n\nBased on the current scope and configuration, the estimated Total Annual Fee (USD) for 2026 is: 180,864.\n\nPlease note that this amount is provided for 2026 cost forecasting purposes only, and is intended to support an evaluation of the long-term sustainability of the service. We welcome further discussion on the most suitable payment structure and scope adjustments, including:\n\n  - Whether annual billing is preferred (with applicable discounts)\n  - After the AssetHub migration, whether the positioning and service scope of AssetHub should be updated\n  - Whether to enable additional AssetHub Trace functionality, if required\n  - Whether to disable Relay Chain Trace to optimize cost efficiency\n\nSubscan will prepare the 2026 service proposal based on the community’s feedback and preferred direction.\n\n### Total Requested Amount\n\nThe total requested amount for all 5 networks, including all maintenance, operational overhead, and mandatory compatibility work, is USD 141,624. This request will be submitted in KSM, converted based on the 30-day average price at the time of on-chain submission.\n\n<https://assethub-kusama.subscan.io/tools/price_converter?value=141624&type=block&from=USD&to=KSM&time=14715524>\n\n2026-03-23 07:00:00 (+UTC), Block \\#14715524\n\nKSM Price ( USD ): 4.340000;\n\nNumber of KSM: 32632.258064\n\nKSM EMA7 Price ( USD ): 4.500600;\n\nNumber of KSM: 31467.804292\n\nKSM EMA30 Price ( USD ): 4.690700;\n\nNumber of KSM: 30192.508580\n\nConclusion  \nSubscan has evolved alongside Kusama since its inception, serving as the \"window\" into the network’s data. As we move into the second half of 2025, this proposal is not just a request for funding, but a commitment to maintaining the gold standard of data transparency for the Kusama ecosystem.\n\n### Why This Proposal Deserves Your Support:\n\n  - Ensuring Ecosystem Continuity: Subscan serves as a reliable data backbone for governance, staking, and XCM tracking. Our goal is to ensure that developers, validators, and users have uninterrupted access to high-fidelity data, preventing any friction in decision-making or daily operations during critical network upgrades.\n  - A Bridge to Lower Costs: While this Q3-Q4 proposal follows the established pricing model to ensure service continuity, it serves as the final transition period. The technical optimizations we are implementing now (such as the Westend pilot) are the direct foundation for the significantly reduced 2026 pricing tiers.\n  - Efficiency First: We have proactively addressed the high storage costs of the Kusama Relay Chain through hot/cold data separation and GCP optimization. Our commitment is to ensure that as Kusama grows, the cost of its infrastructure does not scale linearly, but becomes more efficient over time.\n  - Unmatched Maintenance: This funding covers the rigorous, behind-the-scenes work of adapting to constant runtime upgrades and new feature—ensuring that when the network evolves, the tools the community relies on don't break.\n\n### Summary of Commitment\n\nSubscan is more than a block explorer; it is a public good. By supporting this proposal, the Kusama Treasury is investing in the reliability and accessibility of the network's data. We remain open to community feedback regarding the 2026 roadmap and are dedicated to delivering a more cost-effective, high-performance service in the coming year.\n\nWe invite the community to review our track record of consistent delivery and support this proposal to keep Kusama's data infrastructure robust and reliable.\n","contentType":"markdown","track":34,"createdAt":"2026-03-23T07:33:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-23T07:39:58.656Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-06T18:35:48.000Z","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15285506,"blockHash":"0xde00d5aa17caa5654d95a502d9c7a4f26f2b570b1b25b1575c79230b88309587","blockTime":1775500548000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001b19a74049d100","nays":"0x000000000000000003df074eab30dc54","support":1468305000000000}}},"stateSort":5,"edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":1,"polkassemblyId":641,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","cid":"bafybeiaxdpx2nzf7shohhpckjwrcohlnhh7pudjseoh7o2al2mgplagaci","contentHash":"53e3cc97f8856b88fc7568980537f8b2","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"53e3cc97f8856b88fc7568980537f8b2","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- **What is Subscan?**  \n  Subscan is a tool that helps people see and use data from the Kusama network, like checking transactions, blocks, and votes.\n\n- **What does this proposal ask for?**  \n  Subscan is asking for money to keep working for 6 months (July to December 2025) on five parts of Kusama.\n\n- **How much money?**  \n  They want $141,624, which will be paid in KSM coins based on an average price.\n\n- **What will the money be used for?**  \n  The money pays for basic maintenance, like keeping the data service running, fixing bugs, and updating the system when Kusama upgrades.\n\n- **Why is it important?**  \n  Many people in the Kusama community, like developers, validators, and voters, use Subscan to get important information. Without it, their work would be harder.\n\n- **Will costs go down in the future?**  \n  Yes! Subscan is working to make their system cheaper. They plan to lower prices starting in 2026.\n\n- **What about past work?**  \n  Subscan has been funded by Kusama before to do similar work, and they have a history of completing their tasks."},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"30192000000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","after":null}],"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"isTreasuryV1":true,"onchainData":{"_id":"69c0ecfa0f4f479693c399b5","referendumIndex":641,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14716170,"blockHash":"0xecb62f76c0465d813be2e258dca1785f8a991b1ba5c2dc7330b5b1af35d61993","blockTime":1774251216000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":34,"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"proposer":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15285506,"blockHash":"0xde00d5aa17caa5654d95a502d9c7a4f26f2b570b1b25b1575c79230b88309587","blockTime":1775500548000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001b19a74049d100","nays":"0x000000000000000003df074eab30dc54","support":1468305000000000}}},"info":{"track":34,"origin":{"origins":"BigSpender"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0xa509c75e3e1e22576a5e28cfb2fcb71910c5f54fbdc0943e6cb6eb005db6d54e","len":43}},"enactment":{"after":14400},"submitted":32782843,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":13333333333200},"deciding":{"since":32785243,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001b19a74049d100","nays":"0x000000000000000003df074eab30dc54","support":1468305000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[32986843,[32986843,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x0000000000000000001b19a74049d100","nays":"0x000000000000000003df074eab30dc54","support":1468305000000000,"electorate":"17244502414518496129"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":[],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0xa509c75e3e1e22576a5e28cfb2fcb71910c5f54fbdc0943e6cb6eb005db6d54e","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasury":true,"isTreasuryProposal":true,"treasuryInfo":{"calls":[{"callIndex":"0x5a03","section":"treasury","method":"spendLocal","args":[{"name":"amount","type":"Compact<u128>","value":"30192000000000000"},{"name":"beneficiary","type":"MultiAddress","value":{"id":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae"}}]}],"amount":"30192000000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","beneficiaries":["HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae"]},"allSpends":[{"isSpendLocal":true,"type":"native","symbol":"KSM","amount":"30192000000000000","beneficiary":"HRkTZWtCKJwDKRtrxzB2wjHthtJhvjps3vznyTRtBAnjQae","after":null}],"isTreasuryV1":true,"electorate":"17244502414518496129","rejected":[32986843,{"who":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc","amount":33333333333},{"who":"CoxPmsXK24q3QB6jHSxwTxEHJ5375Mo4kPfUZYfKQMxXqZ9","amount":13333333333200}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"refToPost":{"postId":"69c0ecfa0f4f479693c399b7","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":14716170,"blockHash":"0xecb62f76c0465d813be2e258dca1785f8a991b1ba5c2dc7330b5b1af35d61993","blockTime":1774251216000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeiaxdpx2nzf7shohhpckjwrcohlnhh7pudjseoh7o2al2mgplagaci","createdAt":"2026-03-23T07:33:36.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-23T07:39:58.656Z","referendumIndex":641,"contentHash":"53e3cc97f8856b88fc7568980537f8b2"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69c0ecfa0f4f479693c399b7","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"]},"trackInfo":{"id":34,"name":"big_spender","originalName":"big_spender\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":50,"decisionDeposit":"13333333333200","preparePeriod":2400,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":28800,"minEnactmentPeriod":14400,"minApproval":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":500000000,"ceil":1000000000}},"minSupport":{"reciprocal":{"factor":28326977,"xOffset":53763445,"yOffset":-26881723}}},"author":{"username":"polkadot-key-0x976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","publicKey":"976ce4203c844a11164d1b3f8342ad16a4cc5d99ac8eaae5cd74f4b1cc68c764","emailMd5":"fc29fe0533e27b4fe4341203b696c432","address":"Fzs6WWFcAuJhxAVyZa4EN2suxggjidJjV3AzJxKbRHjh2Jc"},"commentsCount":2},{"_id":"69b997d4a04636a85d1b6fc3","referendumIndex":640,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14491014,"blockHash":"0xe88a5be15973a74c787bab05ee95809de20b3319bc8980e520acf02c4649aa71","blockTime":1773770652000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"proposer":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","title":"[WFC] No Fellowship Removal Without Kusama Vote","content":"## Wish\n\nAny change that removes, merges, or otherwise eliminates the Kusama Technical Fellowship as an independent on-chain collective shall require a dedicated Wish For Change referendum on Kusama, approved by Kusama token holders, before implementation.\n\nThis applies to all mechanisms — including but not limited to runtime upgrades, Fellowship whitelisted calls, or governance migration — that would result in Kusama no longer having its own Technical Fellowship distinct from the Polkadot Technical Fellowship.\n\n## Context\n\n[Issue #484](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/issues/484) proposes retiring the Kusama Technical Fellowship in favor of the Polkadot Technical Fellowship operating via bridge. [PR #1100](https://github.com/polkadot-fellows/runtimes/pull/1100), merged March 12 2026, is the first implementation step — making Kusama system chains recognize the Polkadot Fellowship's authority alongside Kusama's own. This follows [WFC 573](https://kusama.subsquare.io/referenda/573), which committed Kusama to an independent JAM upgrade path.\n\nThe community whose governance structure would change should decide whether that change happens.\n\n## What this WFC does NOT do\n\n- It does not oppose fellowship consolidation on its merits\n- It does not seek to reverse PR #1100 (both fellowships currently coexist)\n- It does not require a separate Kusama Fellowship to be independently funded\n- It does not claim fellowship removal is irreversible — Kusama OpenGov retains full sovereignty regardless\n\nIt establishes one requirement: no removal without a Kusama vote.","contentType":"markdown","track":2,"createdAt":"2026-03-17T18:04:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-17T18:16:03.060Z","lastActivityAt":"2026-04-01T03:24:12.000Z","edited":true,"polkassemblyCommentsCount":2,"polkassemblyId":640,"polkassemblyPostType":"ReferendumV2","state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15062484,"blockHash":"0xcaaab69642c3d58120b57911f8be0baba60dd4a3e2dad159286b388b2099f7c9","blockTime":1775013852000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000012edd0c54e1100","nays":"0x000000000000000003c2b081b7f33c06","support":1502305000000000}}},"stateSort":5,"cid":"bafybeiexvq4f6linktrszeca6gua6ikyzofqwlui2i2edx6j53bf4yuuxi","contentHash":"8b9179f59c01fd6c4f47dd403d22c81a","contentVersion":"2","dataSource":"sima","contentSummary":{"contentHash":"8b9179f59c01fd6c4f47dd403d22c81a","vendor":"deepseek","model":"deepseek-chat","summary":"- This is about keeping the Kusama Technical Fellowship as its own group.\n- A new rule says you can't remove or merge it without a special vote by Kusama token holders.\n- This rule is being made because some people want to combine it with the Polkadot Fellowship.\n- The community that would be affected should get to decide.\n- This does not stop the two groups from working together right now.\n- It also doesn't mean the Kusama group needs its own separate money.\n- It just says you need a vote before making it go away."},"allSpends":null,"isBoundDiscussion":false,"isFinal":true,"isTreasuryProposal":null,"isTreasuryV1":false,"onchainData":{"_id":"69b997c559479e403a8b2f92","referendumIndex":640,"indexer":{"blockHeight":14491014,"blockHash":"0xe88a5be15973a74c787bab05ee95809de20b3319bc8980e520acf02c4649aa71","blockTime":1773770652000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"track":2,"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"proposer":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","authors":["FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH"],"proposal":{"callIndex":"0x0000","section":"system","method":"remark"},"state":{"name":"Rejected","indexer":{"blockHeight":15062484,"blockHash":"0xcaaab69642c3d58120b57911f8be0baba60dd4a3e2dad159286b388b2099f7c9","blockTime":1775013852000,"eventIndex":1},"args":{"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000012edd0c54e1100","nays":"0x000000000000000003c2b081b7f33c06","support":1502305000000000}}},"info":{"track":2,"origin":{"origins":"WishForChange"},"proposal":{"lookup":{"hash":"0x16e3d04eecf527a6cf1d4545589209fb5f7c6b26cba8dbf5d224998679e4b5a5","len":462}},"enactment":{"after":100},"submitted":32704445,"submissionDeposit":{"who":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","amount":33333333333},"decisionDeposit":{"who":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","amount":666666666660000},"deciding":{"since":32705645,"confirming":null},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000012edd0c54e1100","nays":"0x000000000000000003c2b081b7f33c06","support":1502305000000000},"inQueue":false,"alarm":[32907245,[32907245,0]]},"tally":{"ayes":"0x00000000000000000012edd0c54e1100","nays":"0x000000000000000003c2b081b7f33c06","support":1502305000000000,"electorate":"17225580087001830725"},"whitelistedHashes":[],"whitelistDispatchedHashes":[],"whitelistedHashesByXcm":[],"remarks":["Any change removing, merging, or eliminating the Kusama Technical Fellowship as an independent on-chain collective shall require a dedicated Wish For Change referendum, approved by Kusama token holders, before implementation. This applies to all mechanisms — including runtime upgrades, whitelisted calls, or governance migration — that would result in Kusama no longer having its own Technical Fellowship distinct from the Polkadot Technical Fellowship."],"isFinal":true,"proposalHash":"0x16e3d04eecf527a6cf1d4545589209fb5f7c6b26cba8dbf5d224998679e4b5a5","treasuryBounties":[],"fellowshipReferenda":[],"isTreasuryV1":false,"electorate":"17225580087001830725","rejected":[32907245,{"who":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","amount":33333333333},{"who":"FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH","amount":666666666660000}],"lastConfirmStartedAt":null},"refToPost":{"postId":"69b997c559479e403a8b2f94","postType":"referendaReferendum","dataSource":"sima","indexer":{"blockHeight":14491014,"blockHash":"0xe88a5be15973a74c787bab05ee95809de20b3319bc8980e520acf02c4649aa71","blockTime":1773770652000,"extrinsicIndex":2,"eventIndex":6},"cid":"bafybeiexvq4f6linktrszeca6gua6ikyzofqwlui2i2edx6j53bf4yuuxi","createdAt":"2026-03-17T18:04:12.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-03-17T18:16:03.060Z","referendumIndex":640,"contentHash":"8b9179f59c01fd6c4f47dd403d22c81a"},"rootPost":{"postId":"69b997c559479e403a8b2f94","postType":"referendaReferendum","authors":["FRiuwJZ4DJKvQXSASkKzYJqd3X9MXdtQ3N6WBWG5jhrcFGH"]},"trackInfo":{"id":2,"name":"wish_for_change","originalName":"wish_for_change\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000\u0000","maxDeciding":10,"decisionDeposit":"666666666660000","preparePeriod":1200,"decisionPeriod":201600,"confirmPeriod":14400,"minEnactmentPeriod":100,"minApproval":{"reciprocal":{"factor":222222224,"xOffset":333333335,"yOffset":333333332}},"minSupport":{"linearDecreasing":{"length":1000000000,"floor":0,"ceil":500000000}}},"author":null,"commentsCount":3}],"total":680,"page":1,"pageSize":40}